Brandon Ellis v Dale Thomas

[seeds40]

I have no idea who to pick! i know Thomas is a lot cheaper but i do have enough to afford Ellis as well, ive heard both are having a good pre season, but don't know who to pick  :-\

[Ricochet]

Daisy. More proven and cheaper. Only concern you may have with him is if his ankle doesn't hold up through NAB Challenge. But if it does then you have to pick him over Ellis imo

[Mr.Craig]

If it was one or the other then yeah, Daisy.

[Sweetness]

Daisy is the "safer" option.
Though Ellis I reckon will turn Premo this year. Showed what he could do at stages last year and could be ther perfect POD to get you ahead of the pack early.

I'm also tossing it up..

[popedelio]

Thomas is a proven premium, as long he seems to be in good health come round 1 he is the obvious selection

[rider]

I'm locking in both at this stage but if it was 1 i'd go with Daisy.

[Adamant]

Thomas by a very long way.

[Memphistopheles]

No contest. Daisy by a long way. So much more value.

[Jroo]

Even though I love Ellis, Daisy for me.
Much more proven.

[CrowsFan]

I know Daisy offers great value, but I really don't think you can all be calling him a proven premium. He's only ever had 1 year averaging over 100, and that was just 102.9. His next best year has been 95.2. Hardly a proven premium in my opinion.

[Vinny]

95 is still a premium considering he was a forward and for his price has to be picked IMO.

[Jroo]

I know Daisy offers great value, but I really don't think you can all be calling him a proven premium. He's only ever had 1 year averaging over 100, and that was just 102.9. His next best year has been 95.2. Hardly a proven premium in my opinion.

Well he's more proven than Ellis  :P
I think that's what most of us meant.

[Toga]

I really want to include both..

[Nige]

I really want to include both..

Same here, and at the moment, I have.

Not sure whether it's a good move or not though.  :-\

[Master Q]

Daisy. Pretty overwhelming response so far  :P