Jukes' Annual Feedback and Analysis Thread

[Azzas Dockers]

Cheers for the feedback Jukes! Really appreciate it! I see where you're coming with Watson but I don't think i'd be able to give up Swan, I like my M1-M5 too much I don't think I would be able to get rid of any, which is probably a bad thing,

If I decided my rucks where too much, would you say keep Nic Nat or Kreuzer?

With Nic Nat coming off an injury interrupted year, I think you would have to go with him providing his preseason\nab cup form looks good.

[djfloorboy]

TEAM NAME: Gotta be more
DEF: S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, J. Grimes, M. Clarke, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (C. Howard, J. Bews)
MID: M. Barlow, B. Stanton, P. Dangerfield, J. Watson, D. Thomas, J. Martin, L. McDonald, D. Tyson (S. Gray, D. Van Unen)
RUC: M. Kreuzer, H. McIntosh (A. Sandilands, B. Longer)
FWD: C. Wingard, J. Roughead, L. Franklin, D. Zorko, J. Caddy, J. Hogan (R. Nahas, N. Bock)
CASH LEFT: $0

Here's my first attempt - with pros and cons.  All feedback welcome.

Cheers  :)

[benjy251090]

benjy251090 Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by ben251090. Salary cap left: $290,400.

Jarrad McVeigh, Sam Mitchell, Jimmy Bartel, Matt Suckling, Luke McDonald, Matthew Fuller
Christian Howard, Jeremy Laidler

Scott Pendlebury, Scott Selwood, Dayne Beams, Marc Murphy, Jack Martin, James Aish, Tom Rockliff, Viv Michie
Claye Beams, Xavier Ellis

Will Minson, Aaron Sandilands
Billy Longer, Daniel Currie

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Jarryd Roughead, Mitchell Clark, Alex Fasolo, Gary Rohan
Nathan Bock, Mitch Honeychurch

[Jukesy]

TEAM NAME: Gotta be more
DEF: S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, J. Grimes, M. Clarke, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (C. Howard, J. Bews)
MID: M. Barlow, B. Stanton, P. Dangerfield, J. Watson, D. Thomas, J. Martin, L. McDonald, D. Tyson (S. Gray, D. Van Unen)
RUC: M. Kreuzer, H. McIntosh (A. Sandilands, B. Longer)
FWD: C. Wingard, J. Roughead, L. Franklin, D. Zorko, J. Caddy, J. Hogan (R. Nahas, N. Bock)
CASH LEFT: $0

Here's my first attempt - with pros and cons.  All feedback welcome.

Cheers  :)

Likes
dat cash left :P
Stants and Hoges :D
Super ruck depth. Pretty sure you'll be able to rely on one of HMac, Sandi and Longer to play every week, at a stretch :P
Good forward line. Apart from my man Hoges, Caddy and Zorks are great picks imo.

Dislikes
Pretty weak backline. Marty Clarke- really? For my WXV's sake I hope he's best 22 and will score decent enough, but won't let him within a kilometre of my DT. Maybe if he was a bit cheaper, but at 350k...Other than that, two old blokes and an injury-prone guy for premos may hurt.
Gray and Van Unen on your midfield bench- I'd probably try and scrounge up the money to upgrade one of them to somebody better. The rest of the midfield is good though.

Ratings
D: 7/10
M: 8.75/10
R: 8/10
F: 9.25/10
Overall: 8.35/10 uniquely structured team with a few very good selections

[Jukesy]

benjy251090 Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by ben251090. Salary cap left: $290,400.

Jarrad McVeigh, Sam Mitchell, Jimmy Bartel, Matt Suckling, Luke McDonald, Matthew Fuller
Christian Howard, Jeremy Laidler

Scott Pendlebury, Scott Selwood, Dayne Beams, Marc Murphy, Jack Martin, James Aish, Tom Rockliff, Viv Michie
Claye Beams, Xavier Ellis

Will Minson, Aaron Sandilands
Billy Longer, Daniel Currie

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Jarryd Roughead, Mitchell Clark, Alex Fasolo, Gary Rohan
Nathan Bock, Mitch Honeychurch

Likes
Pretty well rounded team- no huge faults in both on-field and depth components.
Solid midfield, should give you good cash and points.

