What do you guys think, cheers *Revised*

[maritz.12]

Thanks for the rating and comments guys
Much appreciated

Def: J.Bartell, P.Hanley, K.Simpson, T.Jonas, S.Morris, K.Kolodjashnij (W.Langford, X,Richards)

Mid: G.Ablett, R.Griffen, N.Fyfe, L.Hodge, D.Thomas, S.Savage, C.Beams, V.Michie (X.Ellis, H.Cunningham)

Ruck: W.Minson, A.Sandilands (T.Downie, B.Brown)

Forward: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, S.Mayes, J.Danniher, L.Tapscott, A.Fasolo (S.Kersten, M.Honeychurch)

Cheers

[johnnytheboy1]

This team is very ordinary it has players who will not score Highly Jonas,Morris,Daniher & Tapscott
Def: Below Average after the first 3 it completely drops away
MIds: Much better here Hodge is a good POD only negative is no Pendles
Rucks: Strong Could downgrade Minson to strengthen other areas on the field
Fwds: Sam mayes is the best of the uniques but not a F3 THIS A WEAK LINE ALSO

I am going to be generous ans give this team a 4.5/10 it could be worse.

[DCAK]

Johnny's right mate, this just won't do.  Go back to your room and don't come out until you're willing to be sensible!

Morris! Pfft!

[willsy13]

Thanks for the rating and comments guys
Much appreciated

Def: J.Bartell, P.Hanley, K.Simpson, T.Jonas, S.Morris, K.Kolodjashnij (W.Langford, X,Richards)

Mid: G.Ablett, R.Griffen, N.Fyfe, L.Hodge, D.Thomas, S.Savage, C.Beams, V.Michie (X.Ellis, H.Cunningham)

Ruck: W.Minson, A.Sandilands (T.Downie, B.Brown)

Forward: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, S.Mayes, J.Danniher, L.Tapscott, A.Fasolo (S.Kersten, M.Honeychurch)

Cheers

If you had salary like 1,000,000 this would be ok.
17/30 players are good picks the rest is a bit crazy!

Look at changing...
Def: Bartel, Morris, Jonas, Langford, Richards
Mid: Hodge, Savage Cunningham
Ruc: Downie, Brown
Fwd: Mayes? Daniher, tappscott...

I'll give you a 5/10 because more than 1/2 your players are good picks

[nick wilkesmann]

clear it... try again man

[maritz.12]

Thanks for the feedback

What do you think of this one??

TEAM 2

DEF: J.Bartell, S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashnij, L.McDonald (W.Langford, X.Richards)

MID: G.Ablett, J.Selwood, J.Watson, D.Beams, S.Mayes, D.Thomas, L.Dunstan, A.Oxley (J.O'Rourke, B.Helbig)

RUCK: C.Dixon, B.Grundy (T.Downie, D.Currie)

FOR: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, J.Caddy, M.Clark, N.Bock (D.Garlett, M.Honeychurch)

Remaining Salary $1700.00

Thanks again guys

[tor01doc]

Good - top 4 defenders / top 4 mids and Daisy / top 3 fwds
OK - rookies but watch NAB and this thread for a few ideas as JS will be crucial - eg Langford??
Poor - Rucks I think / no Pendlebury

May I suggest Dixon as a forward and grab a cheap R/F for R4 and getting a really solid R1 like Goldy / Minson / NicNat or even Sandi?

Mayes doesn't look a popular pick and it is probably for a reason. Maybe get on Martin to free up some cash.

Good luck.

[batt]

This is looking much better.  Oxley is out 6 weeks after getting hurt in the intra-club.

[maritz.12]

Getting closer i think fellas, obviously depending on rookies in NAB cup

TEAM 3

DEF: J.Bartell, S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashnij, L.McDonald (W.Langford, X.Richards)

MID: G.Ablett, J.Selwood, J.Watson, D.Beams, K.Martin, D.Thomas, L.Dunstan, C.Beams (J.O'Rourke, B.Helbig)

RUCK: A.Sandilands, B.Grundy (F.Thurlow, D.Currie)

FOR: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, C.Dixon, M.Clark, N.Bock (D.Garlett, M.Honeychurch)

[The_Captain]

Who the eff is T jonas?? Is he one of the Jonas brothers? Because he cant play football!

[maritz.12]

He's been traded mate, check out the message above your to see the revised team.

[johnnytheboy1]

Team 3 is now looking more competitive and deserves a higher rating the only negative is 2 rookies up back although you are not alone with that set up

Def: The other players on this line are good enough. Hopefully Suckling stands up this year and doesn't get reinjured.
Mids:Better off with Jack Martin than Kyle.
Rucks: Bit Weak here but could pay off.
Fwds: This has great depths can't really go wrong even though the last 2  starters are injury prone.

Team looks good apart from Martin. give it a 7/10

[WandererzUnited]

Your team 3 is looking better. but i would put A.Woodward from hawthorn as a SUB in your midfield and M.Fuller in your backline sub.

Inside word is those two will get a red hot crack this season......

[maritz.12]

Hey guys, thanks for all your feedback, I've taken all your suggestions on board, traded K.Martin for J.Martin freed up some cash to upgrade my ruckman and upgrade a rookie defender to a 2nd year player in T.Hine. Feel free to give more feedback I guess we'll see what the pre season brings
Cheers fellas

TEAM 4

DEF: J.Bartell, S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashnij, T.Hine (M.Fuller, X.Richards)

MID: G.Ablett, J.Selwood, J.Watson, D.Beams, J.Martin, D.Thomas, L.Dunstan, C.Beams (A.Woodward, M.Honeychurch)

RUCK: A.Sandilands, M.Lobbe (F.Thurlow, D.Currie)

FOR: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, C.Dixon, M.Clark, N.Bock (D.Garlett, L.Taylor)

[AaronKirk]

Not convinced about having both Bock and Clark in forwards- Would look to downgrade one of those to Kennedy-Harris, L.Taylor or Impey.

You could then downgrade Hine to McDonald and use cash to upgrade J.Selwood to Pendles

Or you could keep J.Selwood and upgrade Hine to a mid price defender such as Swallow or Grimes.