Master Q's Team Rating Thread - Post your teams and I will rate them!

[Master Q]

rate away

DEF: Need to start again there. Shaw brothers are risky on top of Henderson, Suckling and Birchall.
MID: Not bad. Think there are some better options than Parker but he could do well.
RUC: Not much to complain about
FWD: Nice selection in NRoo, I'd get someone else instead of Darling though.

[Artax]

Thanks mate!

Thinking of Seedsman or Birch for Grimes & downgrading Savage or Darling to upgrade the other, not sure who is worth taking cheaper in those lines though!

[eaglesman]

mcveigh mitchell walker swallow darley kolodjashnij (fuller aylett)

ablett scott selwood stanton fyfe beams thomas Michie ellis (polec templeton)

Mumford sandilands (longer thurlow)

Dangerfield Martin Parker Chapman Karnezis Taylor (kersten bock)

$22k

would love some feedback mate and thanks in advance

[Master Q]

mcveigh mitchell walker swallow darley kolodjashnij (fuller aylett)

ablett scott selwood stanton fyfe beams thomas Michie ellis (polec templeton)

Mumford sandilands (longer thurlow)

Dangerfield Martin Parker Chapman Karnezis Taylor (kersten bock)

$22k

would love some feedback mate and thanks in advance

Hey Eaglesman

DEF: Not sure what you see in Darley, not a nice price either. I prefer Simpson over Walker as well, but Bartel is even better.
MID: Not a fan of Stanton. Fyfe is more of a SC'er, you could upgrade him with your spare cash or even downgrade him to someone like Cotchin.
RUC: Nice pick in Mummy
FWD: Karnezis is an interesting one. Think there are some better options than Parker.

Solid team, just a few guys who I'm not a fan of.

[nrich102]

Thanks Q :)



$130,100 left in the bank.

[Master Q]

Thanks Q :)



$130,100 left in the bank.

DEF: Golby?  :P Brisbane fans  ::)  :P
MID: Not sold on Prestia. Said it many times but I'm not sold on Martin either.
RUC: Think there are some better options than Berger. Don't think he'll go that great this year.
FWD: I'd use some of your cash on upgrading one of Wingard or Dixon.

Not a bad team, think changes need to be made though. Loving the Lions bias  :P

[nrich102]

Thanks Q :)



$130,100 left in the bank.

DEF: Golby?  :P Brisbane fans  ::)  :P
MID: Not sold on Prestia. Said it many times but I'm not sold on Martin either.
RUC: Think there are some better options than Berger. Don't think he'll go that great this year.
FWD: I'd use some of your cash on upgrading one of Wingard or Dixon.

Not a bad team, think changes need to be made though. Loving the Lions bias  :P

Thanks Q.

[Ringo]

One for you Q

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, J. Martin, D. Tyson, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, G. Rohan , M. Clark (B. Lennon, S. Kersten)
CASH LEFT: $28,800

Rookies to be set after NAB Challenge as well as injury returning players. Bock will be considered if he plays and named round 1 for example.

DEF: Looks good to me. Not sure on LRT money making wise but he is good cover. I guess we wait till the NAB challenge to see if there are better options.
MID: I've previously stated that I'm not sold on Martin. Better options than Tyson as well.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Think this needs a bit of restructuring. Zorko, Darling, Rohan and Clark looks very unstable to me. While Clark is a massive lock, doesn't mean he is going to fire  :P

A good effort Ringo. Got a foundation for a fantastic team.

Thanks Q.  Thoughts on theses adjustments in mids and whether it is worth it
Martin > Mitch Grigg
Tyson > Polec

Just on forwards - Darling selected because of Eagles relative easy draw and hopefully make cash for nice upgrade to a performing forward. Educated Guess
Rohan has been training well and may or may not make final cut after NAB Challenge and you know my feelings on Zorko

[Master Q]

One for you Q

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, J. Martin, D. Tyson, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, G. Rohan , M. Clark (B. Lennon, S. Kersten)
CASH LEFT: $28,800

Rookies to be set after NAB Challenge as well as injury returning players. Bock will be considered if he plays and named round 1 for example.