Dislikes
iffy backline- three old blokes, an guy coming off an LTI, and a load of rookies. Not my heaven. Other than that pretty good, as I said earlier no huge faults that could cause you added stress.

Ratings
D: 7.5/10
M: 9/10
R: 7.75/10
F: 8/10
Overall: 8.2/10 well rounded and no huge faults but could be better

[middo1985]

First attempt. I'm usually pretty woeful at dream team so looking to put a little more effort in this season!

Nigel Cats Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by NigelCats. Salary cap left: $49,600.

Sam Mitchell, Grant Birchall, Liam Picken, Matt Suckling, Kade Kolodjashnij, Luke McDonald
Matthew Fuller, Christian Howard

Scott Pendlebury, Matthew Boyd, Ryan Bastinac, Jack Grimes, Matthew de Boer, Andrew Gaff, Dom Sheed, Claye Beams
Xavier Ellis, Jared Polec

Will Minson, Aaron Sandilands
Billy Longer, Daniel Currie

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Josh J. Kennedy, Dayne Zorko, Josh Caddy, Jesse Hogan
Jack Billings, Dayle Garlett

[The_Captain]

First attempt. I'm usually pretty woeful at dream team so looking to put a little more effort in this season!

Nigel Cats Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by NigelCats. Salary cap left: $49,600.

Sam Mitchell, Grant Birchall, Liam Picken, Matt Suckling, Kade Kolodjashnij, Luke McDonald
Matthew Fuller, Christian Howard

Scott Pendlebury, Matthew Boyd, Ryan Bastinac, Jack Grimes, Matthew de Boer, Andrew Gaff, Dom Sheed, Claye Beams
Xavier Ellis, Jared Polec

Will Minson, Aaron Sandilands
Billy Longer, Daniel Currie

Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Josh J. Kennedy, Dayne Zorko, Josh Caddy, Jesse Hogan
Jack Billings, Dayle Garlett

1/10. Would not bang.

[middo1985]

I think I covered that possibility with my assertion that I suck at this.

So perhaps the reason for posting is to get useful feedback...

Any suggestions as to changes I should make?

[Azzas Dockers]

Sam Mitchell, Grant Birchall, Liam Picken, Matt Suckling, Kade Kolodjashnij, Luke McDonald
Matthew Fuller, Christian Howard
Scott Pendlebury, Matthew Boyd, Ryan Bastinac, Jack Grimes, Matthew de Boer, Andrew Gaff, Dom Sheed, Claye Beams
Xavier Ellis, Jared Polec
Will Minson, Aaron Sandilands
Billy Longer, Daniel Currie
Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin, Josh J. Kennedy, Dayne Zorko, Josh Caddy, Jesse Hogan
Jack Billings, Dayle Garlett

Here is my attempt to help you out

I do not see any value in your midfield at all except Beams.
Scott Pendlebury - good but not much increase
Matthew Boyd - old, injury prone.
Ryan Bastinac - why
Jack Grimes -If you have Jack Grimes, pick him as a defender. ,
Matthew de Boer - not gauranteed best 22, will not improve score from last year.
Andrew Gaff - is easily tagged out of games.
Dom Sheed - Their are cheaper player at his price.

If you replaced these players with some of these B. Deledio, J. Watson, D. Beams, M. Murphy, S. Savage, D. Thomas, V. Michie I think it will save you cash.
Michie is priced cheaper then sheed, and scored 85+ points in the wafl.
Beams, Murphy, Thomas are all under priced.
Savage played as a sub 6+ times (from memory), will gain in price.

Swap  Josh J. Kennedy with Franklin, Franklin will out score Kennedy, will increase in price and may also me cheaper than Kennedy.

Liam Picken,Kade Kolodjashnij, Luke McDonald - I would keep a very close eye on these guys, I do not think they will score that well.

If you swapped these for P. Hanley and  P. Seedsman, started Fuller and added a rookie you would save cash and get more points. All you would have to do is find a rookie.

Rucks are not bad, Minson will score quiet well but as he played so well last year I do not expect him to increase in price. I would consider McEvoy, Mumford or  Natanui.

Some things to think about at least.

