Surely The Prices Arent Right ???

[Just2Good]

TEAM NAME: A Bit Early
DEF: K. Simpson, T. McKenzie, G. Birchall, B. Waters, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg (J. Bews, D. Gardiner)
MID: J. Selwood, N. Fyfe, T. Liberatore, T. Cotchin, M. Murphy, D. Beams, D. Tyson, C. Beams (J. Martin, T. Varcoe)
RUC: W. Minson, A. Sandilands (D. Currie, L. McBean)
FWD: T. Rockliff, S. Motlop, C. Dixon, D. Thomas, V. Michie, A. Fasolo (T. Banfield, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $184,800

This is the second team I have made and the prices have changed heaps and it was so much easier to pick a team so is there something wrong with the prices?

Anyways leave your thoughts on the team rookies will change during pre season and what not but the premiums are set at the moment

leave your thoughts guys cheers


 

[GoLions]

Defence is solid. I usually don't comment on rookies, but heard Sharenberg is unlikely to play round 1
Probably best to have just the 5 midfield premiums to start with, as the best rookies are in the midfield. I would drop Murphy for a  rookie, and upgrade Fyfe or Cotchin to one of Watson/Pendles/Ablett/Dangerfield (or upgrade both)
Rucks look good, I think Sandi is worth the risk, although quite a few will disagree here
Forwards seem decent. I'm hoping Rockliff keeps his DPP, but there's a good chance he'll lose it. Would replace with Dusty if he does lose DPP (assuming Dusty keeps his as well)

Overall not a bad team, just the midfield needs a bit of tinkering IMO

[johnnytheboy1]

Hi Just2Good,

The Price on Travis Varcoe is surely incorrect be more like 327000 anyway this is how i rate your team
Def: I would replace Scharenberg with Luke Mcdonald if he has DPP as Scharenberg won't get early games for the magpies.Rest of the defence is OK.
Mids: Maybe Replace Murphy with Dangerfield or someone else who will be consistent each week.
Rucks Solid
Fwds: As long as Rockliff is listed as a Fwd or has DPP YOU HAVE A STRONG Fwd Line

Overall very evenly balanced team missing 2  premiums in Gazza & Pendles but still a decent midfieldshould be competitive. 7.5/10

[Just2Good]

when the actual prices come out I will change the team a lot but at the moment I am happy with the team. If I still have so much money left over I will upgrade say Murphy to another premium or even say motlop to Martin but at the moment im trying to keep a lot of money available.

So you reckon I should down grade a mid to a rookie and then get an upgrade somewhere else ?

[GoLions]

I would downgrade Murphy to a rookie, upgrade Cotchin or Fyfe to Pendlebury, and upgrade Dixon to Dusty

[Just2Good]

yeah okay do you know which rookie is the best option that I don't have and thanks for the feed back guys

[Big Mac]

Put in Dunstan/Crouch/Sheed for now, we won't know who will have a spot in their 22 for a couple months yet.

[Grazz]

Yeh I got a feeling the prices aren't right, teams just look to strong, could be wrong but a lot look to strong. :-\

[Vinny]

Yeh I got a feeling the prices aren't right, teams just look to strong, could be wrong but a lot look to strong. :-\

I agree, think most discounts and things are off.  :(

SC are cruel, they will find anyway to make us do shower.

[Grazz]

Yeh I got a feeling the prices aren't right, teams just look to strong, could be wrong but a lot look to strong. :-\

I agree, think most discounts and things are off.  :(

SC are cruel, they will find anyway to make us do shower.

For sure mate, mungrels lol.

[kilbluff1985]

just remember this year we could afford about 15/16 premos so just go off that

[Ringo]

Yes will be interesting to see how many of these teams are actually affordable when true prices come out.  I remember this year the team I had with the structure I liked went from being 34k under the cap to $220k over the cap as an example.

Team yopu have atm looks good but think at this stage you have one prem mid to many. I would downgrade one and get another prem forward in as I do not think Motlop or Dixon will be in top 8 forwards.