How faulty do you rate Basil's team?

[basil3134]

paris2014 Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by silica80. Salary cap left: $17,300.

Sam Mitchell, Michael Hibberd, Kade Simpson, Matt Suckling, Kade Kolodjashnij, Luke McDonald
Jeremy Laidler, Matthew Fuller

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Jobe Watson, Marc Murphy, , Dayne Beams, Claye Beams, Jared Polec
Dom Sheed Luke Dunstan, Mitch Honeychurch,

Aaron Sandilands, Matthew Lobbe
Fraser Thurlow, Toby Nankervis

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Lance Franklin, Tom Hawkins, Jed Lamb, Gary Rohan
Dayle Garlett, Lewis Taylor

[basil3134]

I think I had a few too many uncertainties  and obscure comments

I welcome comments re Mid  priced forwards eg Hawkins

[dommycala]

I like your defense, enough unique enough players who have proven themselves scorers.

Your midfield is good however i havent heard much on Polec, he is definitley one to watch over the nab challenge but Port havent exactly been fired up by his efforts.

Sandi is a huge risk imo

Hawkins is a smart pick, although still quite risky, i like it, especially if he can get consistent games while fit, he has definite breakout potential while also being a PoD. Not a huge fan of Garlett myself, seems to play the same roles as cryil and hill and alittle bit of smith too, not sure where he will fit into the premiership side, probably will be sub-effected too.

Still a very competitive side, alot still depends on the NAB challenge

[tor01doc]

When counting the genuine 'keepers' I run out after granting keeper status to one of Murphy / Beams.

I count only 10.

Mitchell, Hibberd, Simpson, GAJ, Pendles, Jobe, Danger, Martin, Buddy and one of Beams / Murphy.

A few teams have had 12.

Trades will be tight again and making money difficult with better credentialled rookies starting at a higher price. This means less room to err.

Risky guys like Hawkins, Suckling and Sandi need to be carefully considered.

I would prefer to take Pav and Grundy and $23100 over Hawkins and Lobbe.

Can't see Lobbe or Hawkins being top few in their positions but Pav could and Grundy will make money by just tying up his pony and running out. You'll end up trading both Lobbe and Hawkins out and will not have made a great deal of money.

...in my opinion.

[mpollock]

Hawkins averaged 28 points below his 2012 average so is a bargain really providing his back holds up.

Nice balance in your team and Hibbert is a good POD ...

Looking solid.