Forward for 250k

Started by #1 Stkilda, February 13, 2014, 04:27:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ben_020285

Personally I don't like Rohan or any of the options that are in the 200 - 250k bracket for forwards.

I just don't think any of them will score enough or make enough cash to warrant selection.

If Mitch Clark was fit and playing round 1 then I would go for him but that's not going to happen.


Ricochet


blues123

nah i reckon not shaun higgins i reckon ben kennedy or bock

Bully

As my wishlist continues to diminish I'm preparing to do the unthinkable and and cut Jaeger Martin from the midfield.

As it stands, Walker & Clark are off the table, which leaves Missy Higgins who is 50/50, Fasolo who not only missed last week but is directly competing with Blair, Kennedy & Jamie Elliott, Rohan who has never been SC relevant in my opinion (flashy yes) and Bock who still may not be ready in time. Ben Kennedy may be an option but job security must also be considered.

So if worse comes to worst, I may call upon the services of Tom Hawkins at F5, leaving a forward line something like this -

Danger, Martin, Franklin, Pavlich, Hawkins, Markworth (Impey, Jay Kennedy-Harris).

To do this sacrifices will need to be made and unfortunately it may entail replacing Jack Martin with one of Michie, Sheed or Cripps. It's a bold move and one I'd prefer not to make but I'd rather have stability in the forward line with a guaranteed best 22 player at F5.






ben_020285

Quote from: Bully on February 14, 2014, 12:36:52 PM
As my wishlist continues to diminish I'm preparing to do the unthinkable and and cut Jaeger Martin from the midfield.

As it stands, Walker & Clark are off the table, which leaves Missy Higgins who is 50/50, Fasolo who not only missed last week but is directly competing with Blair, Kennedy & Jamie Elliott, Rohan who has never been SC relevant in my opinion (flashy yes) and Bock who still may not be ready in time. Ben Kennedy may be an option but job security must also be considered.

So if worse comes to worst, I may call upon the services of Tom Hawkins at F5, leaving a forward line something like this -

Danger, Martin, Franklin, Pavlich, Hawkins, Markworth (Impey, Jay Kennedy-Harris).

To do this sacrifices will need to be made and unfortunately it may entail replacing Jack Martin with one of Michie, Sheed or Cripps. It's a bold move and one I'd prefer not to make but I'd rather have stability in the forward line with a guaranteed best 22 player at F5.

I am starting with 5 players in my forward line that I intend to be keepers. My current F5 is Pavlich.

I just think that there is great value in other areas with players such as Suckling, Daisy and Sandi at discount prices.

I think this is the year to load up in the forward line.

Ricochet

I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

blues123

show me your team ben_020285

GCSkiwi

Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Totally agree. At this point I have Pavlich at F3 then Fasolo, Rohan, Kersten, Impey and Garlett. But if some of my 117-123k rookies don't get up, Pavlich will go, leaving me with an F3-8 made of cash cows... Stack the other lines...

ben_020285


ben_020285

Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Yeah I agree that it is wise to not have many rookies on the field in the backline too. A team with 4 keepers, Suckling and a rookie on the field is the way to go and that is my current setup.

Bully

Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Fasolo, Rohan & Lamb are the only real certainties and they don't strike me as the best F5 & F6 alternatives. I'd be all over Walker if available but he won't be, Higgins is also a bit of a gamble, particularly if he doesn't play any pre season matches. One also needs to consider the logistics of planning for the split round. Will people jump on players in the first week, even it means missing out on their preferred option in the second? 

Ricochet

Quote from: Bully on February 14, 2014, 01:43:39 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Fasolo, Rohan & Lamb are the only real certainties and they don't strike me as the best F5 & F6 alternatives. I'd be all over Walker if available but he won't be, Higgins is also a bit of a gamble, particularly if he doesn't play any pre season matches. One also needs to consider the logistics of planning for the split round. Will people jump on players in the first week, even it means missing out on their preferred option in the second?
Who are better F5 and F6 alternatives?

ben_020285

Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:58:22 PM
Quote from: Bully on February 14, 2014, 01:43:39 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Fasolo, Rohan & Lamb are the only real certainties and they don't strike me as the best F5 & F6 alternatives. I'd be all over Walker if available but he won't be, Higgins is also a bit of a gamble, particularly if he doesn't play any pre season matches. One also needs to consider the logistics of planning for the split round. Will people jump on players in the first week, even it means missing out on their preferred option in the second?
Who are better F5 and F6 alternatives?

I think that finding room for a player around the 430k mark at F5 such as Pav, Gunston or Zorko and playing a rookie at F6 is better than going with 2 of Fasolo, Rohan, Lamb, Higgins etc etc

GCSkiwi

If you're running a 430k player at F5, plus 4 keepers, suckling and a rookie in defense, your midfield must be next to nonexistant... That's basically half your salary cap on 12 players. Still got an entire bench, 8 midfield and 2 ruck spots to fill

Ricochet

Quote from: ben_020285 on February 14, 2014, 02:05:47 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:58:22 PM
Quote from: Bully on February 14, 2014, 01:43:39 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on February 14, 2014, 01:12:08 PM
I'm thinking the opposite. With Fasolo, Higgins, Lamb, Rohan, Clark, Bock, Walker at the prices they are (even though a couple won't be ready round 1) and with limited backline rookie options, I think its the year to load up the backline.

Fasolo, Rohan & Lamb are the only real certainties and they don't strike me as the best F5 & F6 alternatives. I'd be all over Walker if available but he won't be, Higgins is also a bit of a gamble, particularly if he doesn't play any pre season matches. One also needs to consider the logistics of planning for the split round. Will people jump on players in the first week, even it means missing out on their preferred option in the second?
Who are better F5 and F6 alternatives?

I think that finding room for a player around the 430k mark at F5 such as Pav, Gunston or Zorko and playing a rookie at F6 is better than going with 2 of Fasolo, Rohan, Lamb, Higgins etc etc
But you pay for their JS. By bringing in a 430k player you have to downgrade to a rookie elsewhere who would most likely have less JS. We have to basically consider these cheap fwds as rookies and only need a 65-70+ averages from them. Most can push much higher than that