rate my team

[sandman_88]

Hey guys nutted a quick team out, will obviously tweak after NAB cup just thought id get some feedback

Def: S Mitchell, Handley, Atley, gwilt, suckling, Docherty, laidler, fuller
Mids: Ablett, Pendles, Murphy, Thomas, J Martin, Tyson, L mcdonald,Taylor, Honeychurch, Woodward
Rucks: McEvoy, Longer, Apeness,Currie
Fwds:Danger, franklin, M clark, D Martin, Lamb, Rowan,garlett,menzel.

rem cash:369,800

tried going for a couple off hopefuls (menzel, gwilt, docherty,lamb) and maybes (clark,rohan) will moniter pre season but by all reports they look to step up to the next level,especially in new surroundings.no doubt they may prove me wrong. suckling is a maybe, see how the knee stands up. honeychurch IMO is going to be a steal, put up great stats in TAC and carnival and cheap as chips, will surely get some games at the dogs if he can avoid the vest, but may be another jake neade

anyways start tearing shreds :) cheers guys

[Rated_RKO]

personal opinion only, but i dont like gwilt or tyson, but understand its only a quick team.

also, thought i heard that mitch clark was doubtful for first few weeks.

[AaronKirk]

A lot of risk here but you do have the cash to make changes

Def: A lot of risk with Atley and Gwilt- Should look at one of McVeigh/Simpson and one of Swallow/Grimes- also should probably move McDonald to Defence as the def rookies look thin on the ground this year.

Mids: As above you probably should move McDonald to DEF and bring in Dunstan who at $132k should be one of the first rookies picked. Not sure about Dom Tyson either- Michie/Sheed/Ellis seem to be stronger options.

You need to bring in D.Beams- Need to also get in another premium mid i.e Watson/Rockliff to counter the rd 8 bye.

Rucks: Longer is likely to be the number 2 ruck to Hickey- extra 30k gets Sandilands

Fwd: Forwards are solid- keep an eye on the rookies- not sure about Menzel.

[sandman_88]

i was thinking of michie over tyson will wait and see how nab cup turns out. the past two years ive gone for high risk and its payed off,provided you do your homework, and a bit of luck thrown in. last year was in top 5000, year before 77th, i have mcdonald in the mids to add flexability with DP status, but i agree would be better there.yea clark was a brain fade ::) will sort that out. dunstan is a very good option i agree from what i have heard, but dont know much about him personally so will wait to see him play to make my decision.
Another premium is indeed a great idea, just undecided. beams is a viable option but not sold on him, i dont no why but id lean toward fyfe first....