[middo1985]

Cheers Azzas, really appreciate it!

[djfloorboy]

TEAM NAME: Gotta be more
DEF: S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, J. Grimes, M. Clarke, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij (C. Howard, J. Bews)
MID: M. Barlow, B. Stanton, P. Dangerfield, J. Watson, D. Thomas, J. Martin, L. McDonald, D. Tyson (S. Gray, D. Van Unen)
RUC: M. Kreuzer, H. McIntosh (A. Sandilands, B. Longer)
FWD: C. Wingard, J. Roughead, L. Franklin, D. Zorko, J. Caddy, J. Hogan (R. Nahas, N. Bock)
CASH LEFT: $0

Here's my first attempt - with pros and cons.  All feedback welcome.

Cheers  :)

Likes
dat cash left :P
Stants and Hoges :D
Super ruck depth. Pretty sure you'll be able to rely on one of HMac, Sandi and Longer to play every week, at a stretch :P
Good forward line. Apart from my man Hoges, Caddy and Zorks are great picks imo.

Dislikes
Pretty weak backline. Marty Clarke- really? For my WXV's sake I hope he's best 22 and will score decent enough, but won't let him within a kilometre of my DT. Maybe if he was a bit cheaper, but at 350k...Other than that, two old blokes and an injury-prone guy for premos may hurt.
Gray and Van Unen on your midfield bench- I'd probably try and scrounge up the money to upgrade one of them to somebody better. The rest of the midfield is good though.

Ratings
D: 7/10
M: 8.75/10
R: 8/10
F: 9.25/10
Overall: 8.35/10 uniquely structured team with a few very good selections

Thanks heaps for your thoughts.  A revamp has produced the side below.  I would appreciate your thoughts on this next try.

TEAM NAME: Gotta be more
DEF: S. Mitchell, J. Bartel, N. Vlastuin, M. Suckling, K. Kolodjashnij, M. Fuller (C. Howard, J. Bews)
MID: L. Montagna, B. Stanton, D. Beams, M. Murphy, D. Thomas, J. Caddy, J. Martin, L. McDonald (M. Crouch, V. Michie)
RUC: D. Cox, H. McIntosh (M. Apeness, B. Longer)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, C. Wingard, L. Franklin, C. Dixon, J. Hogan, A. Fasolo (R. Nahas, N. Bock)
CASH LEFT: $1,200

[Jukes]

I'm going to be taking a temporary leave of absence from this thread- not really feeling up to it, been very busy and with uni starting soon...will hopefully get back into it a few weeks before round 1.

Sorry for not rating the most recent teams.

[muntedmyke]

TEAM NAME: muntitmyke
DEF: S. Mitchell, P. Hanley, P. Seedsman, J. Grimes, D. Swallow, S. Docherty (K. Aylett, J. Battersby)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, J. Selwood, B. Goddard, D. Beams, S. Savage, D. Thomas, T. Curren, C. Beams (J. O'Rourke, J. Polec)
RUC: N. Naitanui, A. Sandilands (S. Naismith, D. Currie)
FWD: N. Riewoldt, C. Wingard, C. Sylvia, L. Franklin, A. Schneider, G. Rohan (S. Kersten, D. Markworth)

[lachie_001]

TEAM NAME: Danger
DEF: J. McVeigh, R. Henderson, P. Hanley, M. Suckling, M. Fuller, J. Laidler (L. McDonald, C. Howard)
MID: S. Johnson, G. Ablett, J. Selwood, M. Barlow, D. Beams, M. Grigg, D. Tyson, X. Ellis (L. Dunstan, J. Polec)
RUC: M. Kreuzer, M. Lobbe (B. Longer, D. Currie)
FWD: P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, L. Franklin, G. Rohan, M. Clark, M. Honeychurch (S. Kersten, D. Garlett)

CASH LEFT: $131, 000

[eaglesman]

mcveigh mitchell walker grimes suckling darley (kolodjashnij, fuller)

scott selwood fyfe beams murphy savage thomas martin ellis (polec templeton)

cox sandi (longer thurlow)

dangerfield martin parker chapman, lewis taylor, garlett (bock kersten)

$30,100

thoughts please mate