top 3000 last 3years running

Started by hawkboy80, February 14, 2014, 02:56:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

hawkboy80

Backs - bartel, mcveigh, d.swallow, suckling, kolodj, l.mcdonald (fuller, clurey)
Mids - gaz, jobe, s.mitchell, d.beams, t.mitchell, daisy, j.martin, x.ellis (dunstan, m.crouch)
Rucks - mcevoy, sandilands, (f.thurlow, m.king)
Fwds - danger, dusty, buddy, zorko, bock, kersten (garlett, impey)

any feedback appreciated, feels a bit light down back but i had to pinch to strenghthen fwds,
i do have flexibility with dpp so that might help me tho ?

Kozij

Even as a Geelong supporter I'm not too sure about Bartel. I'd definitely have Mitchell in your back line. Is Mitchell really M5 worthy? McEvoy is a good POD. Forwards are good. Rate mine?

hawkboy80

unsure about t.mitchell but dpp gives me options & yeah sammi can swing back if req'd thanks

hawkboy80

thoughts on kersten & dunstan anyone

Hippo


Woppa15

Kersten depends on how Geelong choose to structure up I think, could be a week to week prospect depending on their opponent. Mind you they did play Hawkins, pods and Vardy as three talls together up fwd.

Hawkins and Vardy are no brainers but then who lines up alongside them? Kersten, Brown, Walker, Blicavs, McCarthy (probably least likely) and then one of H Mac and Simpson in the ruck.

Haven't seen him myself but from all reports the kid can play, goal kicking accuracy of 73% in 2012 and 76% in 2013. Goalless only once in 2013 and kicked 4 or more goals 6 times.

I think I'm talking myself into yet another Rookie bench option hahaha

KERS


hawkboy80

Backs - bartel, mcveigh, d.swallow, suckling, kolodj, l.mcdonald (fuller, clurey)

Mids - gaz, jobe, s.mitchell, d.beams, t.mitchell, daisy, j.martin, michie, (x.ellis, dunstan)

Rucks - mcevoy, sandilands, (f.thurlow, d.currie)

Fwds - danger, dusty, zorko, caddy, hogan, bock (kersten, garlett)

this feels stronger overall with better bench coverage

Pkbaldy

Quote from: hawkboy80 on February 15, 2014, 10:47:26 AM
Backs - bartel, mcveigh, d.swallow, suckling, kolodj, l.mcdonald (fuller, clurey)

Mids - gaz, jobe, s.mitchell, d.beams, t.mitchell, daisy, j.martin, michie, (x.ellis, dunstan)

Rucks - mcevoy, sandilands, (f.thurlow, d.currie)

Fwds - danger, dusty, zorko, caddy, hogan, bock (kersten, garlett)

this feels stronger overall with better bench coverage

Can you state how much cash you got left over? Because if you got more than 35k i'd upgrade Mitchell to Murphy. Much more proven than Mitchell.... And second year curse could be upon him. Otherwise team looks fine. Not a big fan of Bartel... But not many people have him so could be interesting. I like the McEvoy pick. Miss him already at the Saints. Good luck mate.

hawkboy80

only $1,800 left ...  i like mcevoy cos he'll play every week and should get me 100 each week i think

Pkbaldy

#10
Quote from: hawkboy80 on February 15, 2014, 11:10:36 AM
only $1,800 left ...  i like mcevoy cos he'll play every week and should get me 100 each week i think

Ohhhhh haha. Well I still don't really like the Mitchell pick myself. But your choice sir :P I reckon a player like Bernie Vince could be a nice POD. I wouldn't risk it, because i can afford Murphy! haha...
80-110 each week. He was a TERRIBLE hitter to advantage at the Saints. So if hawks can improve that and get his hitout rate up. He might clock 100 each week.

hawkboy80

fair point about his tap work,maybe i'll rethink the R1

The Pelican

Like Pkbaldy said wouldn't recommend McEvoy.