Fyfe

[Ziplock]

Saw on this fb page that giants might offer pick 1 for fyfe....

looking for thoughts on this- on one hand freo definitely need a young key foward... on the otherhand, giving up fyfe... :/

[Nige]

As much as they need a young KPF, Fyfe is just way too valuable.

[Vinny]

I don't think it's a good idea.

Fyfe is way too valuable, he is 22 and as I said somewhere else, he will be one of the games most dominant players.

Averaged 25 disposals this year and gets plenty of hard ball. Although the No #1 pick is huge and will probably get Boyd.

Fyfe is too good. 8)

[specky92]

I think Giants should definitely put this offer on the table,  I don't see how Cameron, Patton, Boyd and Buddy can all play together and Fyfey is an absolute jet. Then again I don't think freo would do it even though guys like Neale don't get full games. Then again Boyd having Super Pav as a mentor could be very scary!

I wonder if giants would throw in their mid first rounder

[JBs-Hawks]

What about Coniglio + Boyd for Fyfe + Freo 1st rounder?

[Master Q]

Freo should rather work with what they've got or draft someone then trade away Fyfe. Very unlikely this will happen.

[Cicjose]

if this happens the result will be worse than 2001

[Capper]

Freo need a KPF and GWS need Fyfe. Cant see Fyfe wanting to go though

[Holz]

stupid trade, fyfe has showed with his marking abilities that he could play up front an be a beast forward. a superstar midfielder who can go up front and take great contested marks is worth alot more than pick 1, i dont care how good the draft is.

yes they need a KPP player but taking a punt on a unproven player at the cost of a top 5 young player in the comp isnt a go.

Pick 1 and Coniglio for Fyfe + 2nd round is plausible but still a bad move for freo.

[Vinny]

Fyfe is just too good to go anywhere.

[Holz]

Cameron for Fyfe would be a interesting move.

GWS pick up Buddy.

Buydd Patton is still a good forward line and they add fyfe to the midfield.

[Nige]

I genuinely reckon GWS would be more willing to let go of Patton over Jezza.

Cameron almost won the Coleman in his second year...

[Holz]

I genuinely reckon GWS would be more willing to let go of Patton over Jezza.

Cameron almost won the Coleman in his second year...

yeah they would rather give up patton but no way would freo give up fyfe unless cameron was in the trade.

trade Cameron + extra pick up buddy win win.

[Ziplock]

Cameron for Fyfe would be a interesting move.

GWS pick up Buddy.

Buydd Patton is still a good forward line and they add fyfe to the midfield.

there's no flowering way we'd do that.

Cameron > buddy.

[Holz]

Cameron for Fyfe would be a interesting move.

GWS pick up Buddy.

Buydd Patton is still a good forward line and they add fyfe to the midfield.

there's no flowering way we'd do that.

Cameron > buddy.

yes but Buddy + Ffyfe destorys Cameron.

Fyfe >Cameron