DEF: Looks good to me. Not sure on LRT money making wise but he is good cover. I guess we wait till the NAB challenge to see if there are better options.
MID: I've previously stated that I'm not sold on Martin. Better options than Tyson as well.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Think this needs a bit of restructuring. Zorko, Darling, Rohan and Clark looks very unstable to me. While Clark is a massive lock, doesn't mean he is going to fire  :P

A good effort Ringo. Got a foundation for a fantastic team.

Thanks Q.  Thoughts on theses adjustments in mids and whether it is worth it
Martin > Mitch Grigg
Tyson > Polec

Just on forwards - Darling selected because of Eagles relative easy draw and hopefully make cash for nice upgrade to a performing forward. Educated Guess
Rohan has been training well and may or may not make final cut after NAB Challenge and you know my feelings on Zorko

Instead of Grigg have you considered Michie? Polec looks good, looking forward to the NAB Challenge to see how he goes.

[Ringo]

One for you Q

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, J. Martin, D. Tyson, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, G. Rohan , M. Clark (B. Lennon, S. Kersten)
CASH LEFT: $28,800

Rookies to be set after NAB Challenge as well as injury returning players. Bock will be considered if he plays and named round 1 for example.

DEF: Looks good to me. Not sure on LRT money making wise but he is good cover. I guess we wait till the NAB challenge to see if there are better options.
MID: I've previously stated that I'm not sold on Martin. Better options than Tyson as well.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Think this needs a bit of restructuring. Zorko, Darling, Rohan and Clark looks very unstable to me. While Clark is a massive lock, doesn't mean he is going to fire  :P

A good effort Ringo. Got a foundation for a fantastic team.

Thanks Q.  Thoughts on theses adjustments in mids and whether it is worth it
Martin > Mitch Grigg
Tyson > Polec

Just on forwards - Darling selected because of Eagles relative easy draw and hopefully make cash for nice upgrade to a performing forward. Educated Guess
Rohan has been training well and may or may not make final cut after NAB Challenge and you know my feelings on Zorko

Instead of Grigg have you considered Michie? Polec looks good, looking forward to the NAB Challenge to see how he goes.

Played around a bit more is this any better Q

Taking the punt on Michie allowed Motlop in forward line.

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, V Michie, J. Polec, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, S. Motlop , M. Clark (G. Rohan, S. Kersten)

[Master Q]

One for you Q

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, J. Martin, D. Tyson, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, G. Rohan , M. Clark (B. Lennon, S. Kersten)
CASH LEFT: $28,800

Rookies to be set after NAB Challenge as well as injury returning players. Bock will be considered if he plays and named round 1 for example.

DEF: Looks good to me. Not sure on LRT money making wise but he is good cover. I guess we wait till the NAB challenge to see if there are better options.
MID: I've previously stated that I'm not sold on Martin. Better options than Tyson as well.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Think this needs a bit of restructuring. Zorko, Darling, Rohan and Clark looks very unstable to me. While Clark is a massive lock, doesn't mean he is going to fire  :P

A good effort Ringo. Got a foundation for a fantastic team.

Thanks Q.  Thoughts on theses adjustments in mids and whether it is worth it
Martin > Mitch Grigg
Tyson > Polec

Just on forwards - Darling selected because of Eagles relative easy draw and hopefully make cash for nice upgrade to a performing forward. Educated Guess
Rohan has been training well and may or may not make final cut after NAB Challenge and you know my feelings on Zorko

Instead of Grigg have you considered Michie? Polec looks good, looking forward to the NAB Challenge to see how he goes.

Played around a bit more is this any better Q

Taking the punt on Michie allowed Motlop in forward line.

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, V Michie, J. Polec, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, S. Motlop , M. Clark (G. Rohan, S. Kersten)

That's a very strong team. When it comes to the forward line, Zorko, Darling and Motlop are all uniques and POD, so if you like them, good luck  :)

[Ringo]

One for you Q

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, J. Martin, D. Tyson, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, G. Rohan , M. Clark (B. Lennon, S. Kersten)
CASH LEFT: $28,800

Rookies to be set after NAB Challenge as well as injury returning players. Bock will be considered if he plays and named round 1 for example.

