Let Richo Rate Your DT

Jukes · November 15, 2013, 01:26:34 AM

It took me about 15 pages to fall behind, and you're behind on the first page :P

won't post my team to avoid clogging.

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 07:33:27 AM

Quote from: jason100 on November 11, 2013, 06:03:29 PM
TEAM NAME: My Planned Dream Team
DEF: J. McVeigh, B. Houli, T. Greene, B. Waters, M. Suckling, N. Bock (M. Scharenberg, Z. Jones)
MID: L. Montagna, J. Selwood, J. Watson, D. Beams, J. Kelly, J. Aish, J. Polec, X. Ellis (J. Martin, L. Taylor)
RUC: M. Kreuzer, H. McIntosh (L. McBean, M. Apeness)
FWD: S. Johnson, T. Rockliff, C. Wingard, L. Franklin, D. Thomas, V. Michie (A. Fasolo, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $9,400

This is my team. Please rate and give me your thoughts.
:D

DEF: I don't think that Bock and Houli are good picks. Bock Is a 30yo key forward, who's played 5 games over 2 years and I just don't like. Houli :P 9/10
MID: Montagnas suspended round 1 and I think that Beams is a better pick than Polec. I don't think that 4 premodern are enough, I think you need at least 5 premos. 8/10
RUC: Pretty good rucks. 9/10
FWD: I actually think that forward lines too strong :o I'd be changing Johnson into the midfield for Swan/Gaz or even keep him as himself. I think you need 5 premos at least in the mids. 9.5/10

Overall: Your forwards are too strong at the cost of your midfield. 35.5/40

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 05:37:26 PM

Quote from: Noz on November 13, 2013, 08:12:32 AM
Bryce Gibbs, Pearce Hanley, Grant Birchall, Beau Waters, Sam Darley, Matt Scharenberg
James Battersby, Isaiah Miller

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Joel Selwood, Patrick Dangerfield, Dayne Beams, Jack Billings, Kade Kolodjashnij, Dominic Sheed
Jack Martin, Anthony Morabito

Ben McEvoy, Aaron Sandilands
Liam McBean, Sam Naismith

Tom Rockliff, Chad Wingard, Jarryd Roughead, Nic Naitanui, Dale Thomas, Patrick Karnezis
Ben Lennon, Jesse Hogan

Money left - $45,900

DEF: Sam Darley is an interesting pick. I really like this backline, not to much to really say. 9/10
MID: A very strong midfield. I think Claye Beams would have better JS than some of those rookies. 9/10
RUC: Will be interesting to see what Big Boy McEvoy can do at the Hawks ;) 8/10
FWD: Not to sure about Nic Nat and Roughy. Nic Nat burnt me this year, and I dont think Roughy can do to much better after winning the Coleman, however still quite strong. 9/10

Overall: Very good team. 35/40

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 06:01:54 PM

Quote from: dtchamp on November 13, 2013, 06:51:11 PM
DEF: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, D.Stanley, M,Suckling, N.Bock. M.Scharenberg (J.Battersby, Z.Jones)
MID: S.Pendlebury, S.Selwood, J.Watson, T.Cotchin, D.Beams, J.Kelly, N.Freeman, J.Polec (M.Crouch, J.Martin)
RUC: N.Naitanui, S.Mumford (T.Nankervis, M.Apeness)
FWD: S.Johnson, T.Rockliff, L.Franklin, D.Thomas, V.Michie, A.Fasolo (B.Lennon, J.Hogan)

Cash Left: $144,000

DEF: Cannot stand people picking Bock, Massive spud, key forward, 30yo and under investigation by asada :o Dont see why you'd pick him. Other than that it looks pretty good. 8.5/10
MID: Good structure in the mids, but I think that the premos are a bit week, although they are unique. I think that you should get Gaz or Jellwood or Swan in there, and it would look better. 8/10
RUC: Nic Nat burnt me this year, so am probably a bit bias. I think that you would be better off with one full priced premium, and one underpriced (HMac, Longer, Sandi) rather than thos two guys. 8/10
FWD: Forward line quite similar to mine :o 8.5/10

