Roti's Team Rating Thread

[roti]

Bartel, Mitchell, Thompson, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij, Tippet,
Fuller, Cutler

J Selwood, Johnson, Dangerfield, Steven, Beams, , J.Martin, Dunstan, Marsh,
L.Taylor, Honeychurch

Goldstein, Grundy
Nankervis, Thurlow

Harvey, Dusty, Roughead, Franklin, Hogan, JKH,
Gartlett, Markworth

$5,200 remaining


Thanks in advance  ;D

DEF: 3/3 is pretty light on here, won't stack up well with most other defence's going around. 6/10

MID: Unique, think you would need one of Pendles/Gaz in there as a captain option but otherwise sound, prefer Danger in the forwards. 8/10

RUC: Solid. 8/10

FWD: Not sure on Harvey would rather see Danger there and a different mid, but its a good structured line, might be able to find better value than Hogan at that price so keep a look out. 8/10

OVR: 30/40- You have gone unique here, perhaps a little too much, a lot of people are strongly advising against fielding 2 rookies in defence, you're going with 3! Think you need a Pendles/Gaz in there somewhere and Danger is much better utilised in the forward line. Platform to work on heading into NAB cup though.

[roti]

Backs- McVeigh,Mitchell,Hanley,Hurn,Swallow,Suckling (Fuller-McDonald)

Mids- Pendles,murphy,Beams,Thomas,Caddy,Martin,Michie,Garlett (Dunstan-M.Crouch)

Rucks- Grundy,Sandilands (BBrown-Nankervis)

Fwds- Dangerfield,Martin,Wingard,Buddy,Fasolo,Rohan (L.Taylor-Impey)

$17,900 left.

POD= Grundy over Nic Nat to save some coin. Fasolo has looked very good at pre season. Also like what I have been hearing about Hurn at the Eagles.

DEF: Clearly loaded up on the backs here, pretty faultless, don't mind Hurn either. 9.5/10

MID: This is where you get found out because of the backline, only 2 blokes in there you can say for sure are keepers, plus murph who should be. 6.5/10

RUC: Only problem with this is neither of your rucks may end up being in your finished team. 7/10

FWD: Very strong, not sure on Wingard though, maybe get someone a bit cheaper and strengthen those mids. 8/10

OVR: 31/40 - Mids let you down here mate, I would have to look at downgrading either Hurn or Swallow to a rookie, still leaving you with a very strong backline, and maybe Wingard to Gunston/Pav, and use the cash to get another 1 or two mids in to give it some backbone

[roti]

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashnij, L.McDonald (T.Cutler, J.Battersby)

MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Martin, J.Kelly, A.Morabito (J.O'Rourke, M.Crouch)

RUC: H.McIntosh, A.Sandilands (F.Thurlow, T.Nankervis)

FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, J.Gunston, M.Clark, T.Boyd (L.Taylor, D.Garlett)

$108,600 rem.
wondering where to spend the extra....

cheers  ;D

DEF: Pretty standard. 7/10

MID: Very strong first 3, Selwood is in a moonboot though so maybe choose someone else save some more cash. Not sure on Kelly either, maybe do the same. 8.5/10

RUC: In answer to your question about where to spend the cash, here is the first spot, upgrade mcintosh, the other option is to upgrade one of the rookies in defense, not sure I like Hmac, especially as your number 1 ruck. 6.5/10

FWD: Very strong, once again Boyd will not necessarily score well because he is expensive, i'd look around others his price or look to downgrade to a cheaper rookie. 8/10

OVR:  30/40 - A good first ruck would turn this into a really good team, that's where you use the cash and the more you could save

[roti]

DEF: S Mitchell, S Hurn, D Swallow, M Suckling, S Docherty, K Kolodjashnij- L McDonald, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, T Cotchin, D Beams, D Thomas, J Martin, D Tyson, V Michie- D Sheed, L Dunstan
RCK: T Goldstein, N Naitanui- M Apeness, T Nankervis
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, J Caddy, J Hogan, B Lennon, L Taylor- D Garlett, J Impey
$96, 800 remaining
Am going for league wins but want to do well overall as well
Cheers Roti

