How is Your Balance and Check Out Mine

[Madmax75]

I have picked this team with balance in mind. Also originally had Kruezer and Tippet in ruck but have switched to Sandilands and Hmac . What do you think and how balanced is your team?

B Goddard Enright S Fisher Hodge Malceski Ladson Mcguire ( P Davis Trengrove)
C Ablett J Selwood Harvey Cooney Trengove Rohan ( Barlow Bastinac)
R Sandilands McIntosh (Warnock Lobbe)
F Riewoldt Okeefe Tippet Dangerfield B Hall Rockcliffe Ziebell (Dennis-Lane Tarrant)

[c4v3m4n]

Hey there,

Backs - Its a solid backline except for Maguire. IMO, It is a risk putting him onfield, he probably should be on your bench.

Centre - Again its solid but...Harvey is getting a little old and might struggle to recapture that amazing form he used to have.

Rucks - Very very solid. Nothing wrong there.

Forwards - Rockliff is the same as Maguire. IMO, should be on the bench. Apart from that is a decent forward line.

In conclusion, if you can find the cash (maybe after downgrading Harvey or HMac) upgrade Trengove to Shoenmakers, Greenwood, Gillies, or Hunt and uprgrade Tarrant to Mayne, Ballantyne, Walker or Warren.

Hope that helps.

Good luck and happy supercoaching!  :D

[Wastelander]

Nice team,
I'm not a huge fan of Ladson and Maguire in defence.
Midfield is solid, a lot of people are starting 2 rookies in the mid, (myself included. . . .After much debate).
Rucks are very strong.
Forward is also fairly solid, though Rockliff starting means you'll need to make sure both benched forwards are going to get games, and rotate, which, as long as you have the right bench combo wont be a problem. (Same thing for defence and mid)