Roti's Team Rating Thread

[Jackross10]

Mitchell Thompson Simpson Swallow Suckling KK        Cutler Fuller
Ablett Pendles Rocky Murphy Beams Dunstan O'Rourke Crouch.       Gordon Taylor
Naitanui Sandi.      Nankervis Thurlow
Danger Martin Franklin Gray/Gunston JKH Garlett     Impey Kersten.

19k if I get gray. Thanks !

[eaglesman]

Mitchell Houli Henderson Grimes Suckling Kolo (gardiner fuller)

Ablett Fyfe Scottselwood Beams Thomas Martin Ellis Dunstan (honeychurch garlett)

Nic nat sandi (thurlow nankervis)

Dangerfield Martin Dixon Franklin Caddy Taylor (impey kennedy harris)

11k 10/10/10 ... considering dropping martin to michie n going dixon to wingard

what are we thinking mate .. thanks in advance

[roti]

Hi mate, would love to hear your thoughts on my team  :)

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, B.Houli, M.Suckling, K.Kolodashnij, M. Scharenberg (M.Fuller, T.Cutler)

MID: S.Pendlebury, G.Ablett, K.Jack, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Martin, L.Mcdonald  (M.Honeychurch, J.O'Rourke)

RUC: N.Naitanui, A. Sandilands (T.Nankervis, F. Thurlow)

FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, C.Wingard, M.Pavlich, M.Clark, D.Garlett (L.Taylor, J.Impey)

DEF: Solid, Houli good POD. 7/10

MID: Missing a player?? Assuming he is a rookie thats a good solid line. 8/10

RUC: Standard. 8/10

FWD: Nice line, not sure on Wingard would prefer Buddy but going a bit unique isn't a bad thing. 8/10

OVR: 31/40 - Solid team man no complaints from me well done :)

[roti]

Tks again for the thread roti , and tks for your thoughts , debating the Watson to murphy and using the cash elsewhere . . Maybe Mitchell , mcveigh , Hanley , suckling , atley , kk , .......McDonald , fuller
Ablett , pendles , beams , Watson , Thomas , Tyson , michie , x Ellis . .,. . C beams , dunstans
Lobbe , sandi . ... 2 x rookies
Danger , Martin , Franklin , Higgins ( bock , Clark ) , Rohan , Taylor . . . Gartlett , honey church
24k left
Thank you in advance of any advice .

DEF: Interesting with Atley, think he could be a good pickup if he does what many thought he would do last season, certainly capable of scoring well. 7.5/10

MID: Good, solid, dependable. 8/10

RUC: Standard, but good. 8/10

FWD: Lets you down a litt;e here mate, bit light on. if you were to downgrade Watson to Murph i'd use it here, ideally you'd have another keeper where Rohan is. 6.5/10

OVR: 30/40 - Try to get another guy into the forward line and you'll be well on your way

[roti]

Mitchell Thompson Simpson Swallow Suckling KK        Cutler Fuller
Ablett Pendles Rocky Murphy Beams Dunstan O'Rourke Crouch.       Gordon Taylor
Naitanui Sandi.      Nankervis Thurlow
Danger Martin Franklin Gray/Gunston JKH Garlett     Impey Kersten.

19k if I get gray. Thanks !

DEF: Noice, not much else to say.  8/10
MID: Very good indeed with Beams at M5. 8.5/10
RUC: Solid, standard. 8/10
FWD: Would go Gunston mate, your thinking might be to go a little unique, but outside of these forums Gunston will still be pretty unique, has the opportunity to step up and get big numbers, someone has to take the ones Buddy has left behind. Not sure I like two rookies on the field however, not much depth there I don't think at this stage. 7.5/10

OVR: 32/40 - Very good team, would like a little upgrade to a Clark/Fasolo and then you are well and truly ahead of the pack.

[roti]

Mitchell Houli Henderson Grimes Suckling Kolo (gardiner fuller)

Ablett Fyfe Scottselwood Beams Thomas Martin Ellis Dunstan (honeychurch garlett)

Nic nat sandi (thurlow nankervis)

Dangerfield Martin Dixon Franklin Caddy Taylor (impey kennedy harris)

11k 10/10/10 ... considering dropping martin to michie n going dixon to wingard

what are we thinking mate .. thanks in advance

DEF: Bit too unique for my liking, Houli Henderson Grimes could all go one way or the other, what if they all flop? Still good depth in the line with Suckling and KK rounding out the line. 7.5/10

MID: Again would question having both Fyfe and S.Selwood, but if you can justify both go for it. 8/10 (but little bit risky)

RUC: Standard, for once! 8/10

FWD: Its a solid line, not sold on Dixon or Caddy but Dixon should score well if he stays on the park, I am interested to see if Wingard can back it up this year, got a little suspicion he won't so not sure what you should do there, Martin by all reports should be a jet though could be worth the cash. Caddy is due a good scoring year, problem is he hasn't really shown to me that he will have one, he has simply just never scored that well.  8/10

OVR: 31.5/40 - Obviously going unique has allowed you to have really good depth in your squad, but its a little too unique for mine and ultimately if you intend to keep these guys your side won't be as strong as the teams some other guys will finish with. Just food for thought

