Master Q's Team Rating Thread - Post your teams and I will rate them!

[Master Q]

Backs : mcveigh ibbotson hanley grimes suckling k.kolo Lmcdonald S: m fuller a georgiou

Mid : griffen jselwood nfyfe cotchin dbeams savage jmartin cbeams S: jpolec  j orourke

Ruck : b mcevoy   hmcintosh  S: blonger d currie

Forwards: dangerfield roughy zorko chapman caddy mclark S: d garlett mhoneychurch
3k left

DEF: Don' think Grimes is a good pick.
MID: Unique but lacks star power. Better options than Griffen, Jelwood is coming off a pre-season injury too. No Daisy is an issue, don't think Savage and Martin are good picks either.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Roughy/Zorko/Caddy together is a risk. I'd get rid of one or two and get in some safer players.

[Master Q]

Cash $21,600

Back: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, J. Bartell, M. Hibberd, M. Suckling, M. Fuller (J. Battersby, C. Howard)
Mid: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, D. Tyson, V. Michie, C. Beams (X. Ellis, J. Polec)
Ruc: W. Minson, A. Sandilands (B. Longer, F. Thurlow)
Fwd: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, N. Reiwoldt, L. Franklin, M. Clark, G. Rohan (D. Garlett, S. Kersten)

I am a big fan of that team! Only thing I could suggest is replacing Hibberd with someone else, Simpson perhaps?

[Master Q]

DEF: McVeigh, Mitchell, Hanley, H.Shaw, Suckling, R.Shaw (Laidler, Bews)

MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff, Cotchin, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis (Polec, O'Rourke)

RUC: Lobbe, Sandilands (Currie, Lowden)

FWD: Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Clark, Karnezis (Bock, Kersten)

$5,500

DEF: Get rid of the Shaws
MID: Nice
RUC: Solid
FWD: No complaints, Karnezis is a risk though.

Good team buddy.

[Master Q]

Defence: McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, Suckling, KK, McDonald (Clurey, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendles, S Selwood, Jack, Murphy, Thomas, Sheed, Tyson (Newton, Ellis)

Rucks: Goldstein, Sandi

Forward: Danger, Riewoldt, Wingard, Caddy, Clark, Bock (Kersten, Rohan)

Cash: $15,600

DEF: No complaints
MID: I'd get in Michie instead of Tyson. Don't know a lot about Sheed. Better options than Jack as well.
RUC: Good starters, need a bench though  ;)
FWD: Wingard is ok, Caddy too.

[Master Q]

DEF mcveigh, suckling,s mitchelk,p hanley , l mcdonald, h shaw ( C howard J kelly )
MID D swan, S selwood , T rockliff , D beams, D thomas , V michie, C beams , P chapman (X Ellis J Polec )
RUC M Lobbe , A sandilands S (D currie F thurlow)
FWD P dangerfield D martin M pavlich L franklin J Daniher J patton S (Rohan D garlett)
Tried to have some POD with shaw and patton
still undecided about chapman
$4,900 left

DEF: Don't like Shaw
MID: Chappy is only a good FWD pick IMO.
RUC: Solid
FWD: Not sure on Pav. Daniher and Patton are young KPPs so don't think they are very good picks.

[Jazzoskies]

Cash $21,600

Back: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, J. Bartell, M. Hibberd, M. Suckling, M. Fuller (J. Battersby, C. Howard)
Mid: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, D. Tyson, V. Michie, C. Beams (X. Ellis, J. Polec)
Ruc: W. Minson, A. Sandilands (B. Longer, F. Thurlow)
Fwd: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, N. Reiwoldt, L. Franklin, M. Clark, G. Rohan (D. Garlett, S. Kersten)

I am a big fan of that team! Only thing I could suggest is replacing Hibberd with someone else, Simpson perhaps?

Thanks :D At the moment I have replaced Hibberd with Houli as his finish to last season was very promising. Of course it will all be subject to change before the season begins

[Brumby]

Cash: $160,800.

Backs: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, D. Swallow, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg. Emg: J. Laidler, S. Docherty.
Mids: G. Ablett, R. Griffin, J. Watson, N. Fyfe, D. Thomas, J. Martin, L. McDonald, L. Dunstan. Emg: D. Tyson, V. Michie.
Rucks: B. Grundy, A. Sandilands. Emg. J. Osborn, D. Currie.
Fwds: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Parker, M. Clarke, P. Karnezis, D. Garlett. Emg: D. Towers, M. Honeychurch.

[Mavro88]

BACK....Jmcveigh Smitchel Dswallow Msuckling Kkolo Lmcdonald S: mfuller .. LAIDLER

MIDS ... Pendles watson cotchin fyfe beams dthomas vmichie cbeams  S: jpolec jorourke

RUCK... mcevoy sandilands S: longer ceglar

FORWARD.. dangerfield CLOKE franklin chapman zorko clark S: rohan garlet


18k left ..any suggestions?

[abremner]

How about this?