DEF: Interesting, only one bloke there who you'd be confident of being a top 10 defender but still good depth. 7.5/10

MID: Solid, wish I could fit Cotchin in I am tipping a huge year from him. 8/10

RUC: Very nice.  9/10

FWD: Caddy at F3 isn't going to serve you too well I don't think. Ideally Caddy and Lennon get upgraded and Hogan goes to someone around his price range who will score better.  6/10

OVR: 30.5/40 - Forward line lets you down here but I am sure you know its not strong, the challenge will be strengthening it without taking out of your other lines.

[Jackross10]

DEF: S Mitchell, H Lumumba, K Simpson, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald.   M Fuller, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, M Barlow, M Murphy, D Beams, D Sheed, J Aish, L Dunstan.   J Polec, L Taylor
RCK: N Naitanui, A Sandilands. T Nankervis, F Thurlow
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, J Gunston.   D Garlett, J Impey

7k! Thanks

[roti]

DEF: S Mitchell, H Lumumba, K Simpson, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald.   M Fuller, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, M Barlow, M Murphy, D Beams, D Sheed, J Aish, L Dunstan.   J Polec, L Taylor
RCK: N Naitanui, A Sandilands. T Nankervis, F Thurlow
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, J Gunston.   D Garlett, J Impey

7k! Thanks

DEF: Harry is interesting, any reason for it? Solid line. 7/10

MID: Very nice. 8.5/10

RUC: Good again. 8/10

FWD: Missing some players, assuming its a standard Fasolo/Rook combo or something like that its an 8/10

Solid team bud 31.5/40 - no real weaknesses i can see, defence could be strengthened a little but it's still solid

[Jackross10]

DEF: S Mitchell, H Lumumba, K Simpson, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald.   M Fuller, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, M Barlow, M Murphy, D Beams, D Sheed, J Aish, L Dunstan.   J Polec, L Taylor
RCK: N Naitanui, A Sandilands. T Nankervis, F Thurlow
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, J Gunston.   D Garlett, J Impey

7k! Thanks

DEF: Harry is interesting, any reason for it? Solid line. 7/10

MID: Very nice. 8.5/10

RUC: Good again. 8/10

FWD: Missing some players, assuming its a standard Fasolo/Rook combo or something like that its an 8/10

Solid team bud 31.5/40 - no real weaknesses i can see, defence could be strengthened a little but it's still solid

Sorry mate it's fasolo and Kersten.

Think Harry will be a 90-100 average this year. He can also have 140 games. I think he will get a lot of cheap ball like Shaw did. I think Harry and Marley will increase averages a lot. Just a pod!

[roti]

DEF: S Mitchell, H Lumumba, K Simpson, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald.   M Fuller, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, M Barlow, M Murphy, D Beams, D Sheed, J Aish, L Dunstan.   J Polec, L Taylor
RCK: N Naitanui, A Sandilands. T Nankervis, F Thurlow
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, J Gunston.   D Garlett, J Impey

7k! Thanks

DEF: Harry is interesting, any reason for it? Solid line. 7/10

MID: Very nice. 8.5/10

RUC: Good again. 8/10

FWD: Missing some players, assuming its a standard Fasolo/Rook combo or something like that its an 8/10

Solid team bud 31.5/40 - no real weaknesses i can see, defence could be strengthened a little but it's still solid

Sorry mate it's fasolo and Kersten.

Think Harry will be a 90-100 average this year. He can also have 140 games. I think he will get a lot of cheap ball like Shaw did. I think Harry and Marley will increase averages a lot. Just a pod!

Yeh i don't mind it, apparently was BOG in the practice game today, actually interested in Marley, he might come into contention should something with Suckling go wrong, lot of Collingwood people really like him this year

[Jackross10]

Was Harry BOG?

[roti]

Was Harry BOG?