DEF: Looks good to me. Not sure on LRT money making wise but he is good cover. I guess we wait till the NAB challenge to see if there are better options.
MID: I've previously stated that I'm not sold on Martin. Better options than Tyson as well.
RUC: Solid.
FWD: Think this needs a bit of restructuring. Zorko, Darling, Rohan and Clark looks very unstable to me. While Clark is a massive lock, doesn't mean he is going to fire  :P

A good effort Ringo. Got a foundation for a fantastic team.

Thanks Q.  Thoughts on theses adjustments in mids and whether it is worth it
Martin > Mitch Grigg
Tyson > Polec

Just on forwards - Darling selected because of Eagles relative easy draw and hopefully make cash for nice upgrade to a performing forward. Educated Guess
Rohan has been training well and may or may not make final cut after NAB Challenge and you know my feelings on Zorko

Instead of Grigg have you considered Michie? Polec looks good, looking forward to the NAB Challenge to see how he goes.

Played around a bit more is this any better Q

Taking the punt on Michie allowed Motlop in forward line.

DEF: J. McVeigh, S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, K. Simpson, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (L. McDonald, L. Roberts-Thomson)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, T. Rockliff, D. Beams, D. Thomas, V Michie, J. Polec, C. Beams (D. Garlett, X. Ellis)
RUC: B. McEvoy, A. Sandilands (T. Derickx, F. Thurlow)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, D. Zorko, J. Darling, S. Motlop , M. Clark (G. Rohan, S. Kersten)

That's a very strong team. When it comes to the forward line, Zorko, Darling and Motlop are all uniques and POD, so if you like them, good luck  :)

Thanks Q Darling may become Pav if I find $1k when finalising rookies.

[redrocket]

Great work as always Q.

My team,

Backs:Mitchell, Bartell, Hanley, Suckling, Swallow, Geary (Howard, Fuller)
MidsSwan, Ablett, D.Beams, Murphy, Thomas, B.Ellis, C.Beams, Michie (X.Ellis, Polec)
RucksSandilands, Longer (Derickx, Thurlow)
FwdsDangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Walker, M.CLark (Rohan, Bock)

$142,000 left

[Master Q]

Great work as always Q.

My team,

Backs:Mitchell, Bartell, Hanley, Suckling, Swallow, Geary (Howard, Fuller)
MidsSwan, Ablett, D.Beams, Murphy, Thomas, B.Ellis, C.Beams, Michie (X.Ellis, Polec)
RucksSandilands, Longer (Derickx, Thurlow)
FwdsDangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Walker, M.CLark (Rohan, Bock)

$142,000 left

Thanks mate

DEF: Flat out no to Geary - downgrade to someone like McDonald?
MID: Interesting pick in Ellis
RUC: Sandi and Longer combo is quite weak
FWD: I'd downgrade someone like Tex and spend that cash on upgrading Longer or someone like Ellis

Decent team. Just need to work on those rucks - think my suggestions were fair as well.

[redrocket]

Great work as always Q.

My team,

Backs:Mitchell, Bartell, Hanley, Suckling, Swallow, Geary (Howard, Fuller)
MidsSwan, Ablett, D.Beams, Murphy, Thomas, B.Ellis, C.Beams, Michie (X.Ellis, Polec)
RucksSandilands, Longer (Derickx, Thurlow)
FwdsDangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Chapman, Walker, M.CLark (Rohan, Bock)

$142,000 left

Thanks mate

DEF: Flat out no to Geary - downgrade to someone like McDonald?
MID: Interesting pick in Ellis
RUC: Sandi and Longer combo is quite weak
FWD: I'd downgrade someone like Tex and spend that cash on upgrading Longer or someone like Ellis

Decent team. Just need to work on those rucks - think my suggestions were fair as well.

Thanks Q.

Yeah wasn't sure about Geary but he did finish the year well.  Who do you recommend for Tex?