PLEASE rate this SC Beast (I will do ur's)

Started by mjpaps, March 10, 2010, 12:03:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Please rate this team out of 10 for me...

8
4 (26.7%)
8.5
3 (20%)
9
7 (46.7%)
9.5
0 (0%)
10
1 (6.7%)

Total Members Voted: 2

c4v3m4n

IMO, upgrade Pendlebury. Statistically, Mitchell is the #1 player so far in the NAB Cup and I reckon he will carry that form through to the regular season.

lowedown11

ablett is almost a definate...dont hav to worry bout ur captain each week...i believe he will prob go down aswell but thats wot everyone said last year and look wot happened....still not sold on medhurst and greenwood but everything else is very nice....

mjpaps

I just traded Cooney for Ball.

Thats left me with $108,200

What to do now.
I dont really want to get Swan in.
Any other ideas...

Ricko

Backs : very solid.

Mids : Id look at maybe upgrading for a swan / ablett

rucks : cant really go wrong with that line up, skipper will have to play games considering taylor is out.

Forwards : very solid

8.5 / 10

tomsully


mjpaps

Quoteharry obrien. get rid of him. now.

Fair enuf.
I love HarryO.
Who for btw?

Kazahkstan

O'Brien is a good player, just not in SC.
How much cash in the bank?

mjpaps

I have $108,200

I was thinking of doing something in the midfield.
Or upgrading Rockliff or Davis...

Dunno

reesbr

Nice team but i have to agree that you need Ablett or Swan. Other than that it looks good. Nice ruckman and backline as well

milnesmarvels

nice team mate only thing im iffy about is obrien, he could be a gun or bum, good risk and i guess thats wot u need, i was looking at him but he plays that lock down role so if he has a good game on some1 then he does allrigh for himself

lowedown11

everyone said ablett would go down last year n look wot happened HE DIDNT...why take the risk n stuffin up ur whole year in thinkin u will get him wen he goes down but then he doesnt....he is ur skipper everyweek n wen he scores those 140+ each week then ur getting that score twice.....u hav to hav him to go somewhere in this comp!!!!

tekkag

Heres mine;

1. Maxwell, N
2. Symes, B
3. Bradley, K
4. Hayden, R
5. Baker, S
6. Everitt, A
7. Malceski, N
23. Greenwood, L
24. Thursfield, W
8. Montagna, L
9. Judd, C
10. Boyd, M
11. Jack, K
12. Masten, C
13. Walker, A
25. Clarke, X
26. Barlow, M
14. McIntosh, H
15. Kreuzer, M
27. Hille, D
28. Naitanui, N
16. Johnson, S
17. Dangerfield, P
18. Hooper, R
19. Gamble, R
20. Lonergan, T
21. Hentschel, T
22. Staker, B
29. Wonaeamirri, A
30. Gumbleton, S

I had $10,000 left and have Montagna as my Captain and Judd as VC, i have at least one player from every club except port

Let me know what you think. thanks!!!!

Hippo

space it out dude you can't see where the positions start or finish.. throw in a couple of returns and your sweet

mjpaps

#28
Seriously tekkag wtf are u doin?
u could have atleast commented on my team before u hijacked my thread...
start ur own

Not cool... >:(

either way...
I do think ur backline is weak. Should try n get Enright / Shaw. Hodge is a MUST.
Midfield is sweet, However Judd is out for a few.
Rucks are great, abit of wasted cash here i reckon. Put in a few kids to get some cash.
Forwardline could use some serious jiggin.

Only my thoughts 1.5 / 10

lowedown11

7/10 must be his mate....1.5/10 is generous