Collingwood's Best 22 2014

[Big Mac]

Just out of interest, how would you rate Martin's value? i.e. what pick is he worth

[kilbluff1985]

Just out of interest, how would you rate Martin's value? i.e. what pick is he worth

unless he gets full games to show his value cant be worth more then a 2nd round pick

[Ricochet]

Just out of interest, how would you rate Martin's value? i.e. what pick is he worth

Would be lucky to get a 3rd round pick, most likely a 4th rd

[kilbluff1985]

what did they pay for Michie pick 47 or something? KMART prob about the same i guess

[Ricochet]

what did they pay for Michie pick 47 or something? KMART prob about the same i guess

54

[Big Mac]

Fair enough, I think I overestimated his value a little bit - Does make sense though if he hasn't played any games this year

[Ricochet]

plus he's a rookie which wouldn't help

[Nige]

It's a real shame is the Kyle Martin situation.

Sammy Dwyer is doing nicely, I hope he stays in their 22 for a while yet (that said, he's on the extended bench this weekend and could be dropped - will find out soon).

[kilbluff1985]

anybody want to give this a go for 2015 since it would of changed a fair bit?

[Mr.Craig]

Something like this?

B: Sinclair, Reid, Williams
HB: Langdon, Goldsack, Seedsman
M: Sidebottom, Swan, Greenwood
HF: Blair, White, Young
F: Fasolo, Cloke, Elliott

Foll: Witts, Pendlebury, Thomas
Int: Freeman, Brown, Dwyer, Varcoe

Emg: Grundy, Kennedy, Broomhead

Toovey, Adams, Crisp, Frost, Keefe and Karnezis all waiting in the wings.

[Nige]

Adams for Young and Toovey for Sinclair?

[Noz]

Something like this?

B: Sinclair, Reid, Williams
HB: Langdon, Goldsack, Seedsman
M: Sidebottom, Swan, Greenwood
HF: Blair, White, Young
F: Fasolo, Cloke, Elliott

Foll: Witts, Pendlebury, Thomas
Int: Freeman, Brown, Dwyer, Varcoe

Emg: Grundy, Kennedy, Broomhead

Toovey, Adams, Crisp, Frost, Keefe and Karnezis all waiting in the wings.

One of Keefe or Frost will replace Sinclair. Schaz is also on the fringe list

[Mr.Craig]

Adams for Young and Toovey for Sinclair?

That's what was running through my head too. Both line ball decisions.

Schaz is also on the fringe list

Knee reco. ;)

[Samsturmfels]

I'd probably prefer this

B: Toovey, Reid, Williams
HB: Langdon, Frost, Seedsman
M: Sidebottom, Swan, Greenwood
HF: Goldsack, White, Varcoe
F: Fasolo, Cloke, Elliott

Foll: Witts, Pendlebury, Thomas
Int: Broomhead, Brown, Blair, Adams

Emg: Grundy, Kennedy, Freeman

Sinclair, Crisp, Young
Dwyer, Keefe and Karnezis all waiting in the wings.

[Mr.Craig]

I was looking at their Round 18 team before and they played Witts, Cloke, White, Goldsack, Keefe, Frost and Reid. That's 7 players 193cm or taller. No wonder teams were able to run rings around them.