Master Q's Dream Team Analyser 2014 (Pre-NAB Challenge)

[Master Q]

FanFooty's most famous thread is back!

Ask me a Player v Player question and I will look at the stats, and give you my honest opinion!

If you could leave the answering to me, that would be great, if you would like to discuss something in-depth make a thread!  :) I am going to try and get to everybody as well  ;)

Thanks
Master Q

[eg6914]

ok i'll start it off ;), Caddy vs Hawkins would be great! ;D

[Nige]

I'd like a look at Brandon Ellis vs Dion Prestia thanks Quey.  8)

[Master Q]

ok i'll start it off ;), Caddy vs Hawkins would be great! ;D

Thanks! An easy one to start off with too  ;)

Caddy v Hawkins
To be honest I wouldn't pick either for my team, but if I would have to choose between the two, I'd go Caddy. The infamous back issues have been bugging Hawkins for a while, so that may have limited his scoring in 2013. However he still didn't show that much in 2012, only scoring 3 tons. If Caddy can avoid the vest he could be decent this year, especially if he receives more midfield time.

[nrich102]

Q, Libba Vs Prestia

[T Dog]

Q..Paz vs Zorko

[Master Q]

Q, Libba Vs Prestia

From my AFL Fantasy thread:

Prestia v Libba
Both these guys cemented themselves in their 22s in 2013 and averaged nearly the exact same. I feel that Libba is more of a SC'er and has more room for improvement in that game, while I think if Prestia can build up his consistency he can improve his DT game (and average). Saying that, and 520k-odd each, I'd stay away from both. At the start of the season at least.

[nrich102]

Q, Libba Vs Prestia

From my AFL Fantasy thread:

Prestia v Libba
Both these guys cemented themselves in their 22s in 2013 and averaged nearly the exact same. I feel that Libba is more of a SC'er and has more room for improvement in that game, while I think if Prestia can build up his consistency he can improve his DT game (and average). Saying that, and 520k-odd each, I'd stay away from both. At the start of the season at least.

Sorry mate, but thanks :)

[Adamant]

J. Watson + K. Simpson vs D. Thomas + J. McVeigh + 150k.

Think I've already made my mind up on this one but wouldn't mind an opinion. :P

[Master Q]

Q..Paz vs Zorko

Pav vs Zorko

Real toughy. To be honest, not sure if I would pick either. If I had to choose one, I'd have to go with Pav. Absolute legend and been a gun for many years, he's much more reliable than Zorko. As long as he is fit and healthy.

[Master Q]

Q, Libba Vs Prestia

From my AFL Fantasy thread:

Prestia v Libba
Both these guys cemented themselves in their 22s in 2013 and averaged nearly the exact same. I feel that Libba is more of a SC'er and has more room for improvement in that game, while I think if Prestia can build up his consistency he can improve his DT game (and average). Saying that, and 520k-odd each, I'd stay away from both. At the start of the season at least.

Sorry mate, but thanks :)

Haha, no problems.

[Master Q]

J. Watson + K. Simpson vs D. Thomas + J. McVeigh + 150k.

Think I've already made my mind up on this one but wouldn't mind an opinion. :P

Second one, easily. While I may be going with Simpson over McVeigh for the extra cash, Thomas is a must have. Then you can spend that 150k elsewhere, as well.

[Nige]

[Master Q]

I'd like a look at Brandon Ellis vs Dion Prestia thanks Quey.  8)

Very sorry Nigey. Completely missed your question so was confused when I saw your GIF  :P

As long as he can avoid the vest and doesn't attract too much attention, for 100k less, Ellis is definitely a better pick than Prestia.

[Nige]

I'd like a look at Brandon Ellis vs Dion Prestia thanks Quey.  8)

Very sorry Nigey. Completely missed your question so was confused when I saw your GIF  :P

As long as he can avoid the vest and doesn't attract too much attention, for 100k less, Ellis is definitely a better pick than Prestia.

His vest days are long gone.