Overall: Solid team 34/40

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 06:28:18 PM

Quote from: brad71 on November 14, 2013, 06:24:10 AM
HEY RICHO , Would love your thoughts , finished 1800th position last year hoping to improve this year , how is this for a start and cheers for doing reviews ,Brad.
TEAM NAME: goyougoodthing71
DEF: B. Goddard, R. Henderson, T. Greene, M. Suckling, B. Wilson, S. Docherty (S. Shaw, M. Scharenberg)
MID: S. Johnson, D. Swan, G. Ablett jnr, S. Selwood, J. Watson, J. Kelly, J. Billings, J. Aish (J. Polec, J. Martin)
RUC: N. Naitanui, B. Longer (D. Currie, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, L. Franklin, D. Thomas, C. Sinclair, T. Boyd, A. Fasolo (N. Bock, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $17,700

DEF: Couple of unique picks there with Henderson, Greene, Wilson, Docherty and S Shaw. tbh I would be staying well away from Shaw and Wilson, as both have very low JS. I think you need to trade Wilson/Shaw to rookies sand trade Henderson up to a true premo. 7.5/10
MID: Strong midfield, but I dont think you can have Swan, Stevie J and Gaz in the same eam. Sucks way too much money out. Dayne Beams is a lock and as I've said many times, Claye Beams is better than Polec. 9/10
RUC: Nic Nat burnt me last year and dont think that he will be as good at DT as he is at SC. Like Longer, think he will do well at the Saints. 8/10
FWD: Way to weak. Need at least 4 premos. Downgrade Sinclair to a rookie, get rid of Bock in whatever way possible and get in Karnezis. Way too weak. 6/10

Overall: Too midpriced. 30/40

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 06:46:56 PM

Quote from: joshthedee on November 15, 2013, 12:45:02 AM
TEAM NAME: JLA
DEF: D. Heppell, G. Birchall, J. Grimes, T. Greene, M. Suckling, N. Bock (M. Scharenberg, Z. Jones)
MID: S. Johnson, G. Ablett jnr, S. Pendlebury, P. Dangerfield, D. Beams, C. Beams, J. Polec, X. Ellis (N. Freeman, J. Martin)
RUC: S. Mumford, A. Sandilands (S. Hampson, L. McBean)
FWD: C. Wingard, L. Franklin, N. Naitanui, D. Thomas, V. Michie, G. Rohan (J. Hogan, B. Lennon)
CASH LEFT: $73,600

DEF: Pretty good line minus Bock. 9.5/10
MID: Another strong line. Nice pick in Ellis, could burn you if he gets injured, but could be awesome if his body holds up. 9/10
RUC: Standard. 8.5/10
FWD: Need Rockliff in there, it is crazy not to have him. Im not entirely conc=vinced on Rohans ability to score well, think that Karnezis is a far better pick than him. 8.5/10

Overall: Pretty good team, 36.5/40

goofy71 · November 15, 2013, 08:13:16 PM

Hey Richo , cast your view over this team , thanks for any tips

TEAM NAME: goyougoodthing71
DEF: B. Goddard, D. Heppell, T. Greene, B. Waters, M. Suckling, S. Docherty (T. Williams, M. Scharenberg)
MID: S. Johnson, G. Ablett jnr, S. Selwood, J. Watson, D. Beams, J. Kelly, J. Billings, J. Aish (C. Beams, J. Martin)
RUC: A. Sandilands, B. Longer (D. Currie, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, L. Franklin, P. Chapman, D. Thomas, T. Boyd, P. Karnezis (N. Bock, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $42,000

nrich102 · November 15, 2013, 08:31:15 PM

Quote from: goofy71 on November 15, 2013, 08:13:16 PM
Hey Richo , cast your view over this team , thanks for any tips

TEAM NAME: goyougoodthing71
DEF: B. Goddard, D. Heppell, T. Greene, B. Waters, M. Suckling, S. Docherty (T. Williams, M. Scharenberg)
MID: S. Johnson, G. Ablett jnr, S. Selwood, J. Watson, D. Beams, J. Kelly, J. Billings, J. Aish (C. Beams, J. Martin)
RUC: A. Sandilands, B. Longer (D. Currie, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, L. Franklin, P. Chapman, D. Thomas, T. Boyd, P. Karnezis (N. Bock, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $42,000

