Master Q's Team Rating Thread - Post your teams and I will rate them!

[Master Q]

Cash: $160,800.

Backs: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, D. Swallow, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg. Emg: J. Laidler, S. Docherty.
Mids: G. Ablett, R. Griffin, J. Watson, N. Fyfe, D. Thomas, J. Martin, L. McDonald, L. Dunstan. Emg: D. Tyson, V. Michie.
Rucks: B. Grundy, A. Sandilands. Emg. J. Osborn, D. Currie.
Fwds: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Parker, M. Clarke, P. Karnezis, D. Garlett. Emg: D. Towers, M. Honeychurch.

DEF: Solid.
MOD: Griffin is interesting. Downgrade Martin. McDonald is a lock, but for the backline.
RUC: Grundy is a big no no in my opinion. Lacks experience, second season, No.1 ruck spot doesn't make up for that.
FWD: Parker and Karni, better options.

[Master Q]

How about this?


DEFENDERS
M. FullerWBD

$151,800
DEF
0
0
VCI
J. BartelGEE

$514,900
DEF, MID
0
95
VCI
S. MitchellHAW

$517,700
DEF, MID
0
95.52
VCI
K. SimpsonCAR

$461,900
DEF
0
85.23
VCI
J. McVeighSYD

$529,900
DEF, MID
0
97.77
VCI
M. SucklingHAW

$314,400
DEF
0
0
VCI
S. EdwardsESS

$170,900
DEF
0
41.5
I
C. HowardWBD

$135,500
DEF
0
31
I
MIDFIELDERS
G. AblettGCS

$621,200
MID
0
114.62
VCI
D. SheedWCE

$235,800
MID
0
0
VCI
S. SelwoodWCE

$587,500
MID
0
108.39
VCI
T. RockliffBRL

$558,800
MID
0
103.1
VCI
V. MichieMEL

$193,900
MID
0
49
VCI
C. BeamsBRL

$187,400
MID
0
45.5
VCI
D. BeamsCOL

$498,800
MID
0
101.14
VCI
D. ThomasCAR

$346,400
MID
0
75.2
VCI
M. HoneychurchWBD

$135,500
FWD, MID
0
0
I
J. PolecPTA

$135,500
MID
0
31
I
RUCKS
S. MumfordGWS

$423,000
RUC
0
78.05
VCI
A. SandilandsFRE

$244,500
RUC
0
49.57
VCI
D. CurrieNTH

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
L. LowdenHAW

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
FORWARDS
D. MartinRIC

$526,000
FWD, MID
0
97.05
VCI
L. FranklinSYD

$426,500
FWD
0
78.68
VCI
P. DangerfieldADE

$534,700
FWD, MID
0
98.5
VCI
M. ClarkMEL

$213,300
FWD
0
48
VCI
G. RohanSYD

$138,400
FWD
0
32.33
VCI
N. RiewoldtSTK

$559,000
FWD
0
103.14
VCI
S. KerstenGEE

$115,200
FWD
0
0
I
N. BockGCS

$135,900
FWD
0
33
I

That is very tough to read. Quick skim looks good though.

[Master Q]

What are your thoughts on this team (got 20,100 in the kitty)



any feedback will be great thanks :)

Ellis, Martin and Zorko are the only guys I'd look at trading out! Otherwise nice team  :) (And Swallow if you can)

[Master Q]

Salary cap left: $600

Jarrad McVeigh, Pearce Hanley, Grant Birchall, Matt Suckling, Luke McDonald, Kade Kolodjashnij
Matthew Fuller, Sam Docherty

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Selwood, Michael Barlow, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Dale Thomas, Dom Tyson, Luke Dunstan
Jono O'Rourke, Claye Beams

Nic Naitanui, Aaron Sandilands
Fraser Thurlow, Sam Naismith

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Lance Franklin, Charlie Dixon, Mitchell Clark, Lewis Taylor
Gary Rohan, Mitch Honeychurch

Thurlow is a R/F so Dixon can cover for Sandi if he takes a week off. I am really not a fan of Docherty so if you can see an alternative to him I'm all ears!

