First year supercoach

[Andrew3737]

Def: Bartel, Mitchell, McVeigh, Kolodshanjijjhdsgdajsdbasdgas, Scharenberg, McDonald (Ladler, Curran)

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Cotchin, Beams, Martin, Tyson, Beams, Polec (Michie, Ellis)

Ruck: Lobbe, McIntosh ( Thurlow, Currie)

Fwd: Dangerfield, Martin, Petrie, Franklin, Bock, Rohan (Garlett, Honeychurch)

First time ever supercoach.

[Regs81]

Team looks good..
Backs: Try to get suckling in there. Sharenburg is injured so wont play early. Not sure if Laidler will be in swans best 22, you could downgrade shareburg to Fuller or Battersby then upgrade Laidler to Suckling.
Mids: Looks good. There is cheaper options than Michie and Ellis for bench options
Rucks: Lobbe good pick. If McIntosh is fit will be a good pick
Forwards: Petrie is a good unique pick, haven't seen him in any teams.  Not sure about Bock and Rohan.  I would rather put Clark in. 
Overall pretty good team. 7.5/10.. good luck mate

[Vinny]

Kolodjashnij **

Cannot play three rookies in defence, there is just no way.

Stay away from Petrie.

Sandi over HMac, might change NAB tho..

Good otherwise.

[GCSkiwi]

Hi andrew

I feel like you must have a bit of spare cash left over? I have a team with a more expensive D4 and D5, M5 and R1 than you at the expense of an F4 - I feel like there is no way that cash matches up??

Agree with Vinny, you cannot play 3 defensive rookies. K.Kolo and McDonald are the only 2 I think are likely to get decent game time, everyone else is a big risk. Fuller maybe?

Prefer Sandi over HMac at similar price, purely because Sandi got back up and was playing AFL by the end of last year, HMac has yet to do so. One to keep an eye on.

Good start, bit of refinement needed.

[Andrew3737]

I have 20k left :S Maybe its the Ablett, Swan, Cotchin


Yeah cheers feelas

[Vinny]

I don't think Bartel is worth his coin this year, I'd trade him to be honest.

[Andrew3737]

Def: Mitchell, McVeigh, Simpson, Suckling, Kolodshanjijjhdsgdajsdbasdgas, McDonald (Ladler, Curran)

Mid: Pendlebury, Watson, Cotchin, Kennedy, Martin, Kelly, Beams, Michie (Ellis, O'Rouke)

Ruck: Lobbe, Sandilands ( Thurlow, Currie)

Fwd: Dangerfield, Martin, Petrie, Franklin, Bock, Rohan (Garlett, Honeychurch)

55k left

[Vinny]

Kennedy > Beams
Kelly > Dunstan
KK/LMac > Swallow.

That's what I'd do. But it's up to you.

[tor01doc]

Would outCotchinGAJ.

Kennedy to D Beams.

Dish Petrie out - ? Wingard

Pretty good.

[Big Mac]

Hi andrew

I feel like you must have a bit of spare cash left over? I have a team with a more expensive D4 and D5, M5 and R1 than you at the expense of an F4 - I feel like there is no way that cash matches up??

Agree with Vinny, you cannot play 3 defensive rookies. K.Kolo and McDonald are the only 2 I think are likely to get decent game time, everyone else is a big risk. Fuller maybe?

Prefer Sandi over HMac at similar price, purely because Sandi got back up and was playing AFL by the end of last year, HMac has yet to do so. One to keep an eye on.

Good start, bit of refinement needed.

He has a lot of expensive rookies. e.g. Michie, Tyson, Martin, Polec, Scharenberg - Although I think he's gotten rid of a few

[GCSkiwi]

Yeah I was looking player by player, I've got most of the expensive rookies and GAJ/Pendles as M1+2, it's funny how the cash surreptitiously disappears.

Def: Mitchell, McVeigh, Simpson, Suckling, Kolodshanjijjhdsgdajsdbasdgas, McDonald (Ladler, Curran)

Mid: Pendlebury, Watson, Cotchin, Kennedy, Martin, Kelly, Beams, Michie (Ellis, O'Rouke)

Ruck: Lobbe, Sandilands ( Thurlow, Currie)

Fwd: Dangerfield, Martin, Petrie, Franklin, Bock, Rohan (Garlett, Honeychurch)

55k left

This team looks better, I'm with doc not being sure on Petrie and don't think Kelly is worth it. JPK could be worth a risk as he's killing preseason supposedly, but he needs to kick more for SC points. Your call.