JROO's Top 50 Players of 2013

[Ricochet]

I actually have Crowley inside the top 10 best players in the competition, possibly top 5.
#1 tagger in the comp who has been beaten, say 2-3 times this year?
To compare... Selwood got beaten on 2-3 occasions as well, one of which being beaten by Crowley

To be fair here, winning "one on one" competitions doesn't make you a 30 player in terms of positive impact to the game

But to shut down the opposition's most important player and limit there influence is the same as another player collecting possessions and kicking goals?
He's basically doing the same job as Harry Taylor and he is top 10. Stopping a direct opponent, winning possessions yourself and kicking goals occasionally

[Jroo]

Hannerbery @ 38 is a disgrace!!

Fair enough, he had an awesome first half of the season, but fell away a bit in the second half.

That is a bit of a generalisation, had a BOG in rnd 17 and didnt play Rnd 23

Got different role at the end of the season, asked to tag which effected his numbers, but still played team role.

As a whole year guide, he came equal 6th in the Brownlow with Pendles (#3) Rockliff (#22)

Yes, he was awesome in round 17, but besides he didn't do a lot and you can't really use the Brownlow as an indicator as they mostly only award attacking players.
This top 50 is only my opinion, so I'm not saying it's right, it's just what I believe.

Yeah - its all good! I dont mean to be attacking! I am not going to try and do a top 50 thats for sure!

In general you have it about right, but IMO Hanners had a top20 year not top 40.

That's fine you're allowed to have an opinion  :)
Hanners is a fantastic player, but I just thought there were a few better than him.

37  ;)

Jezza was fantastic this year, besides that one game against Richmond.
He's playing a very difficult role, the ball hardly went in their forward 50.

[My Chumps]

No Bartel again?

You guys are killing me :P

[Jroo]

No Bartel again?

You guys are killing me :P

He was close, but couldn't fit him in  :-\