PAV vs FRANKLIN

[Oricle]

I'm stuck on deciding between these two. Pav is a champion but has his best past him? Can he put on his cape and become superpav again? Franklin is in his prime but sharing a fwd line with a lot of good players who could steal points. Who would you take?

[kilbluff1985]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

[quinny88]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

That will indicate nothing KB. We know how seriously teams take the pre season comp. Sydney in particular treat it like the joke that it is.

I'm starting both if they are both fit come round one. Both bargain prices and both capable of averaging 100+

[kilbluff1985]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

That will indicate nothing KB. We know how seriously teams take the pre season comp. Sydney in particular treat it like the joke that it is.

I'm starting both if they are both fit come round one. Both bargain prices and both capable of averaging 100+

yeah forgot about Sydneys attitude towards preseason games but i reckon they will average around the same

[Jimmykidd]

ill be starting both. absolutely. GET EM IN!

[Mailman the 2nd]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

That will indicate nothing KB. We know how seriously teams take the pre season comp. Sydney in particular treat it like the joke that it is.

I'm starting both if they are both fit come round one. Both bargain prices and both capable of averaging 100+

yeah forgot about Sydneys attitude towards preseason games but i reckon they will average around the same

You would be very lucky to see either Tippett or Franklin at the Nab games

[quinny88]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

That will indicate nothing KB. We know how seriously teams take the pre season comp. Sydney in particular treat it like the joke that it is.

I'm starting both if they are both fit come round one. Both bargain prices and both capable of averaging 100+

yeah forgot about Sydneys attitude towards preseason games but i reckon they will average around the same

You would be very lucky to see either Tippett or Franklin at the Nab games

Yeah exactly what I was thinking haha. Most the Sydney players will have "general soreness"

[Ricochet]

Buddy just I reckon. Just has it on Pav in age and scoring potential with Pav now soley a lead up full forward and not getting the mid rotations any more

[Nails]

i don't think you can make this call until hopefully Buddy and Tippett play together in the NAB Challenge see how they go

That will indicate nothing KB. We know how seriously teams take the pre season comp. Sydney in particular treat it like the joke that it is.

I'm starting both if they are both fit come round one. Both bargain prices and both capable of averaging 100+

yeah forgot about Sydneys attitude towards preseason games but i reckon they will average around the same

You would be very lucky to see either Tippett or Franklin at the Nab games

Yeah exactly what I was thinking haha. Most the Sydney players will have "general soreness"

They don't really list general soreness/reasons for NAB cup. You can take as much as you want in NAB iirc.

[quinny88]

Buddy just I reckon. Just has it on Pav in age and scoring potential with Pav now soley a lead up full forward and not getting the mid rotations any more

He was in 2012 though to wasn't he ric? He did he still play some mid?

[meow meow]

Pav is the exception to the rule. He has always scored better when playing as a forward.

[Footyrulz]

Buddy easily if u have the cash.

Pav could easily get injured or keep dropping off.

[Hippo]

Both

[redfield]

Franklin for me.

[Jroo]

Franklin. I wouldn't be worried about his teammates stealing points. The Hawks' forward line is better than the Swans and it didn't really affect him there.