DEF: Looks a little weak to me. Laidler is a bargain instead of Dochers
MID: Barlow  :-\
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Lots of hype surronding Dixon but I'm not so sure about him.

[Master Q]

Team name FRENCHBREAD

Backs - McVeigh, Mitchell, Bartel, D Swallow, Suckling, R Shaw ( Fuller, Laidler )

Mids - Ablett, Watson, Beams, Cotchin, Pendlebury,D Thomas, Morabito, C Beams ( x Ellis, Honeychurch )

Rucks - Dixon, Sandilands ( Longer, Currie )

Forwards - Dangerfield, Zorko, Chapman, Franklin, M Clarke, fasolo ( rohan, B Brown )

$12,400 cash left over ....

DEF: No to Shaw
MID: Very strong
RUC: Dixon is ok in the Forwards, bad pick in Rucks IMO.
FWD: Not sure about Zorko and Fasolo. Otherwise, very nice.

[Master Q]

DEF: S. Mitchell, G. Ibbotson, M. Hibberd, D. Swallow, M. Suckling, C. Sutcliffe (M. Fuller, Laidler)
MID: J. Watson, T. Cotchin, D. Beams, M. Murphy, B. Ellis, S. Savage, D. Thomas, V. Michie (C. Beams, J. Polec)
RUC: A. Sandilands, N. Naitanui (B. Longer, D. Currie)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, J. Winderlich\C. Sylvia, J. Lamb, M. Clark (D. Garlett, N. Bock)

Happy with my team except for my 4th forward. I have 521k to spend so happy to hear any recomendations.

DEF: Very weak backline. You need to upgrade your D2 & 3.
MID: Again think this is pretty weak. Watson isn't good enough to be your No.1 mid, not a fan of Ellis and Savage too.
RUC: Nice
FWD: Don't like Winderlich or Sylvia. Don't know a lot about Lamb.

[robbo]

This is just a first draft, would appreciate any help.

D: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, J.Adcock, D.Swallow, M.Suckling, L.McDonald (Z.Jones, C.Howard)
M: S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Martin, D.Tyson, V.Michie, C.Beams (D.Sheed, J.Billings)
R: N.Natanui, A.Sandilands (B.Longer, T.Derickx)
F: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin, P.Karnezis, A.Fasolo, M.Clark (B.Lennon, J.Hogan)

Cash: $23,100

Not sure whether to go Joel Selwood or Scott Selwood

[Chrisso1]

Not sure whether to go Joel Selwood or Scott Selwood

Scott for sure.

Jel just had surgery on his foot or something. Riskier option.

[Mavro88]

How about this?


