Rate My Team wanting plenty of input

Started by mike, February 13, 2014, 07:46:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mike

McVeigh. J . Mitchell S . Suckling M . Enright C. Laidler J . Kolodjashnij
(Culter. T . Fuller .M)


Gazza . Pendals . Watson . Fyfe . D. Beams . D Thomas . L. McDonald . C Beams
( L Dunstan . X Ellis )

Nic Nat . B longer ( F .Thurlow . T .Nankavis )

Pavlich . Dangerfield . Dusty.  A Fasolo. G Rohan . D garlett .
( L . Taylor . M honeycrunch )

Was tossing up between Enright and Hanley . Wanting all criticism


Kozij

I think you may be a little light up forward. I like Watson and Fyfe as PODs. Not too sure about Longer at R2 also.

tor01doc

As per usual one line has to be a bit light on.

You seem to have both Rucks and Forwards a bit lacking in depth.

Sandi seems a better bet than Longer at R2.

Hanley v Enright - depends on byes as they are both solid choices.

X Ellis on the bench seems expensive if you're looking to save a few dollars somewhere.

McDonald as mid / def DPP may net be required until later so you could put him to where Laidler is and grab another cheaper mid rookie to free up more cash for a better R2.

Higgins?

hawkboy80

hanley or enright both good options, enright for me tho, agree with prev comments about longer @ R2, seems a bit too risky for mine,overall pretty good place to start

westy501

Looks like a cookie cutter team... find a way to be different from the rest... your fwds are far too weak aswell...
in fact you need to change every line... suckling should be a D5 not a D3... there are cheaper mid rookies who will generate cash quicker. Dunsten is a lock but have him on field. Not sure if nic nat will be ready rd1 and longer is a risk... fasolo rohan garlett aren't good optoions to be on field... fasolo will be fighting for his spot and wont play every week(if not wear the vest in the first few rounds) garlett is a good bench option but not sure how much opportunity he will have in the beginning...