AFL Trade radio

[Capper]

Shaw isn't worth pick 1, he's turning 28 this off season

They could work something out they want experienced defenders

Doesnt Adams want to go back to vic??

[Vinny]

Yeah Adams has said that he does not want to remain at GWS. Nah I don't think Heath Shaw is worth Pick 1 either mate.

[specky92]

Adams

for

Shaw + Pick 10

?

[SydneyRox]

surely that way overvalues Adams. Reckon the giants want players over picks and straight swap for Shaw sounds right.

[Vinny]

Yeah I think a straight swap is fair too.

[kilbluff1985]

Yeah Adams for Shaw seems fair

[specky92]

I don't see it, I must be rating Adams too high, Shaw will just make GWS a bit more respectable next year, then help them make the 8 in a few years but doubt he'll be there for the flag,  :-\

[JBs-Hawks]

I don't see it, I must be rating Adams too high, Shaw will just make GWS a bit more respectable next year, then help them make the 8 in a few years but doubt he'll be there for the flag,  :-\

Adams value goes down for the fact that he wants to go home

[specky92]

Oh yeah, so GWS don't have many bargaining chips,  :-\

[Ricochet]

Small reports heating up that Harry O will be looking to head back home to WA

We don't want/need him. I don't think the Eagles do either really

[Torpedo10]

Small reports heating up that Harry O will be looking to head back home to WA

We don't want/need him. I don't think the Eagles do either really

With McPharlin getting on a bit I think he'd fit in quite well and would be able to rebound. Why don't you think you need him?

[Ricochet]

Small reports heating up that Harry O will be looking to head back home to WA

We don't want/need him. I don't think the Eagles do either really

With McPharlin getting on a bit I think he'd fit in quite well and would be able to rebound. Why don't you think you need him?

McPharlin isn't a rebounding defender though and he has 1 or 2 years left in him. We have Duffield, Johnson, Spurr, Mzungu. We don't need another rebounding defender really. Maybe in a couple of years but not now. Plus we have quite a few developing big men who play/have played defence
Smith 196cm 90kg
Faulks 194cm 91kg
Silvagni 192cm 93kg
Hannath 201cm 102kg
Taberner 197cm 89kg

[Noz]

The Giants have officially withdrawn their offer to Franklin.

Franklin will either be a Docker or a Swan next year.

Matt White has requested a trade to Port

[valkorum]

Smith 196cm 90kg
Faulks 194cm 91kg
Silvagni 192cm 93kg
Hannath 201cm 102kg
Taberner 197cm 89kg

Lets be fair here

Faulks will most likely be de-listed
Hannath is a Ruck/Fwd
Taberner is a forward.

We definitely need someone to replace McPharlin but Harry O isnt that person

[Nige]

Heath Shaw more than likely to not be at the Pies as well.