Rate my team

Started by Dusto23, February 11, 2014, 11:01:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dusto23

DEF- Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, KK, McDonald (Cutler, Fuller)

MID- Ablett, Pendles, Watson, Murphy, Beams, D Thomas, J Martin, Aish (Dunstan, Honeychurch)

RUCK- Grundy, Sandilands (Nankervis, Thurlow)

FORWARD- Danger, Martin, Franklin, Pav, Rohan, Garlett (Kersten, Taylor)

$6000 left in the cap. I know maybe a premo short in the backline so appreciate any feed back would be great. Cheers

AaronKirk


Def: A premo short here for sure and with Suckling only 50/50 to play round one i'd look to get another premo here

Mid: Maybe strong here, as the better rookies look like they are coming from the midfield i'd look to downgrade Murphy/Thomas to a rookie of your choice.

Ruck: Very risky with 2 mid pricers- do you see either as keepers? if not you should upgrade one to a Nic Nat/Lobbe/Mumford/Ryder

Fwd: Solid forward line here.

WandererzUnited

Not bad does need work done to it though

Here is my advice:

DEF: L.McDonald good choice, not too sure if having both him and KK in the backline makes it look tad week. 6/10

MID: I rate this very strong, If D.Thomas is fit and stays fit your laughing, I have a few players for you to look out for: X.Ellis, D.Tyson or J.Polec. 8/10.

RUCK: just standard, i dont know much about grundy, but sandi if again his fit he will score really high.... maybe you might need to re think the rucks. 6.5/10

FORWARDS: these are very good choices that you have made, however i wouldn