SCISM 2024

[bomberboy0618]

First draf for the year. Fire away.

SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $45,100.

Jimmy Bartel, Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Beau Waters, Matt Suckling, Matt Scharenberg
Zak Jones, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Jobe Watson, Nathan Fyfe, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Luke McDonald, Dominic Sheed, Jack Martin
Tom Langdon, Luke Dunstan

Shane Mumford, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Toby Nankervis

Tom Rockliff, Jarryd Roughead, Nic Naitanui, Matthew Pavlich, Taylor Walker, Jesse Hogan
Jay Kennedy-Harris, Ben Brown

[nas]

Walker injured & not due till mid year

[bomberboy0618]

Walker injured & not due till mid year

Damn. Will swap him for Dale Thomas.


SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $3,100.

Jimmy Bartel, Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Beau Waters, Matt Suckling, Matt Scharenberg
Zak Jones, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Jobe Watson, Nathan Fyfe, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Luke McDonald, Dominic Sheed, Jack Martin
Tom Langdon, Luke Dunstan

Shane Mumford, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Toby Nankervis

[johnnytheboy1]

You Haven't included your fwd line in your updated team.
May want to look at Michie instead of Taylor Walker also not sure whether goddard and Rockliff will keep DPP so you may need to adjust those positions. Apart from that a strong team with the Unique pick of Luke Hodge in defence. Can't see Scharenberg being in Collingwoods senior team in Round 1. So i give your team a 7/10

[_wato]

You Haven't included your fwd line in your updated team.
May want to look at Michie instead of Taylor Walker also not sure whether goddard and Rockliff will keep DPP so you may need to adjust those positions. Apart from that a strong team with the Unique pick of Luke Hodge in defence. Can't see Scharenberg being in Collingwoods senior team in Round 1. So i give your team a 7/10

Geez buddy, bit harsh on the rating? 7/10 for this team? Easily an 8-8.5/10, has good premiums across all lines, good rookie choices and good mid pricers. Agree there is some things I'd change but that is open for discussion.

Hate to see what you'd rate your own team. If it was 10 it'd have to be bloody good.

[Ringo]

Just concerned with Goddard retaining DPP - expect him to be a mid only. Expect Rocky to maintain DPP this year though given he spent half of last year in forward line.
Like most teams a lot will depend on rookies playing to complete lines.  Not rating teams at this stage for that reason. eg Looking at this team atm he is relying on playing 3 rookies playing each week a pretty tall order.

[bomberboy0618]

You Haven't included your fwd line in your updated team.
May want to look at Michie instead of Taylor Walker also not sure whether goddard and Rockliff will keep DPP so you may need to adjust those positions. Apart from that a strong team with the Unique pick of Luke Hodge in defence. Can't see Scharenberg being in Collingwoods senior team in Round 1. So i give your team a 7/10

Oops. Here it is.

SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $3,100.

Jimmy Bartel, Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Beau Waters, Matt Suckling, Matt Scharenberg
Zak Jones, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Jobe Watson, Nathan Fyfe, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Luke McDonald, Dominic Sheed, Jack Martin
Tom Langdon, Luke Dunstan

Shane Mumford, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Toby Nankervis

Tom Rockliff, Jarryd Roughead, Nic Naitanui, Matthew Pavlich, Dale Thomas, Jesse Hogan
Jay Kennedy-Harris, Ben Brown

And ringo- I think Jack Martin is a lock to play each week. That leaves four rookies to find. Think I can nail that.

[_wato]

And ringo- I think Jack Martin is a lock to play each week. That leaves four rookies to find. Think I can nail that.

You can lock in Sheed and Hogan to play every week also. Luke Dunstan is a pretty safe bet at St Kilda, not so sure on McDonald at North, same with Scharenberg. That one defender spot is the one you need to nail. Best of luck mate.

[bomberboy0618]

And ringo- I think Jack Martin is a lock to play each week. That leaves four rookies to find. Think I can nail that.

You can lock in Sheed and Hogan to play every week also. Luke Dunstan is a pretty safe bet at St Kilda, not so sure on McDonald at North, same with Scharenberg. That one defender spot is the one you need to nail. Best of luck mate.

l
Cheers man. I agree. Scharenberg just place holding. I actually don't think the team will change much besides the rookies though.

