Master Q's Team Rating Thread - Post your teams and I will rate them!

[Money]

Cheers mate

[Master Q]

Great work as always Q.

My team,

Backs:Mitchell, Bartell, Hanley, Suckling, Swallow, Geary (Howard, Fuller)
MidsSwan, Ablett, D.Beams, Murphy, Thomas, B.Ellis, C.Beams, Michie (X.Ellis, Polec)
RucksSandilands, Longer (Derickx, Thurlow)
FwdsDangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Walker, M.CLark (Rohan, Bock)

$142,000 left

Thanks mate

DEF: Flat out no to Geary - downgrade to someone like McDonald?
MID: Interesting pick in Ellis
RUC: Sandi and Longer combo is quite weak
FWD: I'd downgrade someone like Tex and spend that cash on upgrading Longer or someone like Ellis

Decent team. Just need to work on those rucks - think my suggestions were fair as well.

Thanks Q.

Yeah wasn't sure about Geary but he did finish the year well.  Who do you recommend for Tex?

Well we don't know much about rookies at this stage. I've heard good things about Lewis Taylor and Kersten though.

[redrocket]

Great work as always Q.

My team,

Backs:Mitchell, Bartell, Hanley, Suckling, Swallow, Geary (Howard, Fuller)
MidsSwan, Ablett, D.Beams, Murphy, Thomas, B.Ellis, C.Beams, Michie (X.Ellis, Polec)
RucksSandilands, Longer (Derickx, Thurlow)
FwdsDangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Walker, M.CLark (Rohan, Bock)

$142,000 left

Thanks mate

DEF: Flat out no to Geary - downgrade to someone like McDonald?
MID: Interesting pick in Ellis
RUC: Sandi and Longer combo is quite weak
FWD: I'd downgrade someone like Tex and spend that cash on upgrading Longer or someone like Ellis

Decent team. Just need to work on those rucks - think my suggestions were fair as well.

Thanks Q.

Yeah wasn't sure about Geary but he did finish the year well.  Who do you recommend for Tex?

Well we don't know much about rookies at this stage. I've heard good things about Lewis Taylor and Kersten though.

Yeah just wasn't sure if you were meaning rookie.

Team changes:
Geary to McDonald
Ellis to Cotchin
Longer to Nic Nat
Tex to Garlett

Thanks Q I think it looks better and still $94,000 left.  Probably will change before start anyway.

[Master Q]

Cheers mate

DEF: Backs look a bit shakey - maybe upgrade Birchall to Mitchell or Bartel?
MID: Not a fan of Stanton. Think there a better options than Young. Don't know a lot about Sheed so won't comment on him.
RUC: Cool.
FWD: Very nice. Karnezis is a risk, wouldn't you prefer MClark?

Very nice team mate. Lots of changes you could make though.

[Master Q]

Very nice redrocket  :)

[Money]

Cheers mate

DEF: Backs look a bit shakey - maybe upgrade Birchall to Mitchell or Bartel?
MID: Not a fan of Stanton. Think there a better options than Young. Don't know a lot about Sheed so won't comment on him.
RUC: Cool.
FWD: Very nice. Karnezis is a risk, wouldn't you prefer MClark?

Very nice team mate. Lots of changes you could make though.

Cheers for the feedback Q, great stuff
I honestly think Birchall can get up to 90-95 and unique
Stanton is my real unqiue mid option, with the incusion of Bomber T and a fit Watson I reckon he will go 108+
If Young starts R1 I will have him locked in, prevon 80+ scorer and think he will score better than rookies around his price
Not sure on karnezis yet, thinking of maybe downgrading to a rook

[Master Q]

It's your team after all  ;)

[Money]

It's your team after all  ;)

aha very true, thanks for the rate mate

[Master Q]

It's your team after all  ;)

aha very true, thanks for the rate mate

No worries.

[seeds40]

BACKS: McVeigh, Hanley, Birchall, Seedsman, B.Smith, Fuller (Howard, Laidler)
MIDS: Ablett, S.Selwood, Watson, Liberatore, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J. Martin, Michie (Polec, O'Rourke)
RUCK: Natanui, Sandilands (Longer, Currie)
FORWARDS: Dangerfield, D.Martin, Wingard, Caddy, Clark, Rohan (Garlett, Kersten)

SALARY: $16,500

[Master Q]

BACKS: McVeigh, Hanley, Birchall, Seedsman, B.Smith, Fuller (Howard, Laidler)
MIDS: Ablett, S.Selwood, Watson, Liberatore, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J. Martin, Michie (Polec, O'Rourke)
RUCK: Natanui, Sandilands (Longer, Currie)
FORWARDS: Dangerfield, D.Martin, Wingard, Caddy, Clark, Rohan (Garlett, Kersten)

SALARY: $16,500

DEF: Don't know a lot about Brodie Smith. Seedsman is a risk, and Birchall is coming off an average season.
MID: Nice midfield, but you could upgrade Lbba and downgrade Martin.
RUC: SOlid
FWD: Caddy has been a popular pick, but I'd look at getting someone like Buddy instead of Wingard or Caddy.

[seeds40]

here is an article on smith, it's either smith or swallow at this stage for me: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-01-25/crows-middle-man

who would you recommend downgrading martin to mate?

as for buddy.. hmm i dunno.. he really let me down last year

[Master Q]

here is an article on smith, it's either smith or swallow at this stage for me: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-01-25/crows-middle-man

who would you recommend downgrading martin to mate?

as for buddy.. hmm i dunno.. he really let me down last year

Well it's pre-NAB challenge, so we don't know a lot about rookies, but there are guys like X.Ellis or C.Beams who you could look at?

[Thunderbolts]

Hey Q,

For you to pick apart and any advice?  :-X

[Senior]

Hey Q, cheers for the advice last time  :) I made some changes to my team on what you had said and I think my team has gotten a lot better from it! 

DEF: McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, Suckling, K.kolodjashnij, Mcdonald (Laidler, Howard)
MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, S.Selwood, Watson, Beams, Thomas, C.Beams, Michie (O'Rourke, Polec)
RUC: Mcevoy, Sandi (Pierce, Currie)
FWD: Riwwoldt, Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, M.Clark, Rohan (Bock, Honeychurch)
CASH LEFT: $3,400