DEF: Pretty good, be prepared for Heppell and Goddard to lose dpp and Greene to possibly not gain it. 9/10
MID: Scooter Selwood seems to be a pretty popular pick this year. Standard. 8.5/10
RUC: I like the idea of Sandi and Longer, but I don't think it will score as well was knew of them and someone else. 7/10
FWD: Not bad, would be better without bock. 8.5/10

Overall: Not bad. 33/40

oc16 · November 16, 2013, 02:13:22 PM

hey richo, i did my team again having taken ur advice.

TEAM NAME: the COlts
DEF: J. McVeigh, D. Stanley, G. Birchall, T. Greene, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg (D. Gardiner, J. Battersby)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, J. Selwood, T. Liberatore, D. Beams, D. Tyson, C. Beams, J. Polec (M. Crouch, J. Martin)
RUC: H. McIntosh, A. Sandilands (L. McBean, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, C. Wingard, A. Christensen, L. Franklin, D. Thomas, A. Fasolo (J. Patton, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $-67,500

thanks

nrich102 · November 16, 2013, 02:14:42 PM

Ill rate it when your under the salary cap.

oc16 · November 16, 2013, 02:22:02 PM

oh ok - sorry, i just thought that since it is only over by 60k and the prices in fanplanner are only approximate then it would be ok.

oc16 · November 16, 2013, 02:23:32 PM

but if u want it changed then i can do that

oc16 · November 16, 2013, 02:24:56 PM

TEAM NAME: the COlts
DEF: J. McVeigh, D. Stanley, G. Birchall, T. Greene, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg (D. Gardiner, J. Battersby)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, J. Selwood, T. Liberatore, D. Beams, D. Tyson, C. Beams, J. Polec (M. Crouch, J. Martin)
RUC: H. McIntosh, A. Sandilands (L. McBean, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, A. Christensen, L. Franklin, P. Chapman, D. Thomas, A. Fasolo (J. Patton, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $39,600

i swapped wingard for chapman

joshthedee · November 16, 2013, 08:42:57 PM

TEAM NAME: JLA
DEF: D. Heppell, G. Birchall, J. Grimes, T. Greene, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg (Z. Jones, J. Kolodjashnij)
MID: D. Hannebery, G. Ablett jnr, S. Pendlebury, P. Dangerfield, D. Beams, C. Beams, J. Polec, X. Ellis (N. Freeman, J. Martin)
RUC: S. Mumford, A. Sandilands (R. Lobb, L. McBean)
FWD: C. Wingard, S. Johnson, T. Rockliff, D. Thomas, V. Michie, P. Karnezis (J. Hogan, B. Lennon)
CASH LEFT: $96,200

nrich102 · November 17, 2013, 07:59:22 AM

Quote from: oc16 on November 16, 2013, 02:24:56 PM
TEAM NAME: the COlts
DEF: J. McVeigh, D. Stanley, G. Birchall, T. Greene, M. Suckling, M. Scharenberg (D. Gardiner, J. Battersby)
MID: D. Swan, S. Selwood, J. Selwood, T. Liberatore, D. Beams, D. Tyson, C. Beams, J. Polec (M. Crouch, J. Martin)
RUC: H. McIntosh, A. Sandilands (L. McBean, R. Lobb)
FWD: T. Rockliff, A. Christensen, L. Franklin, P. Chapman, D. Thomas, A. Fasolo (J. Patton, J. Hogan)
CASH LEFT: $39,600

i swapped wingard for chapman

DEF: Solid. Have a backup plan if Greene doesn't get DPP though. 9/10
MID: Good Midfield. 9/10
RUC: Solid ruck, hopefully both can get there body right. 8.5/10
FWD: Interesting pick in Christensen. Karnezis if named round 1 is a lock, and should score a bit better than Patton. Michie is also a lock IMO. 8.5/10

Overall: Strong team. 35/40