NAB Rising Star Comp

[MTTY]

I'd say Aish, Kelly fighting it out with him right now.

[Toga]

Dunstan, Kelly and Aish I would think. Probably in that order for the time being although Aish has been steadily improving so far.

[Vinny]

I went for a smokey in Tom Langdon. Will probably come in now he has a nomination.

Like your thinking Ringo, Langdon looks pretty good.

[Mr.Craig]

My current Top 5 would be -

1. Langdon
2. Dunstan
3. Aish
4. KK
5. McDonald

[Ringo]

Squizzy is being pretty consistent as well so could surprise as well,

My order atm would be:

Langdon
Aish
Dunstan
KK
Taylor

[Toga]

1. Langdon
2. Kolo
3. Dunstan
4. Aish
5. McDonald

[GoLions]

My top 5 would be something like;

1. Langdon
2. Aish
3. Dunstan
4. KK
5. McDonald

Aish, Dunstan, KK could be in any order though I reckon

[Vinny]

1. Langdon
2. Kolo
3. Dunstan
4. Aish
5. McDonald

[Big Mac]

1. Langdon
2. Kolo
3. Dunstan
4. Aish
5. McDonald

Looks about right to me - might swap Dunstan and Aish but there's not much that separates them

[kilbluff1985]

do u guys think Merrett has a chance now?

[Nige]

do u guys think Merrett has a chance now?

He'll do well, but I don't think he'll win it.

[kilbluff1985]

He might even be good enough to get a game for the GWS 2's

don't you have a hole you can climb back into and stay there?

[Bill Manspeaker]

seriously think Dunstan is being ignored. without actually knowing the stats I would've guessed he's played the most games out of those eligible (Patton be up there as well I guess) and he's been consistent. sure he's not a flashy player, but he's hard at every contest and had a lot of clearances, tackles, and he's kicked a few goals. but again I'm not really sure of any stats

if he doesn't finish AT LEAST top 3 I'll kill everyone

Aish would up there in games played as well actually

[GoLions]

seriously think Dunstan is being ignored. without actually knowing the stats I would've guessed he's played the most games out of those eligible (Patton be up there as well I guess) and he's been consistent. sure he's not a flashy player, but he's hard at every contest and had a lot of clearances, tackles, and he's kicked a few goals. but again I'm not really sure of any stats

if he doesn't finish AT LEAST top 3 I'll kill everyone

Aish would up there in games played as well actually

Taylor hasn't missed a game and IMO is likely to finish higher than Aish if he plays out the season (which he should)

[kilbluff1985]

hows it work anyway the Bookies have/had Bontempelli fav but has only played half the season thought that was strange