Main Menu

Top 100 TV Shows of All Time

Started by Mat0369, October 01, 2013, 12:38:59 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

SydneyRox

#345
i am confused.....

is it because he made Seinfeld 15, that Whos line didnt get through?

Nige

Quote from: SydneyRox on October 04, 2013, 11:06:23 AM
i am confused.....

In LF's post, Whose Line is on 21, Doctor Who is on 15. Simple addition or subtraction shows that's a gap of 6, not 7. Holz then went ahead and added a new show acting like Whose Line was inducted.

Basically, Whose Line should still be on the board and Avatar should not.

Ringo

Quote from: NigeyS on October 04, 2013, 11:09:40 AM
Quote from: SydneyRox on October 04, 2013, 11:06:23 AM
i am confused.....

In LF's post, Whose Line is on 21, Doctor Who is on 15. Simple addition or subtraction shows that's a gap of 6, not 7. Holz then went ahead and added a new show acting like Whose Line was inducted.

Basically, Whose Line should still be on the board and Avatar should not.
I think we are alright 
Looking at transactions from KB's phone votes
Whose Line was 20 KB -1 to 19 LF +2 to 21
Dr Who  was 14 KB+2 =16 LF - 1 to 15 Holz - 1 = 14
So with Holz minusing Dr Who to 14 Whose line is inducted and he can add Avatar so SR is correct as well.

T Dog

Ok ..I think..after SR

Dr Who, Some Mothers , Friends


Doctor Who - Newman - 18
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 13
How I Met Your Mother - Bays/Thomas - 13
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 12
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 6
The Wire - Simon - 5
Suits - Korsh - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2

Vinny

#349
Yeah Ringo is right but Suits never got its vote added from KB so I shall fix that and do my own vote too.

after TDog

HIMYM, Suits, Doctor Who

Doctor Who - Newman - 17
How I Met Your Mother - Bays/Thomas - 15
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 13
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 12
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Suits - Korsh - 7
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 6
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2

FIXED VERSION CAUSE TDOG AND I WENT AT THE SAME TIME.

Nige

Okay yeah, my bad guys. Carry on. I flowered up.

Didn't notice that Holz took a vote off Doctor Who to bring it down to 14 which is how Whose Line got inducted on 21.

Apologies!  :-[

13Brummy

after vinny

HIMYM, Friends, Doctor Who

How I Met Your Mother - Bays/Thomas - 17
Doctor Who - Newman - 16
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 13
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 12
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Suits - Korsh - 7
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 7
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2

GoLions

After Brummy

HIMYM/Friends/Dr Who

Don't have time to update board right now, sorry. Will do it when I get home if no-one else has.

Ringo

After Go Lions and updating both selections

HIMYM Bonanza (New) Dr Who


Doctor Who - Newman - 14
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 13
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 12
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Suits - Korsh - 7
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 8
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2
Bonanza - Dortort 1

How I Met Your Mother - Bays/Thomas - 21 now inducted

Introducing Bonanza but not sure how many will know it. 2nd longest running show on US TV from 1959 to 1973 and now being reshown.

SydneyRox


BB67th

HIMYM shouldn't be inducted yet? It only had 19 votes, compared to Dr. Who's 14?

Nige

Quote from: BB67th on October 04, 2013, 01:45:06 PM
HIMYM shouldn't be inducted yet? It only had 19 votes, compared to Dr. Who's 14?

Ringo updated for Dave and then gave HIMYM 2 votes as well, so it got 4 votes.

kilbluff1985

After Ringo

Doctor Who 2, Suits 1, Bonanza -1

Doctor Who - Newman - 16
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 13
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 13
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Suits - Korsh - 8
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 8
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2
Bonanza - Dortort 0

SydneyRox

After KB

Doctor Who 2, Suits 1, Seinfeld -1

Doctor Who - Newman - 18
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 12
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 13
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 8
Suits - Korsh - 9
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 8
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Avatar - The Last Airbender - 2
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2


Nige

After SR

Little Britain/Criminal Minds/Avatar

Doctor Who - Newman - 18
Seinfeld - David/Seinfeld - 12
Friday Night Lights - Aubrey - 13
Some Mother Do Have Em -Allen - 11
Sons of Anarchy - 10
Parks and Recreation - Daniels/Schur - 10
Criminal Minds - Davis - 9
Suits - Korsh - 9
Friends - Crane/Kauffman - 8
The Wire - Simon - 5
South Park- Parker/Stone - 5
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - McElhenney - 4
Are you being Served - Lloyd/Croft - 2
Little Britain - Lucas/Walliams - 2
Avatar - 1