[GoLions]

Oops. Here it is.

SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $3,100.

Jimmy Bartel, Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Beau Waters, Matt Suckling, Matt Scharenberg
Zak Jones, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Jobe Watson, Nathan Fyfe, Trent Cotchin, Dayne Beams, Luke McDonald, Dominic Sheed, Jack Martin
Tom Langdon, Luke Dunstan

Shane Mumford, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Toby Nankervis

Tom Rockliff, Jarryd Roughead, Nic Naitanui, Matthew Pavlich, Dale Thomas, Jesse Hogan
Jay Kennedy-Harris, Ben Brown

And ringo- I think Jack Martin is a lock to play each week. That leaves four rookies to find. Think I can nail that.

Doubt Goddard will retain DPP, as Ringo already said. Can switch him for any other defender of your choice. Hodge is a nice POD, hopefully it works out for you
Mids look pretty good
Ruck is a risk with both Mummy and Sandi, but I think it could pay off
May have gone too heavy in forwards with the value there next season. Fasolo, Karnezis, and Higgins are all options if named round 1

Pretty decent team, probably an 8/10

[bomberboy0618]

SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $40,000.

Jimmy Bartel, Jarrad McVeigh, Luke Hodge, Brent Reilly, Matt Suckling, Luke McDonald
Jeremy Laidler, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Jobe Watson, Nathan Fyfe, Dayne Beams, Dale Thomas, Jack Martin, James Aish, Xavier Ellis
Luke Dunstan, Dayle Garlett

Nic Naitanui, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Toby Nankervis

Steve Johnson, Patrick Dangerfield, Matthew Pavlich, Shaun Higgins, Alex Fasolo, Shane Kersten
Jay Kennedy-Harris, Mitch Honeychurch

New team with prices updated. Thoughts?

[_wato]

Defence looks fine, but not sure on Brent Reilly though. JS isn't as good as previous years, hence why he didn't play after Round 14 last year. Hodge could be a risk with him always sustaining injuries, but hopefully he scores well and stays uninjured for your sake.

Mids look ok, and I say that only because you're missing Scott Pendlebury. You really need him man, get him in over Watson. Good choice of rookies however, and I like your choice of Nat Fyfe.

Rucks are standard and look good.

SJ isn't a forward next year so I suggest swapping with Martin/Franklin. Look at Mitch Clark over the preseason and if he's fit lock him in. Priced at $240k and should average 80~

Few changes need to be made but otherwise good. Best of luck mate.

[Ringo]

Not a bad team BomberBoy

With the prices this year hard to get the ideal structure right early.

Not commenting on rookies at this stage as it will be subjective without seeing them play.  Only thing I will see when finalising rookies ensure you have those that you want to make cash playing from Round 1 so you can maximise them during the early byes.

Defense is sound
Mids: Daisy at Mid 5 is a risk but if he can make money and upgrade early to a 5th prem not a bad move. Do not expect him to be that 5th prem though.
Rucks; Seems to be the favoured paring at this stage.
FWDS Johnson not a forward so look at replacing him with Martin/Franklin or N Roo and just use cash elsewhere.

[bomberboy0618]

Cheers guys. Looks like I'm gonna go Johnson-Martin and Watson-Franklin, and Reilly-whoever.

[bomberboy0618]

SC Is Serious Mum Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by bomber5186. Salary cap left: $40,900.

Jarrad McVeigh, Pearce Hanley, Shannon Hurn, Matt Suckling, Sam Darley, Jeremy Laidler
Matthew Fuller, Jake Kolodjashnij

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Jobe Watson, Dayne Beams, Dale Thomas, Jack Martin, Dom Tyson, Viv Michie
Luke Dunstan, Matt Crouch

Will Minson, Shane Mumford
Rory Lobb, Toby Nankervis

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Lance Franklin, Alex Fasolo, Ben Lennon, Shane Kersten
Dayle Garlett, Lewis Taylor

Updated team. Personally think the structure is sound. Thoughts?