DEFENDERS
M. FullerWBD

$151,800
DEF
0
0
VCI
J. BartelGEE

$514,900
DEF, MID
0
95
VCI
S. MitchellHAW

$517,700
DEF, MID
0
95.52
VCI
K. SimpsonCAR

$461,900
DEF
0
85.23
VCI
J. McVeighSYD

$529,900
DEF, MID
0
97.77
VCI
M. SucklingHAW

$314,400
DEF
0
0
VCI
S. EdwardsESS

$170,900
DEF
0
41.5
I
C. HowardWBD

$135,500
DEF
0
31
I
MIDFIELDERS
G. AblettGCS

$621,200
MID
0
114.62
VCI
D. SheedWCE

$235,800
MID
0
0
VCI
S. SelwoodWCE

$587,500
MID
0
108.39
VCI
T. RockliffBRL

$558,800
MID
0
103.1
VCI
V. MichieMEL

$193,900
MID
0
49
VCI
C. BeamsBRL

$187,400
MID
0
45.5
VCI
D. BeamsCOL

$498,800
MID
0
101.14
VCI
D. ThomasCAR

$346,400
MID
0
75.2
VCI
M. HoneychurchWBD

$135,500
FWD, MID
0
0
I
J. PolecPTA

$135,500
MID
0
31
I
RUCKS
S. MumfordGWS

$423,000
RUC
0
78.05
VCI
A. SandilandsFRE

$244,500
RUC
0
49.57
VCI
D. CurrieNTH

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
L. LowdenHAW

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
FORWARDS
D. MartinRIC

$526,000
FWD, MID
0
97.05
VCI
L. FranklinSYD

$426,500
FWD
0
78.68
VCI
P. DangerfieldADE

$534,700
FWD, MID
0
98.5
VCI
M. ClarkMEL

$213,300
FWD
0
48
VCI
G. RohanSYD

$138,400
FWD
0
32.33
VCI
N. RiewoldtSTK

$559,000
FWD
0
103.14
VCI
S. KerstenGEE

$115,200
FWD
0
0
I
N. BockGCS

$135,900
FWD
0
33
I

That is very tough to read. Quick skim looks good though.



Looks good... dunno bout sam mitchel have feeling he will get tagged hard. Shane kerston I think I read somewhere he wont play till late in season..
Overall solid..

[Mavro88]

BACKS .. McVeigh  Bartel   Hanley
                Suckling  kkolo     Mcdonald    S:fuller  laidler

MIDS.. Pendles Sselwood Rockliff Fyfe
            Dbeams Dthomas Cbeams Vmichie S: Jpolec  Orourke

RUCK ... Lobbe Sandi  S: Longer currie

FORWARD... Riewoldt Danger Roughead
                       Zorko  M clark Grohan       S: Jtayler Bock
25k left.... any thoughts?

[paully3112]

Def: J.McVeigh S.Mitchell J.Adcock M.Suckling K.Kolodjashnij M.Scharenberg ( J.Laidler M.Fuller )
Mid: D.Swan S.Pendlebury T.Rockliff D.Beams D.Thomas V.Michie J.Kelly C.Beams ( B.Ah Chee M.Crouch )
Ruc: S.Mumford A.Sandilands ( D.Currie T.Nankervis )
Fwd: P.Dangerfield D.Martin J.Roughead L.Franklin M.Clark N.Bock ( J.Hogan M.Honeychurch )
Salary Cap Remaining: $500

[Jcrew]

Def- mcveigh, mullet, suckling, k.kolodjashnij, Simpson, vlastuin (bews,fuller)
Mid- ablett, pendlebury, Martin, d.beams, sheed, aish, r.griffin,  c.beams (o'rourke, X.ellis)
Ruck- Minson, Grundy (naismith, thurlow)
Forwards-  dangerfield, roughead, Franklin, Dwyer, varcoe, wingard. (Bock,kersten)

Not great, would love some advice!

[MaxyT]

Backline
Ibbotson, Enright, Walker, Suckling, Koladashnij,Swallow (Laidler,LRT)

Mid
Ablett, Pendlebury, Johnson, Martin,Rich, Beams, Thomas, Tyson (C Beams, Blease)

Rucks
Mcintosh, Sandilands (Currie, Longer)

Forwards
Dangerfield, Martin, Clark, Walker, Hogan, Pavlich (Bock, Rohan)

thoughts?

[Buddysbuddy]

DEF-j mcveigh , m suckling , s Mitchell , p Hanley , k kolo, k Simpson ( laidler c Howard )
MID - d swan , s selwood , t rockliff , d beams , d Thomas , v michie c beams , j Watson ( j polec , cairan sheehan )
RUC -m lobbe a sandilsnds ( d currie f thurlow )
FWD - p danger field , d Martin , p chapman , l franklin , g Rohan , m Clark ( s kersten , m Duffy )
Not sure about Kk or l McDonald in the back line might see how they perform in NAB cup
is Watson the best option for the money or anyone better I?

[R.Griffen]

Defenders: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, A. Walker , D. Swallow, M. Suckling (K. Aylett, C. Howard)
Midfielders: D. Swan, G. Ablett, D. Beams, M. Murphy, D. Thomas, J. Martin, X. Ellis, C. Beams (J. Polec, M. Honeychurch)
Ruckman: S. Mumford, A. Sandilands (B. Longer, D. Currie)
Forwards: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, L. Parker, M. Clark, A. Fasolo (G. Rohan, N. Bock)
Cash: $8,300