That's what i hear

[morgs76]

Bartel, Mitchell, Thompson, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij, Tippet,
Fuller, Cutler

J Selwood, Johnson, Dangerfield, Steven, Beams, , J.Martin, Dunstan, Marsh,
L.Taylor, Honeychurch

Goldstein, Grundy
Nankervis, Thurlow

Harvey, Dusty, Roughead, Franklin, Hogan, JKH,
Gartlett, Markworth

$5,200 remaining


Thanks in advance  ;D

DEF: 3/3 is pretty light on here, won't stack up well with most other defence's going around. 6/10

MID: Unique, think you would need one of Pendles/Gaz in there as a captain option but otherwise sound, prefer Danger in the forwards. 8/10

RUC: Solid. 8/10

FWD: Not sure on Harvey would rather see Danger there and a different mid, but its a good structured line, might be able to find better value than Hogan at that price so keep a look out. 8/10

OVR: 30/40- You have gone unique here, perhaps a little too much, a lot of people are strongly advising against fielding 2 rookies in defence, you're going with 3! Think you need a Pendles/Gaz in there somewhere and Danger is much better utilised in the forward line. Platform to work on heading into NAB cup though.

cheers, I'll keep all that in mind

[Corkascrew]

Corkascrew

Defenders

1.McVeigh, J 2.Mitchell, S
3.Hanley, P 4.Suckling, M
5.Kolodjashnij, K 6.McDonald, L

(7.Langdon, T 8.Fuller, M)

Midfielders

9.Ablett, G 10.Pendlebury, S
11.Selwood, S 12.Beams, D
13.Thomas, D 14.Savage, S
15.Martin, J 16.Michie, V

(17.Taylor, L 18.Garlett, D)

Rucks

19.Lobbe, M 20.Sandilands, A

(21.Thurlow, F 22.Nankervis, T)

Forwards

23.Dangerfield, P 24.Martin, D
25.Franklin, L 26.Crameri, S
27.Fasolo, A 28.Rohan, G

(29.Kennedy-Harris, J 30.Honeychurch, M)

[morgs76]

Bartel, Mitchell, Thompson, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij, Tippet,
Fuller, Cutler

J Selwood, Johnson, Dangerfield, Steven, Beams, , J.Martin, Dunstan, Marsh,
L.Taylor, Honeychurch

Goldstein, Grundy
Nankervis, Thurlow

Harvey, Dusty, Roughead, Franklin, Hogan, JKH,
Gartlett, Markworth

$5,200 remaining


Thanks in advance  ;D

DEF: 3/3 is pretty light on here, won't stack up well with most other defence's going around. 6/10

MID: Unique, think you would need one of Pendles/Gaz in there as a captain option but otherwise sound, prefer Danger in the forwards. 8/10

RUC: Solid. 8/10

FWD: Not sure on Harvey would rather see Danger there and a different mid, but its a good structured line, might be able to find better value than Hogan at that price so keep a look out. 8/10

OVR: 30/40- You have gone unique here, perhaps a little too much, a lot of people are strongly advising against fielding 2 rookies in defence, you're going with 3! Think you need a Pendles/Gaz in there somewhere and Danger is much better utilised in the forward line. Platform to work on heading into NAB cup though.

cheers, I'll keep all that in mind

second try :)

Bartel, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, L.McDonald, Tippet
Fuller, Cutler

Ablett, Johnson, Pendles, Beams, Thomas, J.Martin, Gartlett, L Taylor
M Crouch, X Ellis

Goldstein, Grundy
Nankervis, Thurlow

Harvey, Dusty, Danger, Franklin, Kersten, JKH,
Markworth, Honeychurch

[nightwalker_1310au]

Overall strong team and good standouts they say second try is always the best and all criticism is good. Team overall looks strong mate can see you being a good challenge in a league spot rating 36.5/40 can you rate my team http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,89079.0.html

[morgs76]

Overall strong team and good standouts they say second try is always the best and all criticism is good. Team overall looks strong mate can see you being a good challenge in a league spot rating 36.5/40 can you rate my team http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,89079.0.html

looks good, my only concern is the same concern I have every year, Sandilands, cant trust him to not get injured somehow, I know hes cheap but I cant bring myself to name him in my squad as hes burnt me too many times in the past