[Gil Gunderson]

Bartel, Mcveigh, Mitchell, Suckling, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij,
Laidler, Fuller

Ablett, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Beams, Daisy, J.Martin, Michie, Polec
L.Taylor, Morabito

Nic Nat, Lobbe
Currie, Thurlow

Dangerfield, Dusty, Roughead, Hogan, Rohan, Paine
Kersten, Gartlett

$20,900 in the bank! Cheers

[roti]

Bartel, Mcveigh, Mitchell, Suckling, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij,
Laidler, Fuller

Ablett, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Beams, Daisy, J.Martin, Michie, Polec
L.Taylor, Morabito

Nic Nat, Lobbe
Currie, Thurlow

Dangerfield, Dusty, Roughead, Hogan, Rohan, Paine
Kersten, Gartlett

$20,900 in the bank! Cheers

DEF: Pretty standard, not sure two rookies is the way to go, stocks look a little thin there this year. 7/10

MID: Good, Solid line I like it. 8/10

RUC: Good to see a strong lineup here! 9/10

FWD: 3 good premo's, other 3 however I am not convinced by, would like to see Hogan upgraded to a good player and Rohan up to someone in that 200-250k range, not sure where you would find the money for that however so its up to you. 6.5/10

OVR: 30.5/40 - Just need to strengthen that forward line up a little and you will be well on your way

[Gil Gunderson]

Cheers brother

[morgs76]

Bartel, Mitchell, Thompson, L.McDonald, Kolodjasnij, Tippet,
Fuller, Cutler

J Selwood, Johnson, Dangerfield, Steven, Beams, , J.Martin, Dunstan, Marsh,
L.Taylor, Honeychurch

Goldstein, Grundy
Nankervis, Thurlow

Harvey, Dusty, Roughead, Franklin, Hogan, JKH,
Gartlett, Markworth

$5,200 remaining


Thanks in advance  ;D

[Big Mac]

DEF: S. Thompson, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, G. Birchall, M. Suckling, L. Mcdonald (M. Fuller, J. Battersby)
MID: G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, V. Michie, D. Sheed, L. Dunstan (J. O'Rourke, L. Taylor)
RUC: T. Goldstein, N. Naitanui (D. Currie, T. Nankervis)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, A. Fasolo, S. Kersten, D. Garlett (J. Impey, M. Honeychurch)
Only $700 left - Cheers

[skn146]

Backs- McVeigh,Mitchell,Hanley,Hurn,Swallow,Suckling (Fuller-McDonald)

Mids- Pendles,murphy,Beams,Thomas,Caddy,Martin,Michie,Garlett (Dunstan-M.Crouch)

Rucks- Grundy,Sandilands (BBrown-Nankervis)

Fwds- Dangerfield,Martin,Wingard,Buddy,Fasolo,Rohan (L.Taylor-Impey)

$17,900 left.

POD= Grundy over Nic Nat to save some coin. Fasolo has looked very good at pre season. Also like what I have been hearing about Hurn at the Eagles.

[joelbow]

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashnij, L.McDonald (T.Cutler, J.Battersby)

MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Martin, J.Kelly, A.Morabito (J.O'Rourke, M.Crouch)

RUC: H.McIntosh, A.Sandilands (F.Thurlow, T.Nankervis)

FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, J.Gunston, M.Clark, T.Boyd (L.Taylor, D.Garlett)

$108,600 rem.
wondering where to spend the extra....

cheers  ;D

[CarlTom]

DEF: S Mitchell, S Hurn, D Swallow, M Suckling, S Docherty, K Kolodjashnij- L McDonald, J Laidler
MID: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, T Cotchin, D Beams, D Thomas, J Martin, D Tyson, V Michie- D Sheed, L Dunstan
RCK: T Goldstein, N Naitanui- M Apeness, T Nankervis
FWD: P Dangerfield, D Martin, J Caddy, J Hogan, B Lennon, L Taylor- D Garlett, J Impey
$96, 800 remaining
Am going for league wins but want to do well overall as well
Cheers Roti

[roti]

DEF: S. Thompson, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, G. Birchall, M. Suckling, L. Mcdonald (M. Fuller, J. Battersby)
MID: G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, V. Michie, D. Sheed, L. Dunstan (J. O'Rourke, L. Taylor)
RUC: T. Goldstein, N. Naitanui (D. Currie, T. Nankervis)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, A. Fasolo, S. Kersten, D. Garlett (J. Impey, M. Honeychurch)
Only $700 left - Cheers

DEF: Strong mate with 4 keepers plus suckling, good work. 8.5/10

MID: Very nice again. 8/10

RUC: Very strong yet again, starting with two guns in the ruck is a luxury i wish i could afford. 9/10

FWD: Obviously weakened at the expense of your other lines, could be dangerous playing two rookies plus fasolo 6.5/10

OVR: 32/40 quite a strong team, I think possibly downgrading nicnat if hes not quite right to Sandi and getting another forward in would give you a very strong lineup.