The outside contenders

[Ricochet]

Personally I think if we played Hurley and Carlisle up forward it's pretty good with Belly

Pears should be in our best 22 hence having Carlisle and Hurley forward Hooker, Pears and Fletcher the key defenders and Carlisle, Belly, Hurley the 3 key forwards with Joe on the bench maybe not sure on him

Not many share the opinion of Carlisle and Hurley forward with Belly but I like having 3 talls with Hurley pushing up the ground

I do understand the whole ASADA thing but until it happens worry about it then

Bomber Thompson on where Carlisle and Hurley will play

AFL ‏@AFL 8m
@Laura_Perrett95 Correct. Carlisle will play forward and Hurley back #AskTheCoach

[kilbluff1985]

Not that it means that much

[Ricochet]

Still, you were on the ball about Carlisle playing fwd

[elephants]

Hurley is a much better backman IMO.

[TeeJay]

I loved Carlisle down back last year. He did some great jobs on high profile forwards. They really do need 2 of him

[Master Q]

Not going to read through the thread.

Voted Collingwood and Carlton as they are the only two teams with potential Top 4 lists on the poll.

[elephants]

Not going to read through the thread.

Voted Collingwood and Carlton as they are the only two teams with potential Top 4 lists on the poll.

Top 4 contenders generally have a forward/backline :P

[Bill Manspeaker]

I don't reckon Carlton have a potential top 4 list Q but we've chatted about this on the Saints board :P

potential top 8 definitely, not 4 imo

but each to their own mate, especially if you barrack for the team

although I don't rate the Saints top 4....   .....yet :P

[Master Q]

Richmond -> Fourth place behind Dons - Till Dusty shows up in big games, Cotchin overrated, JROO and Deledio good
Collingwood
Port Adelaide -> No way
Carlton
Essendon -> Already stated in this thread. I think Carlton and Collingwood are ahead anyway.
North Melbourne -> Don't think they have the list. They made finals in 2012 because Carlton and Essendon choked. I think they are like Essendon but just a few years behind.
Adelaide -> Overrated team. Tex is a beast though.
West Coast -> Nah

[Toga]

Cotchin overrated? You take that back Mr Q :P

[Master Q]

Most overrated players in the AFL

1. Martin
2. Cotchin
3. Dangerfield

[Mailman the 2nd]

Most overly criticised players in the AFL

1. Martin
2. Cotchin
3. Dangerfield

[Adamant]

Collingwood and Essendon for mine.

[JBs-Hawks]

Most overrated players in the AFL

1. Martin
2. Cotchin
3. All Carlton players

[Master Q]

Good one (y)