Who should Collingwood draft? / Draft Discussion Thread

[T Dog]

There is talk ramping up that Aish at 6 and Scharenberg at 10  8)

I've seen mock drafts with both Aish and Berg going at 1 or 2. now that probably won't happen, but just goes to show how highly both are rated. if Collingwood get both with 6 and 10, then holy shower.... smells fishy.. but that could just be my anti-pie radar going off.

massive congratulations if you get both

Anti - Pie Radar?....lol...not possible... ;D

[Bill Manspeaker]

There is talk ramping up that Aish at 6 and Scharenberg at 10  8)

I've seen mock drafts with both Aish and Berg going at 1 or 2. now that probably won't happen, but just goes to show how highly both are rated. if Collingwood get both with 6 and 10, then holy shower.... smells fishy.. but that could just be my anti-pie radar going off.

massive congratulations if you get both

Anti - Pie Radar?....lol...not possible... ;D

hahaha ;D

good point. if any Aussie (not including vegans) has an anti-pie radar, then they really ain't Aussies.

anti-Collingwood radar on the other hand... :P

[Mr.Craig]

Shaz and Salem.

[T Dog]

Shaz and Salem.

Salem and Bontempelli ... ;D

[Nige]

Shaz and Salem.

[Jay]

Aish wont slip to 6

[Matt_352]

Want Bontempelli at the pies sooo much

[Nige]

Aish wont slip to 6

Nobody saw Grundy getting to Collingwood at 18.

[kilbluff1985]

Aish wont slip to 6

Nobody saw Grundy getting to Collingwood at 18.

is a ruck though bit different, but saying Aish wont slip to 6 is a big call

[Nige]

Aish wont slip to 6

Nobody saw Grundy getting to Collingwood at 18.

is a ruck though bit different, but saying Aish wont slip to 6 is a big call

Still serves the point.

[Toga]

Shaz and Salem.

Been thinking about that Craigy, but aren't they very similar players? Do the Pies want two players so similar to one another?

[kilbluff1985]

you guys don't think they are interested in Crouch at all with pick 10? is considered the next Swan pretty much

[Nige]

you guys don't think they are interested in Crouch at all with pick 10? is considered the next Swan pretty much

Nup, not at all.

[Mr.Craig]

Shaz and Salem.

Been thinking about that Craigy, but aren't they very similar players? Do the Pies want two players so similar to one another?

Nah, Shaz is like 7cm taller. He's a pretty similar size to Goddard and that's probably the player comparison I'd go with.

Salem on the other hand, there's a bit of Luke Hodge and Dusty Martin about him. Great hands, good awareness, can kick goals and is really strong.

I guess they're similar in the sense they could be multi-positional players but that can only be a good thing.

[Toga]

Yeah fair enough. I more so meant that the are both very efficient left foot kicks, are best suited to the back flanks/midfield from what I gather and are very much versatile players. As you say, probably a good thing but idk they seem kinda similar to me :P