Master Q's Team Rating Thread - Post your teams and I will rate them!

[Master Q]

Hey Q

TEAM NAME: Ping Pongs v2
DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, K. Simpson, J. Watts, M. Suckling, L. McDonald (M. Fuller, J. Laidler)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, J. Watson, D. Beams, D. Hannebery, M. Murphy, D. Thomas, V. Michie, C. Beams (X. Ellis, J. Polec)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (B. Longer, S. Naismith)
FWD: N. Riewoldt, P. Dangerfield, L. Franklin, P. Chapman, S. Higgins, M. Clark (G. Rohan, M. Honeychurch)
CASH LEFT: $700

Any news on Higgins?
Also problem if my byes are pretty much all round 9 and 10?

Thanks Q!

DEF: Watts? Otherwise very good.
MID: Again, very nice. Hannerbery could go well, but I think most of the Sydney mids are more suited to the SC game.
RUC: No problems. Naismith could get games this year, not sure if he'll play round 1 though?
FWD: Identical to mine bar Higgins. No other player has burnt us more in the past but if you want to risk it, like someone does every year, your choice  ;)

[Master Q]

Hey Q,

For you to pick apart and any advice?  :-X

DEF: Looks good if you are happy to take the risk on Seedsman.
MID: Very solid, however if you are going to pick Caddy I'd only get him in the FWD line. I'd dowgrade Martin too.
RUC: I've also got Lobbe and Sandi at this stage. Cool.
FWD: Fantastic.

Love the team mate, definitely some improvements you could make though.

[Master Q]

Hey Q, cheers for the advice last time  :) I made some changes to my team on what you had said and I think my team has gotten a lot better from it! 

DEF: McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, Suckling, K.kolodjashnij, Mcdonald (Laidler, Howard)
MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, S.Selwood, Watson, Beams, Thomas, C.Beams, Michie (O'Rourke, Polec)
RUC: Mcevoy, Sandi (Pierce, Currie)
FWD: Riwwoldt, Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, M.Clark, Rohan (Bock, Honeychurch)
CASH LEFT: $3,400

Love it!

[Junkitup]

Def: J.McVeigh , S.Mitchell , H.Lumumba , R.Shaw , L.McDonald , C.Howard (J.Laidler , J.Tippett )
Mid: G.Ablett, J.Watson, T.Liberatore , T.Cotchin, D.Beams , M.Murphy , C.Beams , J.Polec (V.Michie , J.Hunt )
Ruc: P.Ryder , A.Sandilands (B.Longer , T.Derickx )
Fwd: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin , B.Howlett, R.Nahas , N.Bock (M.Clark, G.Rohan )

Remaining: $215,100

[boxknowsbest]

This is my first attempt at the 2014 team!!


DEF... M Scharenberg, J McVeigh, J Adcock, K Kolodjashnij, M Suckling, J Bartel, (L Plowman, L McDonald)
MID... D Beams, J Watson, J Polec, T Rockliff, B Ebert, C Beams, D Thomas, J Ziebell, (J O'Rourke, V Michie)
RUC...M Lobbe, A Sandilands, (T Hickey, B Longer)
FOR...N Bock, P Dangerfield, D Martin, R Gray, G Rohan, P Chapman, (S Kersten, M Clark)


$4500 cap remaining

What do you think Q???

[Mavro88]

Backs : mcveigh ibbotson hanley grimes suckling k.kolo Lmcdonald S: m fuller a georgiou

Mid : griffen jselwood nfyfe cotchin dbeams savage jmartin cbeams S: jpolec  j orourke

Ruck : b mcevoy   hmcintosh  S: blonger d currie

Forwards: dangerfield roughy zorko chapman caddy mclark S: d garlett mhoneychurch
3k left

[Jazzoskies]

Cash $21,600

Back: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, J. Bartell, M. Hibberd, M. Suckling, M. Fuller (J. Battersby, C. Howard)
Mid: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, D. Tyson, V. Michie, C. Beams (X. Ellis, J. Polec)
Ruc: W. Minson, A. Sandilands (B. Longer, F. Thurlow)
Fwd: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, N. Reiwoldt, L. Franklin, M. Clark, G. Rohan (D. Garlett, S. Kersten)

[roti]

DEF: McVeigh, Mitchell, Hanley, H.Shaw, Suckling, R.Shaw (Laidler, Bews)

MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff, Cotchin, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis (Polec, O'Rourke)

RUC: Lobbe, Sandilands (Currie, Lowden)

FWD: Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Clark, Karnezis (Bock, Kersten)

$5,500

[Noz]

Defence: McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, Suckling, KK, McDonald (Clurey, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Pendles, S Selwood, Jack, Murphy, Thomas, Sheed, Tyson (Newton, Ellis)

Rucks: Goldstein, Sandi

Forward: Danger, Riewoldt, Wingard, Caddy, Clark, Bock (Kersten, Rohan)

Cash: $15,600

[Mavro88]

Backs : mcveigh LUMUMBA hanley  suckling k.kolo Lmcdonald S: m fuller a georgiou

Mid : STEVIEJ WATSON nfyfe cotchin dbeams DTHOMAS jmartin cbeams S: jpolec  j orourke

