Roti's Team Rating Thread

[benno123]

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Lobbe, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$3K

Cheers roti, your thoughts would be great :)

[codman]

Hey here's my team let me know what everyone thinks

Def: Bartel(MID), Mitchell(MID), hibberd, suckling, kolodashnij.k, Langdon(MID)
Res: fuller, cutler

Mid: ablett, j.Steven, rockliff(FWD), Murphy, d.beams, j.martin, billings(FWD), McDonald(DEF)
Res: garlett(FWD), honey church(FWD)

Ruck: lobbe, sandilands
Res: b.brown(FWD), nankervis

Fwd: Dangerfield(MID), wingard(MID), martin(MID), zorko(MID), Boyd, kersten
Res: apeness(RUC), impey

$22.500 remaining
Let me know what u think

[Jay]

Would love a rate thanks man :) got 28k left in the kitty...

[roti]

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Lobbe, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$3K

DEF: Solid, just watch starting too rookies but that will become more clear. 7/10

MID: Same setup as me which sadly seems to be getting quite popular, for a reason though I suppose. 8/10

RUC: good, Standard. 8/10

FWD: Excellent line without weakening the rest of your team, can't get much better then that really. 9.5/10

OVR: 32.5/40 - Really good team, almost a complete forward line while keeping the rest of your team quite strong well done

Cheers roti, your thoughts would be great :)

[roti]

Hey here's my team let me know what everyone thinks

Def: Bartel(MID), Mitchell(MID), hibberd, suckling, kolodashnij.k, Langdon(MID)
Res: fuller, cutler

Mid: ablett, j.Steven, rockliff(FWD), Murphy, d.beams, j.martin, billings(FWD), McDonald(DEF)
Res: garlett(FWD), honey church(FWD)

Ruck: lobbe, sandilands
Res: b.brown(FWD), nankervis


Fwd: Dangerfield(MID), wingard(MID), martin(MID), zorko(MID), Boyd, kersten
Res: apeness(RUC), impey

$22.500 remaining
Let me know what u think

DEF: Solid, similar to others and my comments stay the same. 7/10

MID: Strong here with beams at D5, would be wary of Billings think there are better options then him, ditto would put McDonald in defence wouldn't stress about DPP in your starting team you can trade that in. 8.5/10

RUC: Standard. 8/10

FWD: Again good line, you might be able to get better options then Boyd at that price so watch closely during nab. 8/10

OVR: 31.5/40 really solid side not much to criticise at all man well done

[roti]

Would love a rate thanks man :) got 28k left in the kitty...

DEF: Best structure in my mind, very solid. 8/10

MID: Few teams popping up with this midfield now, which has been mine for a while and doesn't seem to be very unique anymore! It's good though you are exploiting the value here along with two guns. 8/10

RUC: Standard but good. 8/10

FWD: Again I think you have nailed the structure so props to you for that, another good line. 8/10

OVR: 32/40 - First team I think that has scored an 8/10 for each line, really well balanced side man well done

[benno123]

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Lobbe, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$3K

DEF: Solid, just watch starting too rookies but that will become more clear. 7/10

MID: Same setup as me which sadly seems to be getting quite popular, for a reason though I suppose. 8/10

RUC: good, Standard. 8/10

FWD: Excellent line without weakening the rest of your team, can't get much better then that really. 9.5/10

OVR: 32.5/40 - Really good team, almost a complete forward line while keeping the rest of your team quite strong well done

Cheers roti, really appreciate it :) what are your thoughts on Pendles, Murphy, Lobbe out for Nic Nat, Cotchin, Fyfe? Do you think it would improve my side at all? Would look like....

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, Laidler (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Fyfe, Cotchin, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Naitanui, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$2,900

[roti]

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Lobbe, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$3K

DEF: Solid, just watch starting too rookies but that will become more clear. 7/10

MID: Same setup as me which sadly seems to be getting quite popular, for a reason though I suppose. 8/10

RUC: good, Standard. 8/10

FWD: Excellent line without weakening the rest of your team, can't get much better then that really. 9.5/10

OVR: 32.5/40 - Really good team, almost a complete forward line while keeping the rest of your team quite strong well done

Cheers roti, really appreciate it :) what are your thoughts on Pendles, Murphy, Lobbe out for Nic Nat, Cotchin, Fyfe? Do you think it would improve my side at all? Would look like....

Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Thompson, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, Laidler (Gardiner, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Fyfe, Cotchin, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan (Acres, Garlett)

Rucks: Naitanui, Sanilands (Thurlow, Nankervis)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Martin, Roughead, Franklin, Pavlich, Kersten (Taylor, Kennedy-Harris)

$2,900

I wouldn't do it at this stage mate, its more risky and I honestly don't think you'd gain too much from it, if they all have good years I think they will actually average pretty much the same.

Lobbe (100), Pendles (125), Murphy (110) = 135

NicNat (110), Cotchin (115), Fyfe (110) = 135

Lobbe and co. are probably safer and they could well score more anyway

[codman]

Hey here's my team let me know what everyone thinks

Def: Bartel(MID), Mitchell(MID), hibberd, suckling, kolodashnij.k, Langdon(MID)
Res: fuller, cutler

Mid: ablett, j.Steven, rockliff(FWD), Murphy, d.beams, j.martin, billings(FWD), McDonald(DEF)
Res: garlett(FWD), honey church(FWD)

Ruck: lobbe, sandilands
Res: b.brown(FWD), nankervis


Fwd: Dangerfield(MID), wingard(MID), martin(MID), zorko(MID), Boyd, kersten
Res: apeness(RUC), impey

$22.500 remaining
Let me know what u think

DEF: Solid, similar to others and my comments stay the same. 7/10

MID: Strong here with beams at D5, would be wary of Billings think there are better options then him, ditto would put McDonald in defence wouldn't stress about DPP in your starting team you can trade that in. 8.5/10

RUC: Standard. 8/10

FWD: Again good line, you might be able to get better options then Boyd at that price so watch closely during nab. 8/10

OVR: 31.5/40 really solid side not much to criticise at all man well done

Thanks for the advice and the rate I've made some changes

Def: Bartel, Mitchell, Grimes, Suckling, Sharenberg, Laidler
Res: Cutler, Fuller

Mid: Ablett, Steven, Rockliff, Murphy, Beams, Savage, Martin, X.Ellis
Res: Honeychurch, Garlett

Ruc: Natanui, Sandilands
Res: Thurlow, Nankervis

Fwd: Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Pavlich, D.Menzel, Kersten
Res: L.Taylor, Impey

2,900 rem

[King01]

Backline: Bartel, Mitchell, S.D Thompson, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Tippet, Fuller)
Mid: Pendulbury, J. Selwood, P.Dangerfield, T.Cotchin, D. Beams, J.Martin, J.Kelly, D.Sheed (J.Cripps, D.Garlett)
Ruck: Goldstein, B.Longer (D.Currie, F.Thurlow)
Forwards: Franklin, J. Kennedy, T.Hawkins, T.Walker, T.Boyd, J.Hogan (G.Rohan, B.Lennon)

[willsy13]

Hey roti I'm back, few changes...

Laidler to Cutler
Polec to crouch
J.martin to Thomas



Def: S.Mitchell, P.Hanley, K.Simpson, D.Swallow, M.Suckling, L.McDonald (M.Fuller, T.Cutler)
Mid: S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, T.Cotchin, D.Beams, D.Thomas, D.Tyson, V.Michie, L.Dunstan (J.O'Rourke, M.Crouch)
Ruc: S.Mumford, A.Sandilands (F.Thurlow, T.Nankervis)
Fwd: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, L.Parker, T.Menzel, L.Taylor (S.Kersten, D.Garlett)
$6,900

Cheers

[roti]

Hey here's my team let me know what everyone thinks

Def: Bartel(MID), Mitchell(MID), hibberd, suckling, kolodashnij.k, Langdon(MID)
Res: fuller, cutler

