Master Q's AFL Fantasy Analyser 2014 (Pre-NAB Challenge)

[Master Q]

What are your thoughts of Wingard as F3

Don't like Wingard fantasy wise. Buddy is my F3 at this stage, he could even become F4 if I manage to squeeze in NROO ahead of Danger and Dusty who are locks IMO. Chappy is another good option.

Sorry Master didn't read your post properly what about Wingard v Parker

Wingard seems to be more consistent and has a higher roof. Going forward and kicking goals really helps his game.

[shaker]

Alright Master just joined up DT today and have Longer at R3 because he is so cheap and Leuy at R1 who is your pick for R2 out of Sandi , Grundy , Hmac or Hickey cheers

[nickstiges]

Thoughts on K Kolo v L McDonald?
Both been hyped up a fair bit so far at this early stage.

[Master Q]

Alright Master just joined up DT today and have Longer at R3 because he is so cheap and Leuy at R1 who is your pick for R2 out of Sandi , Grundy , Hmac or Hickey cheers

Thanks for the question Shaker.

Firstly Hickey and Grundy are out of the equation. I don't think either will score well. That makes it Hmac v Sandi, and IMO I think for his price Sandi is just worth the risk (v Hmac).

[Master Q]

Thoughts on K Kolo v L McDonald?
Both been hyped up a fair bit so far at this early stage.

Kolo v McDonald

It's pre-NAB challenge but I really think McDonald will be the best rookie this year. Every club loves a F/S and he seems like he could be a great scorer, and for his price in his position he isn't a bad pick. I think he could easily play 22 games this year.

[zeus123456]

Who do you think are the most top 5 premium starter midfielders and lobbe vs nicnat vs mumford

[Master Q]

Who do you think are the most top 5 premium starter midfielders and lobbe vs nicnat vs mumford

5 most premium Mids
Not in any particular order - Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Scott Selwood and Beams (great price is a factor)

Lobbe v Nic Nat vs Mummy
Lobbe for me.

[nrich102]

McVeigh Vs Mitchell, thanks :)

[Master Q]

McVeigh Vs Mitchell, thanks :)

Let's break it down:

McVeigh
Price: 529k
2013 games: 22
2013 average: 97.7
2013 tons: 8
Years averaged over 100: 0

Mitchell
Price: 517k
2013 games: 21
2013 average: 95.5
2013 tons: 10
Years averaged over 100: 3

Both very similar, but Mitchell has shown a lot more in the past. So he'd be my first priority, McVeigh is still good if you can squeeze him in. However I downgraded him to Simpson, someone who is a lot cheaper and doesn't average a lot less. There a few guys like Simpson who you could look at though.

[jamfrank]

Liberatore vs Watson?

[Master Q]

Liberatore vs Watson?

Watson by a country mile. No contest.

[Money]

Not sure if we're allowed to comeback for seconds but heres another

Liam Anthony v Jesse Lonergan

[Noz]

Marc Murphy or Daniel Rich

[Master Q]

Not sure if we're allowed to comeback for seconds but heres another

Liam Anthony v Jesse Lonergan

First I've heard of these two this pre-season  :P

Anthony should be close to the 22 and had a great 2012. So I'd say Anthony?

[Master Q]

Marc Murphy or Daniel Rich

Murphy by a country mile. No research to be done.