Giants v Swans Preseason Challenge Feb 20th

[SydneyRox]

Sydney Swans        ✔ @sydneyswans
The three outs from the squad of 29 are Craig Bird, Dan Robinson and Aliir Aliir #NABChallenge

Sydney Swans        ✔ @sydneyswans
The teams are in: Jordan Lockyer and Harry Marsh will start as subs for the Swans #goswans #NABChallenge

Bugger, really wanted to see Aliir, and Robinson :(

[BGK]

That first quarter is a little bit of a tease. Mitchell, Parker, Towers, Coniglio and Greene have all been on my watch list this pre season.

[Ricochet]

Conigs is killing it so far

[BGK]

Conigs is killing it so far

3rd year break out? Only thing that puts me off him and Greene is they won't win enough games.

[eaglesman]

i actually thought rohan showed a few good signs early on ... i had completely ruled him out ... but i have seen some life and some chance

[Bones Bombers]

Are Mitchell and Parker going to gather this many possies when the real games start? Looks to me like all the other mids are playing but are they just taking it easy?

I just had a look at the advanced stats and they both have shower disposal efficiency. May not be good enough for SC.

[Nige]

Adam Treloar!  :-*

[Jroo]

Mitchell and Greene are ball magnets.

[Nige]

Derickx is doing a lot better than I thought he would.

[dmac07]

Derickx is doing a lot better than I thought he would.

Showed a bit more than nankervis on tonights performance.


Mitchell and Parker looked good tonight, but jpk, jack, hanneberry, okeefe, mcveigh all under 60sc and didnt seem to press too hard, would imagine all those guys picking up a much bigger share of the points when the real stuff starts.

[Nige]

From what I heard, Naismith was playing second ruck as opposed to Nank, I wonder if they'll change that around next game.

[fidou]

Just got back home from the game. It was fairly lacklustre and Sydney had the game in hand most of the game although GWS did get within a couple of kicks late in the third quarter. A bit of a laugh with everyone trying to sing the GWS song at times. Both Mummy and Giles shared it although Mummy looks right at home. I was impressed with Jed Lamb early. Whitfield and Greene scouted the forward line and worked well. Patton only came on briefly. For Sydney Tommy Mitchell was everywhere, Rhyce Shaw impressed and is cheap. Gary Rohen looked alight.

Had plenty of beer and a good time with a few Carlton mates. Hoorah.

[Ringo]

Final Supercoach scores

SUPERCOACH SCORES

Tom Mitchell 152
Lachie Whitfield 126
Luke Parker 107
Nick Malceski 105
Toby Greene 99
Rhyce Shaw 94
Sam Reid 93
Stephen Coniglio 91
Adam Treloar 89
Nick Haynes 86
Callan Ward 83
Jonathan Giles 82
Ted Richards 80
Harry Cunningham 75
Shane Mumford 75
Tom Scully 74
Tom Derickx 72
Jarrad McVeigh 70
Daniel Hannebery 70
Dylan Shiel 70
Devon Smith 69
Josh Hunt 69
Adam Kennedy 66
Gary Rohan 66
Tomas Bugg 64
Ben McGlynn 64
Josh Kennedy 62
Dylan Addison 61
Adam Tomlinson 59
Nick Smith 59
Jed Lamb 58
Ryan O'Keefe 58
Brandon Jack 56
Sam Naismith 56
Heath Grundy 53
Dean Towers 53
Heath Shaw 48
Rhys Palmer 47
Toby Nankervis 47
Curtly Hampton 45
Jake Lloyd 43
Jeremy Laidler 43
Kieren Jack 42
Phil Davis 42
Jeremy Cameron 39
Dane Rampe 39
Sam Frost 35
Lachlan Plowman 35
Jonathon Patton 18
Jordan Lockyer 5
Matt Buntine 3
Harry Marsh -1

[R.Griffen]

Mitchell bad team bully except for this time he took off while the game was in the balance

[Ringo]

Cut and paste again - now fixed

Would you say Sydney Ruck Order looks like being Pyke, Derickx, Naismith and Nankervis based on last night