Ruck : b mcevoy  SANDILANDS S: blonger d currie

Forwards: dangerfield FRANKLIN zorko chapman caddy mclark S: d garlett GROHAN
left 15k

[Master Q]

Def: J.McVeigh , S.Mitchell , H.Lumumba , R.Shaw , L.McDonald , C.Howard (J.Laidler , J.Tippett )
Mid: G.Ablett, J.Watson, T.Liberatore , T.Cotchin, D.Beams , M.Murphy , C.Beams , J.Polec (V.Michie , J.Hunt )
Ruc: P.Ryder , A.Sandilands (B.Longer , T.Derickx )
Fwd: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, L.Franklin , B.Howlett, R.Nahas , N.Bock (M.Clark, G.Rohan )

Remaining: $215,100

DEF: Looks too weak to me. Not sure about Harry O...Sorry, Lumumba  :P
MID: Very strong. Maybe too strong  :P
RUC: Better options than Ryder IMO.
FWD: Not sure Howlett and Nahas. Clark is definitely good enough for F5 or F6.

Think you need to spend that money. Would definitely spend it on upgrading Shaw or one of your forwards.

[Master Q]

This is my first attempt at the 2014 team!!


DEF... M Scharenberg, J McVeigh, J Adcock, K Kolodjashnij, M Suckling, J Bartel, (L Plowman, L McDonald)
MID... D Beams, J Watson, J Polec, T Rockliff, B Ebert, C Beams, D Thomas, J Ziebell, (J O'Rourke, V Michie)
RUC...M Lobbe, A Sandilands, (T Hickey, B Longer)
FOR...N Bock, P Dangerfield, D Martin, R Gray, G Rohan, P Chapman, (S Kersten, M Clark)


$4500 cap remaining

What do you think Q???

DEF: Adcock + Suckling makes your backline look a bit risky. I'd go for someone else instead of Adcock.
MID: Pretty weak to be honest. Don't see much in Ebert and Ziebell.
RUC: Nice
FWD: Again looks pretty weak to me. Clark is good enough to play on the field, might get someone instead of Gray.

Not a real fan of the team to be honest.

[boxknowsbest]

This is my first attempt at the 2014 team!!


DEF... M Scharenberg, J McVeigh, J Adcock, K Kolodjashnij, M Suckling, J Bartel, (L Plowman, L McDonald)
MID... D Beams, J Watson, J Polec, T Rockliff, B Ebert, C Beams, D Thomas, J Ziebell, (J O'Rourke, V Michie)
RUC...M Lobbe, A Sandilands, (T Hickey, B Longer)
FOR...N Bock, P Dangerfield, D Martin, R Gray, G Rohan, P Chapman, (S Kersten, M Clark)


$4500 cap remaining

What do you think Q???

DEF: Adcock + Suckling makes your backline look a bit risky. I'd go for someone else instead of Adcock.
MID: Pretty weak to be honest. Don't see much in Ebert and Ziebell.
RUC: Nice
FWD: Again looks pretty weak to me. Clark is good enough to play on the field, might get someone instead of Gray.

Not a real fan of the team to be honest.

Thanks for the advice Q... I have re-jigged the team for your advice!!!!


DEF... M Scharenberg, J McVeigh, D Swallow, K Kolodjashnij, M Suckling, S Mitchell, (L Plowman, L McDonald)
MID... D Beams, J Watson, J Polec, K Cornes, S Pendlebury, C Beams, D Thomas, G Ablett, (J O'Rourke, V Michie)
RUC...M Lobbe, A Sandilands, (J Ceglar, B Longer)
FOR...N Bock, P Dangerfield, D Martin, R Gray, M Clark, P Chapman, (S Kersten, G Rohan )


$1200 cap remaining

I have replaced Ebert, Ziebell and Rockliff with Ablett, Pendlebury and Cornes to strengthen the Mids.... AND replaced Adcock/ Bartel with Mitchell/ D Swallow.

The reason I have Gray is because I have seen him training throughout the summer and he looks in super shape - better than before his ACL!!!

The only other change was the Ruck bench to free up some cash!!!

[Buddysbuddy]

DEF mcveigh, suckling,s mitchelk,p hanley , l mcdonald, h shaw ( C howard J kelly )
MID D swan, S selwood , T rockliff , D beams, D thomas , V michie, C beams , P chapman (X Ellis J Polec )
RUC M Lobbe , A sandilands S (D currie F thurlow)
FWD P dangerfield D martin M pavlich L franklin J Daniher J patton S (Rohan D garlett)
Tried to have some POD with shaw and patton
still undecided about chapman
$4,900 left

[Mavro88]

BACK....Jmcveigh Smitchel Dswallow Msuckling Kkolo Lmcdonald S: mfuller .. tsimpkin

MIDS ... Pendles watson cotchin fyfe beams dthomas vmichie cbeams  S: jpolec jorourke

RUCK... mcevoy sandilands S: longer ceglar

FORWARD.. dangerfield roughy franklin chapman zorko clark S: rohan garlet


18k left ..any suggestions?