Bartel v McVeigh v Walker v Mitchell

[joshua98]

3 ageing stars who have gained DPP as well as a player who's role may vary. Which players, in order, would you pick for your side in 2014?

[nib]

1. Mcveigh
2. Mitchell
3. Bartel
4. Walker

[kilbluff1985]

1. Mcveigh
2. Mitchell
3. Bartel
4. Walker

Swap Mitchell and McVeigh

[Big Dawg]

1. Mitchell
2. McVeigh
3. Walker
4. Bartel

[Jroo]

I have McVeigh locked in.
Then I'm considering the other 3 for my D2.
ATM it's
1. McVeigh
2. Bartel
3. Mitchell
4. Walker

[shorty3264]

I think Sam Mitchell is clear first personally. He will play the most midfield time. Then McVeigh, and Bartel just pipping Walker. However I think the first two will score quite a bit better than the latter. So yeh Mitchell, McVeigh, Bartel, Walker for mine.

[specky92]

1. Mitchell
2. McVeigh
3. Walker
4. Bartel

I agree with his one, Mitchell is Mr.Consistent and was in my team last year, will average 105 again

[Footyrulz]

1. mitchell (scores 105+ every year)
2. mcveigh (younger than mitch and bartel, very consistent scorer)
3. bartel (also a good option, but quite old and unlike mitchell, only had 1 105+ year)
4. walker (theres a chance he could move forward again which would ruin his scoring, too risky at that price)

[kilbluff1985]

Mitchell
McVeigh
Walker
Bartel

imo

[_wato]

In terms of points scored Mcveigh may have it but for ppg Mitchell should have it by the end of the year.

I want Mitchell but can't fit him in because of his bye. Mcveigh is the suitor to my team personally so I'd say the best choice is Mcveigh.

[GoLions]

1 - Mitchell
2 - McVeigh

Walker and Bartel probably a tie for 3rd

[Bones Bombers]

All four players could play different positions this year, making it a little harder to predict.

1-Mitchell, wether mostly mid or back I'd put him first.
2- McVeigh, if playing across half back. If McVeigh plays predominately mid, Jimmy should outscore him.
3- whoever is left from 2.
4- Walker, with Daisy and Carrots in the team not sure where he will be and not confident he will score as well.

I do take past season averages into consideration too, meaning I like Mitch and Jimmy.

[quinny88]

Mitchell
Mcveigh
Walker
Bartel

All good options though. I'm personally starting Mitchell and McVeigh

[dmac07]

Im starting mitchell and mcveigh, which seems to be the consensus that those two are ahead of the others.

[nrich102]

1. McVeigh
2. Mitchell
3. Bartel
4. Walker