Please Rate my first Cut!

[spuddy9595]

BACKS        McVeigh, Hanley, Birchall, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald, (Cutler, Fuller)

MIDS          Ablett, Pendles, Cotchin, Scott Selwood, Wingard, Beams, Ellis, Dunstan  (O'Rourke, L Taylor)

RUCKS        Lobbe, Sandilands ( Lobb, Nankervis)

FWDS         Danger, Buddy, Gunston, T Walker, Billings, Kennedy-Harris    (Garlett, Honeychurch)


Im not sure about Taylor Walker, if he is fit and ready to go but figured he is cheap after not playing most of last year. I'm also not sure if I should move Hanley to the Mid F so I have a Mid/Def compatible player in both lines to swap for byes etc

Thanks!

[Pkbaldy]

BACKS        McVeigh, Hanley, Birchall, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald, (Cutler, Fuller)

MIDS          Ablett, Pendles, Cotchin, Scott Selwood, Wingard, Beams, Ellis, Dunstan  (O'Rourke, L Taylor)

RUCKS        Lobbe, Sandilands ( Lobb, Nankervis)

FWDS         Danger, Buddy, Gunston, T Walker, Billings, Kennedy-Harris    (Garlett, Honeychurch)


Im not sure about Taylor Walker, if he is fit and ready to go but figured he is cheap after not playing most of last year. I'm also not sure if I should move Hanley to the Mid F so I have a Mid/Def compatible player in both lines to swap for byes etc

Thanks!

Backline: Not too bad here. Pretty standard. I just don't like the idea of having 2 starting rookies in the defence... Scares me a little. And also Birchall, a good POD but can go a bit sour in some games. 7/10

Midfield: Ab/Pen/Cot all good picks. I went Jack Steven myself for 3rd pick. But he's perfectly fine. My 2 worries for you are Scott Selwood and Wingard. Midfielders are the best for cash cows. So can i suggest downgrading 1 of them too Jack Martin/Dom Tyson. And the other to a premium midfielder, or Murphy/Thomas to have some more money to even out other roles. 8.5/10

Rucks: Pretty stock standard for plenty of people. I myself change my mind of having Lobbe. But we will see how he goes Pre-season. And Turf Toe is a massive risk, but he's sooooo damn cheap so I don't blame you! 9.5/10

Forwards: Straight away I notice no Martin? Good risk or not we will find out! But If you really want Wingard in your team i'd pop him in here. Danger/Wingard/Franklin for your premiums would be good. And with that cash you can pop in Gunston and a 200ker that'll improve this year (Fasolo, Rohan, Lamb) and than a rookie. I don't suggest Billings just yet (St. Kilda supporter). So having Danger/Wingard/Franklin/Gunstan/Fasolo/Kennedy-Harris would look pretty nice. If you still have the cash. 7/10

Looks alright over all just a little tweeking around and it'll look awesome! 32/40

[spuddy9595]

Thanks for the info! I actually read that Selwood will be looking at going back to a run with player so I have already got rid of him and brought in Dom Sheed. Will also look at Wingard to the forward line

Thanks!