WXV Discussion

[JBs-Hawks]

You cant count Scharenburg when you traded him in knowing his knee was cooked.

[Holz]

Jobe Watson: out the whole season
Bob Murphy: Probably out for the season
Tom Mcdonald: 95 to 74 drop in average
David Mundy: 113 down to 81 missed 3 games
Travis Boak: 99 average down to 88
Josh Bruce: 68 average down to 56

in saying that Walters and SJ for yarran and jetta were epic fails.

[Purple 77]

Jobe Watson: out the whole season
Bob Murphy: Probably out for the season
Tom Mcdonald: 95 to 74 drop in average
David Mundy: 113 down to 81 missed 3 games
Travis Boak: 99 average down to 88
Josh Bruce: 68 average down to 56

in saying that Walters and SJ for yarran and jetta were epic fails.

Can it be that I finally figured out Holz in trade talks? :P

Lewis Jetta will rebound anyway. Trade him back to me if you don't want him  ;)

[Holz]

Jobe Watson: out the whole season
Bob Murphy: Probably out for the season
Tom Mcdonald: 95 to 74 drop in average
David Mundy: 113 down to 81 missed 3 games
Travis Boak: 99 average down to 88
Josh Bruce: 68 average down to 56

in saying that Walters and SJ for yarran and jetta were epic fails.

Can it be that I finally figured out Holz in trade talks? :P

Lewis Jetta will rebound anyway. Trade him back to me if you don't want him  ;)

nah jetta still good for me long term. the punt was he would play HFF or HBF annoyingly he looks to be playing wing so shouldnt get dpp.

If he got D/M status i would be laughing.

SJ isnt a spud though, cant believe how much he got talked down. basically the only thing that has gone good for Berlin. i reckon he has 2-3 years of 90 in him, could actually win a flag with GWS.

if you worked me out trade with me this year :P

Crouch Fyfe must be big headaches, ill handle them for you.

[Purple 77]

Jobe Watson: out the whole season
Bob Murphy: Probably out for the season
Tom Mcdonald: 95 to 74 drop in average
David Mundy: 113 down to 81 missed 3 games
Travis Boak: 99 average down to 88
Josh Bruce: 68 average down to 56

in saying that Walters and SJ for yarran and jetta were epic fails.

Can it be that I finally figured out Holz in trade talks? :P

Lewis Jetta will rebound anyway. Trade him back to me if you don't want him  ;)

nah jetta still good for me long term. the punt was he would play HFF or HBF annoyingly he looks to be playing wing so shouldnt get dpp.

If he got D/M status i would be laughing.

SJ isnt a spud though, cant believe how much he got talked down. basically the only thing that has gone good for Berlin. i reckon he has 2-3 years of 90 in him, could actually win a flag with GWS.

if you worked me out trade with me this year :P

Crouch Fyfe must be big headaches, ill handle them for you.

Haha, my current feelings on Crouch will change as soon as he pumps out regular hundreds  ;) whereas Fyfe is the key to my success  8)

[Levi434]

A week or two ago a few of the coaches were having a conversation about which players got scaled up and down the most. I did a bit of digging a came up with the following:

Players who get scaled UP the most:
1: Steven May 54.8 DT for 84.2 SC   ( +29.4 )
2: Daniel Merrett 37.6 DT for 65.2 SC   ( +27.6 )
3: Alex Rance 78.2 DT for 105.4 SC   ( +27.2 )
4: Nic Naitanui 93.5 DT for 117.8 SC   ( +24.3 )
5: Callan Ward 94.7 DT for 117.8 SC   ( +23.1 )
6: Scott Thompson(NM) 63 DT for 85.8 SC   ( +22.8 )
7: Patrick Dangerfield 108.2 DT for 128.8 SC   ( +20.6 )
8: Max Gawn 98.7 DT for 118.8 SC   ( +20.1 )
9: Phil Davis 51.5 DT for 71.5 SC   ( +20 )
10: Shane Mumford 78.2 DT for 98.2 SC   ( +20 )



Players who get scaled DOWN the most:
1: Sebastian Ross 102.3 DT for 86.5 SC   ( -15.8 )
2: Caleb Daniel 97.8 DT for 84.2 SC   ( -13.6 )
3: Matthew Stokes 79.7 DT for 66.3 SC   ( -13.4 )
4: Levi Greenwood 87.5 DT for 76.3 SC   ( -11.2 )
5: Matthew Lobbe 72 DT for 61 SC   ( -11 )
6: Sam Gray 79.2 DT for 68.3 SC   ( -10.9 )
7: Jack Steele 79 DT for 68.2 SC   ( -10.8 )
8: Zachary Merrett 112.3 DT for 101.7 SC   ( -10.6 )
9: Hamish Hartlett 83.5 DT for 73.2 SC   ( -10.3 )
10: Jackson Merrett 69.3 DT for 59 SC   ( -10.3 )

Corey Gault, Liam Shiels, Matthew Goodyear all have -16 but weren't included due to minimal games played.

Seb Ross is indeed the most scaled down player. Also I must say that it is an outrage that Sir Daniel is on that list.

I'll also take requests if people have any :)

[Torpedo10]

Moscow have owned 3 out of that top 5 scaled up.

[RaisyDaisy]

Appreciate the effort that went into that - good work Levi :)

[Toga]

Very interesting stats Levi!

[Purple 77]

Ah awesome, I love fun stats  8) appreciate the effort Levi!

I bloomin noticed Steven May is treated kind by SC, I was tempted to try and trade for him for a while because of it :P

[Torpedo10]

Ah awesome, I love fun stats  8) appreciate the effort Levi!

I bloomin noticed Steven May is treated kind by SC, I was tempted to try and trade for him for a while because of it :P

Fyfe? He's got that dodgy leg.  ;)

[Jay]

Poor Pacific can't take a trick at the moment! First Suckers, now both Devon and Laird.

Heppell, Hooker, Gray, O'Meara, Sheed, Scharenberg, May, and Monfries missing here so shhhhh

Don't recruit drug cheats/injured blokes then :P

[Ricochet]

Nice work Levi!

Oh well, hopefully one day Ross can balance that ratio up

[meow meow]

Moscow have owned 3 out of that top 5 scaled up.

You're welcome.

[Holz]

Its time to start worrying everyone.

The Hawks estimate Roughead, who had the posterior cruciate ligament in his knee reconstructed in February, is around six weeks away from being available to play.

Surely Chris Yarran isnt too far away either.