DEFENDERS
M. FullerWBD

$151,800
DEF
0
0
VCI
J. BartelGEE

$514,900
DEF, MID
0
95
VCI
S. MitchellHAW

$517,700
DEF, MID
0
95.52
VCI
K. SimpsonCAR

$461,900
DEF
0
85.23
VCI
J. McVeighSYD

$529,900
DEF, MID
0
97.77
VCI
M. SucklingHAW

$314,400
DEF
0
0
VCI
S. EdwardsESS

$170,900
DEF
0
41.5
I
C. HowardWBD

$135,500
DEF
0
31
I
MIDFIELDERS
G. AblettGCS

$621,200
MID
0
114.62
VCI
D. SheedWCE

$235,800
MID
0
0
VCI
S. SelwoodWCE

$587,500
MID
0
108.39
VCI
T. RockliffBRL

$558,800
MID
0
103.1
VCI
V. MichieMEL

$193,900
MID
0
49
VCI
C. BeamsBRL

$187,400
MID
0
45.5
VCI
D. BeamsCOL

$498,800
MID
0
101.14
VCI
D. ThomasCAR

$346,400
MID
0
75.2
VCI
M. HoneychurchWBD

$135,500
FWD, MID
0
0
I
J. PolecPTA

$135,500
MID
0
31
I
RUCKS
S. MumfordGWS

$423,000
RUC
0
78.05
VCI
A. SandilandsFRE

$244,500
RUC
0
49.57
VCI
D. CurrieNTH

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
L. LowdenHAW

$115,200
RUC
0
0
I
FORWARDS
D. MartinRIC

$526,000
FWD, MID
0
97.05
VCI
L. FranklinSYD

$426,500
FWD
0
78.68
VCI
P. DangerfieldADE

$534,700
FWD, MID
0
98.5
VCI
M. ClarkMEL

$213,300
FWD
0
48
VCI
G. RohanSYD

$138,400
FWD
0
32.33
VCI
N. RiewoldtSTK

$559,000
FWD
0
103.14
VCI
S. KerstenGEE

$115,200
FWD
0
0
I
N. BockGCS

$135,900
FWD
0
33
I

[nicw98]

What are your thoughts on this team (got 20,100 in the kitty)



any feedback will be great thanks :)

[thefuzz]

Salary cap left: $600

Jarrad McVeigh, Pearce Hanley, Grant Birchall, Matt Suckling, Luke McDonald, Kade Kolodjashnij
Matthew Fuller, Sam Docherty

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Selwood, Michael Barlow, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Dale Thomas, Dom Tyson, Luke Dunstan
Jono O'Rourke, Claye Beams

Nic Naitanui, Aaron Sandilands
Fraser Thurlow, Sam Naismith

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Lance Franklin, Charlie Dixon, Mitchell Clark, Lewis Taylor
Gary Rohan, Mitch Honeychurch

Thurlow is a R/F so Dixon can cover for Sandi if he takes a week off. I am really not a fan of Docherty so if you can see an alternative to him I'm all ears!

[Thunderbolts]

Hey Q,

For you to pick apart and any advice?  :-X

DEF: Looks good if you are happy to take the risk on Seedsman.
MID: Very solid, however if you are going to pick Caddy I'd only get him in the FWD line. I'd dowgrade Martin too.
RUC: I've also got Lobbe and Sandi at this stage. Cool.
FWD: Fantastic.

Love the team mate, definitely some improvements you could make though.

Thanks for your input.. V2 below for advice to see if you like the changes and since Seedsman is now out for the 1st few rounds...

[dan77]

Team name FRENCHBREAD

Backs - McVeigh, Mitchell, Bartel, D Swallow, Suckling, R Shaw ( Fuller, Laidler )

Mids - Ablett, Watson, Beams, Cotchin, Pendlebury,D Thomas, Morabito, C Beams ( x Ellis, Honeychurch )

Rucks - Dixon, Sandilands ( Longer, Currie )

Forwards - Dangerfield, Zorko, Chapman, Franklin, M Clarke, fasolo ( rohan, B Brown )

$12,400 cash left over ....

[Azzas Dockers]

DEF: S. Mitchell, G. Ibbotson, M. Hibberd, D. Swallow, M. Suckling, C. Sutcliffe (M. Fuller, Laidler)
MID: J. Watson, T. Cotchin, D. Beams, M. Murphy, B. Ellis, S. Savage, D. Thomas, V. Michie (C. Beams, J. Polec)
RUC: A. Sandilands, N. Naitanui (B. Longer, D. Currie)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, J. Winderlich\C. Sylvia, J. Lamb, M. Clark (D. Garlett, N. Bock)

Happy with my team except for my 4th forward. I have 521k to spend so happy to hear any recomendations.

[Master Q]

BACK....Jmcveigh Smitchel Dswallow Msuckling Kkolo Lmcdonald S: mfuller .. LAIDLER

MIDS ... Pendles watson cotchin fyfe beams dthomas vmichie cbeams  S: jpolec jorourke

RUCK... mcevoy sandilands S: longer ceglar

FORWARD.. dangerfield CLOKE franklin chapman zorko clark S: rohan garlet


18k left ..any suggestions?

Nice, not a fan of Cloke and Zorko still.