Master Q's Dream Team Analyser 2014 (Pre-NAB Challenge)

[Adamant]

Ok here is another one from me.

K. Simpson + S. Pendlebury + G. Rohan
vs
D. Swallow + D. Thomas + N. Riewoldt

Keep in mind that in the second option Swallow would be my D3 and in the first option I am starting two sub-180k forwards (one is Rohan).

Also Thomas would be M6 in the second option.

[Master Q]

Ok here is another one from me.

K. Simpson + S. Pendlebury + G. Rohan
vs
D. Swallow + D. Thomas + N. Riewoldt

Keep in mind that in the second option Swallow would be my D3 and in the first option I am starting two sub-180k forwards (one is Rohan).

Also Thomas would be M6 in the second option.

Thomas is a must have. Whether that means you go with option one and squeeze him in some other way or just go with option two. I much prefer Simpson to Swallow, but NRoo is going to smash it the first few rounds.

Option 2 is the way to go unless you can get Thomas in another way.

[Adamant]

Ok here is another one from me.

K. Simpson + S. Pendlebury + G. Rohan
vs
D. Swallow + D. Thomas + N. Riewoldt

Keep in mind that in the second option Swallow would be my D3 and in the first option I am starting two sub-180k forwards (one is Rohan).

Also Thomas would be M6 in the second option.

Thomas is a must have. Whether that means you go with option one and squeeze him in some other way or just go with option two. I much prefer Simpson to Swallow, but NRoo is going to smash it the first few rounds.

Option 2 is the way to go unless you can get Thomas in another way.

Cheers Q, doubt I'll be able to fit in Thomas another way unless I downgrade Watson (M5) to a rookie, but will ponder these two combos leading up to round one anyway.

[Toga]

Not really a player vs player question here Q, but as a Blues supporter what can you see Simpson averaging this season? :)

[Master Q]

Not really a player vs player question here Q, but as a Blues supporter what can you see Simpson averaging this season? :)

Around 85/90, if Carlton play like a Top 4 side he could lift that to 90/95.

[eg6914]

Master Q which combo?
a) Pendles + Kolo
b) Cotchin + Suckling
ATM i am leaning towards option a, as i prefer the Guns N Rooks setup

[Toga]

Not really a player vs player question here Q, but as a Blues supporter what can you see Simpson averaging this season? :)

Around 85/90, if Carlton play like a Top 4 side he could lift that to 90/95.

Wow, that'd be pretty good hey! I'm trying to decide whether to go with him or McVeigh in both AF & DT, so if Simmo could average that high I'd have to go with him I think. Cheers!

[Master Q]

Master Q which combo?
a) Pendles + Kolo
b) Cotchin + Suckling
ATM i am leaning towards option a, as i prefer the Guns N Rooks setup

Safer to see how Kolo goes, but I don't think b) is that bad either.

Very tough call.

[Master Q]

Not really a player vs player question here Q, but as a Blues supporter what can you see Simpson averaging this season? :)

Around 85/90, if Carlton play like a Top 4 side he could lift that to 90/95.

Wow, that'd be pretty good hey! I'm trying to decide whether to go with him or McVeigh in both AF & DT, so if Simmo could average that high I'd have to go with him I think. Cheers!

I'll be honest, I haven't completed my DT team yet, but in AF I got Simpson instead of McVeigh. I don't think McVeigh will score that much more and I could use the cash elsewhere.

[dejan]

stevie j or jobe watson or scott selwood

[eg6914]

What about, which two out of Scooter, GAZ and Pendles?