Any advice??

Started by Regs81, January 03, 2014, 12:00:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Regs81

Rookies will change come round 1. I think this looks pretty good, would love some feedback.. Thanks

BACKS:
Bartel, McVeigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Kolodjashnij, McDonald
(Fuller, Langford )

MIDS:
Ablett, Liberatore, Reddon, D. Beams, Shuey, D. Thomas, J. Martin, crouch
(Morabito , O'rouke)

RUCKS:
Pyke, Sandilands
(Lobb, Brown)

FORWARDS:
Dangerfield, Franklin, Dixon, Pavlich, Taylor , garlett
(Honeychurch, Kennedy-Harris)

benno123

Solid defensive set up. Would maybe downgrade one of your big 3 to a player around $500K to save some cash. Loving some of you midfield picks. Libba seems to be a 'popular' unique option, as an eagles fan thinking Shuey is in for a big year. Redden as well, but would upgrade one to a more proven player, too many risks for your midfield in my opinion. Love the Pyke pick, in my draft league got this this guy last season with my 2nd last pick as bench cover, and became my r1 by seasons end. Big fan of him, should improve with an even bigger role this year. Forwards pretty standard, liking Dixon for his R/F swing. Good side mate :)

johnnytheboy1

DEF: Maybe Downgrade Bartel to someone Cheaper who will score similar to save money
Mid: Would Upgrade Shuey to someone better e.g Watson.Like the Pick of Redden will improve even more this year.
Rucks: Pyke is now the No 1 Ruck at the Swans so his scores will climb.Sandi is a risk but worth taking at his price
Fwds: No Problems just need to see who the best rookies are before making a decision

Give you an 8/10 because of the unique picks you have.

shaker

Pretty much what the other guys have said maybe get Suckling in your backs and upgrade to 1 more proven gun in your mids

Regs81

Ok, I have made some changes.. How does it look now??

Backs:
Bartel, McVeigh, Swallow, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald
(Fuller,  hunt)

Mids:
Ablett, liberatore, Kennedy, redden, D.Beams, Shuey, D.Thomas, J.Martin
(Crouch, Amon)

Rucks:
Pyke, Sandilands
(Brown, lobb)

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Franklin, Pavlich, caddy, Taylor, garlett
(Kennedy-Harris, Honeychurch )

shaker

Would look better if you had Pendles Watson or Rockliff in the mids think you can get by with 5 plus Thomas a lot are going with 4 plus Thomas but we all will be making lots of changes when we see lots of rookies we have picked not playing round 1

Regs81

Who would you trade? I only have 5000 left

Bluesman


shaker

I would get rid of 2 between libba , kennedy , reddan , shuey and get one I mentioned plus who you can afford , murphy is under 500k

Regs81

Couple of changes::
Out: liberatore. In: pendlebury
Out: Shuey. In: claye beams

Thoughts??

Regs81


shaker

#11
You could spend that on 1 gun ruck or up grade Sandi .

Regs81

I think the rucks are ok.. Willing to risk it with Sandilands

shaker

You and many others myself will see how he is going by round 3 before jumping on

johnnytheboy1

Those changes have improved your Midfield just need to decide what to next as you have alot of money left.