Quinnys team

[quinny88]

Had done well not to get caught up in these damn super early team planners that will look 90% different by round 1 but boredom got the better of me :(

B: B.Goddard, J.Mcveigh, G.Birchall, B.Waters, M.Suckling, M.Scharenberg (J.Kolodjashjij, rookie)

M: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Watson, T.Rockliff, D.Beams, D.Tyson, C.Beams, J.Martin (M.Crouch, rookie)

R: N.Naitanui, H.Mcintosh (S.Naismith, L.Mcbean)

F: D.Martin, L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, D.Thomas, A.Fasolo, V.Michie (J.Hogan, rookie)

My knowledge of the rookies isn't great, hence why I haven't named all positions. That will be decided during the pre season
Goddard probably won't be a defender but he sits there for now. Rocky I'm assuming will only be a mid for now.
Hmac and Pavlich are both on notice depending on how they get through pre season. Rioli another tempting prospect to consider.
My bye structure is none existent at this stage but will develop it better when I have the patience.

Fire away  ;D

[kilbluff1985]

it's honestly pretty standard at this stage mate not much wrong with it at all really

[quinny88]

it's honestly pretty standard at this stage mate not much wrong with it at all really

Thanks KB yeh it's a bit boring at this time of year. Everyone's teams look very similar

[johnnytheboy1]

Quinny you have a team that will be competitive as long as you have taken into account the Byes and whether Goddard will lose DPPas i presume he will be a Mid in 2014
Also interesting to see if Rockliff holds DPP.
Anyway as i go through your team apart from Scharenberg who probably won't be in the senior side in Round 1 apart from that a decent team on all lines.just need to fill in the rookie positions

7.5/10

[quinny88]

Quinny you have a team that will be competitive as long as you have taken into account the Byes and whether Goddard will lose DPPas i presume he will be a Mid in 2014
Also interesting to see if Rockliff holds DPP.
Anyway as i go through your team apart from Scharenberg who probably won't be in the senior side in Round 1 apart from that a decent team on all lines.just need to fill in the rookie positions

7.5/10

Thanks Johnny.
Yeah I don't really expect Goddard to be defender, I will replace him with either Simpson or someone else.
Byes have not been taken into account but it will be easy enough to shift one or 2 players around to even it up.
Thanks for the feedback

[Noz]

Out Martin
In Wingard

The rest is pretty standard mate.

[Ringo]

May want to reconsider Naismith as he is still only on a the Swans Rookie list - may be OK if he is the last Swan to be promoted. Keep an eye on.

I am one of the few that thinks Rocky may keep DPP mainly due to the fact he spent more than half a season forward,

If Nat keeps his DPP have you thought of moving him forward and then selecting another ruck. Mr Bean will no doubt keep the DPP.

[quinny88]

Out Martin
In Wingard

The rest is pretty standard mate.

Haha let's not go there

[quinny88]

May want to reconsider Naismith as he is still only on a the Swans Rookie list - may be OK if he is the last Swan to be promoted. Keep an eye on.

I am one of the few that thinks Rocky may keep DPP mainly due to the fact he spent more than half a season forward,

If Nat keeps his DPP have you thought of moving him forward and then selecting another ruck. Mr Bean will no doubt keep the DPP.

Yeah Naismith is a wait and see. That position in the ruck is causing me some headaches.
If rocky keeps dpp he will certainly go forward. I actually hope that he doesn't though so that he becomes a bit of a unique.
I think there's value in the forward line so will probably keep nicnat in the ruck regardless.

Thanks for the feedback ringo