Rate My team and I will rate yours!!!

[robbieGTS]

DEF:
J. Bartel, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, L. Mcdonald, M, Fuller [L. Thomson, T. Cutler]
MID:
G. Ablett, S.Pendlebury, T. Cotchin, M. Murphy, D. Beams, S.Savage, V. Michie, L. Dunstan [D. Sheed, L.Taylor]
RUCK:
N. Natinui, P. Ryder [T. Nankervis, M. Apeness]
FWD:
P. Dangerfield, L. Franklin, D.Zorko, J. Lamb, G. Rohan, J. Kennedy- Harris [J. Impey, M. Honeychurch


My team is constantly changing but i think i might keep it this way untill Nab Challenge starts, if Simpson averages 90+ i will be over the moon, my Mid field is staked and my forward line looks locked, Rucks are in a good spot and i dont like any of the mid price rucks up for sale (sandi, Mcintosh, Grundy) all of them are injury prone. Jed Lamb is a gun has a secured spot and is the kind of player GWS need. Shane savage averaged around 90 when he wasnt in the green vest, and i doubt he will be ested at saint kilda

[BigMac93]

Backline a bit weak for mine would only go with 1 rookie on the field. Bartel is set to play forward more this season so not sure he will average what he did last year playing off half back
Midfield is great just be aware Ablett, Pendles and Cotchin all share the same bye round. Personally I would pick Dale Thomas over Savage, he averaged 109 under Malthouse in 2011. If he gets back to that he is a steal.
Dont like Ryder, too inconsistent for mine. Sandilands has had a full pre season compared to the past 3 years where he has not, so he may not be as injury prone this year, but it's your choice.
Forwards look good as long as Zorko dosen't average what he did last year.

Your team is good but I think you should try to get only 1 rookie on the field in defence.

[robbieGTS]

Thanks for the reply mate!

[The Pelican]

DEF:
J. Bartel, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, L. Mcdonald, M, Fuller [L. Thomson, T. Cutler]
MID:
G. Ablett, S.Pendlebury, T. Cotchin, M. Murphy, D. Beams, S.Savage, V. Michie, L. Dunstan [D. Sheed, L.Taylor]
RUCK:
N. Natinui, P. Ryder [T. Nankervis, M. Apeness]
FWD:
P. Dangerfield, L. Franklin, D.Zorko, J. Lamb, G. Rohan, J. Kennedy- Harris [J. Impey, M. Honeychurch

Defenders- A bit weak,should try go Cutler to Kolajashnij or Laidler. Good picks in Simpson and Hanley but I think one should be upgraded to Mitchell or McVeigh. 8/10
Midfielders- Good strong midfield but, where is JMartin. Other then that it is a strong midfield. 9/10
Rucks- I like the selection in Ryder. He'll score well when Bellchambers isn't around. 10/10
Forwards- Good pick in Zorko but I'm not sure about Lamb and Rohan. Maybe try get Fasolo instead.  8/10

35/40 Good strong team


Rate my team here http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,88919.0.html

[Jackross10]

Nice team mate.

Like Hanley and Simpson. Don't know who L Thompson is but I guess wait till after Nab Challenge.
One of the best mids I've seen. Love the pick of Savage, I want him but don't know how.
Great ruck. I also think Ryder will score well early and when nui is fit he is a lock.
I think you are missing Martin, he is going to be top 2-3 forwards come seasons end so I think you should try get him. Zorko looks a good pick but lamb I don't think. He has never tonned in his life, second year blues... He may be worth it but it's a huge risk. I'd try get Fasolo in.

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,89415.0.html

Thanks

[AaronKirk]

Def: Risky Defense- Bartel overpriced IMO- Mitchell and Mcveigh better picks, Hanley will be first tagged at Brisbane so he is also a risk- if you start with Suckling you may need another premium at D3/D4- otherwise upgrade Suckling. 7/10

Mid: 4 premiums have the round 8 bye which is a major concern- need to upgrade Cotchin to a round 10 premo such as Rocky/Watson. Savage is a major risk- reckon Thomas at the price is a stronger pick. 8/10

Rucks: Strong rucks- do you see Ryder as a lock? if so he is a good pick, if not you may need to think about Sandi/Hmac  8.5/10

Fwd: Zorko at M3 is a risk saying he is going to be a lockdown forward and pinch hit in the midfield. Lamb is a good pick. would like to see another premium though for balance. The only real way to do this is to downgrade Ryder to sandi and use the cash in the forwards. 6.5/10

Overall: A bit of work to do here- depends how you want to structure i guess.  30/40