Mid: ablett, j.Steven, rockliff(FWD), Murphy, d.beams, j.martin, billings(FWD), McDonald(DEF)
Res: garlett(FWD), honey church(FWD)

Ruck: lobbe, sandilands
Res: b.brown(FWD), nankervis


Fwd: Dangerfield(MID), wingard(MID), martin(MID), zorko(MID), Boyd, kersten
Res: apeness(RUC), impey

$22.500 remaining
Let me know what u think

DEF: Solid, similar to others and my comments stay the same. 7/10

MID: Strong here with beams at D5, would be wary of Billings think there are better options then him, ditto would put McDonald in defence wouldn't stress about DPP in your starting team you can trade that in. 8.5/10

RUC: Standard. 8/10

FWD: Again good line, you might be able to get better options then Boyd at that price so watch closely during nab. 8/10

OVR: 31.5/40 really solid side not much to criticise at all man well done

Thanks for the advice and the rate I've made some changes

Def: Bartel, Mitchell, Grimes, Suckling, Sharenberg, Laidler
Res: Cutler, Fuller

Mid: Ablett, Steven, Rockliff, Murphy, Beams, Savage, Martin, X.Ellis
Res: Honeychurch, Garlett

Ruc: Natanui, Sandilands
Res: Thurlow, Nankervis

Fwd: Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Pavlich, D.Menzel, Kersten
Res: L.Taylor, Impey

2,900 rem

Its good mate,
DEF: 7/10
MID: 9/10
RUC: 8/10
FWD: 8/10

OVR: 32/40 well done

[roti]

Backline: Bartel, Mitchell, S.D Thompson, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Tippet, Fuller)
Mid: Pendulbury, J. Selwood, P.Dangerfield, T.Cotchin, D. Beams, J.Martin, J.Kelly, D.Sheed (J.Cripps, D.Garlett)
Ruck: Goldstein, B.Longer (D.Currie, F.Thurlow)
Forwards: Franklin, J. Kennedy, T.Hawkins, T.Walker, T.Boyd, J.Hogan (G.Rohan, B.Lennon)

DEF: Pretty standard, no problems just watch the rookies. 7/10

MID: Solid mate with beams at M5 and your rookies, watch Kelly there might be better value there, ditto Sheed. 8.5/10

RUC: Would prefer to see Sandi there for Longer, not sure Longer is the saints #1 ruck could be behind Hickey. 7/10

FWD: Don't like this line mate, missing Danger and Dusty who are the must haves although I am aware youve got danger, and i would have question marks about all your other picks. 6/10

OVR: 28.5/40 - Team needs some work mate, i'd look to get Sandi in for Longer and then find the cash to upgrade Kennedy, Hawkins and if possible Walker to true keepers, Would bring Danger into the forwards for Walker, who then can become Daisy in your mids. Then fiddle around with your rookies, C.Beams, Michie Dunstan all worth a look in the mids, get rid of Lennon for a cheapy and you should be able to upgrade Kennedy and Hawkins. Best of luck

[Bachar14]

Hi mate, would love to hear your thoughts on my team  :)

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, B.Houli, M.Suckling, K.Kolodashnij, M. Scharenberg (M.Fuller, T.Cutler)

MID: S.Pendlebury, G.Ablett, K.Jack, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Martin, L.Mcdonald  (M.Honeychurch, J.O'Rourke)

RUC: N.Naitanui, A. Sandilands (T.Nankervis, F. Thurlow)

FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, C.Wingard, M.Pavlich, M.Clark, D.Garlett (L.Taylor, J.Impey)

[vmac66]

Tks again for the thread roti , and tks for your thoughts , debating the Watson to murphy and using the cash elsewhere . . Maybe Mitchell , mcveigh , Hanley , suckling , atley , kk , .......McDonald , fuller
Ablett , pendles , beams , Watson , Thomas , Tyson , michie , x Ellis . .,. . C beams , dunstans
Lobbe , sandi . ... 2 x rookies
Danger , Martin , Franklin , Higgins ( bock , Clark ) , Rohan , Taylor . . . Gartlett , honey church
24k left
Thank you in advance of any advice .