"Rate my Team" Supercoach Finals Thread - Week 2

[Vinny]

If Duigan doesn't keep his spot, that is the biggest load of shower ever.

[Nige]

I based my team around Duigan keeping his spot.  :P

[Jackross10]

Guthrie Mackie Logan
Selwood VC Corey Duncan Bell
Lobbe
Stokes C Motlop Young

[Ringo]

Have settled on this team for the time being:

Gibbs, Logan, Duigan
Jack Kennedy Murphy Menzell
Lobbe
Bartel Robinson Young.

[Jackross10]

Have settled on this team for the time being:

Gibbs, Logan, Duigan
Jack Kennedy Murphy Menzell
Lobbe
Bartel Robinson Young.

What C and VC Ringo ?

[Ringo]

Have settled on this team for the time being:

Gibbs, Logan, Duigan
Jack Kennedy Murphy Menzell
Lobbe
Bartel Robinson Young.

What C and VC Ringo ?

Jack as Captain and tossing between Bartel and Murphy for vice. (Will probably change this half a dozen times tomorrow)

[Bones Bombers]

Duigan, Rivers, Jonas
Murphy, Ebert, Cornes, Corey
Lobbe
Bartel, Robbo, Bird

Like this balanced team but not sure on C/VC?
Btw leaves $0 in the bank!

[Jackross10]

Duigan, Rivers, Jonas
Murphy, Ebert, Cornes, Corey
Lobbe
Bartel, Robbo, Bird

Like this balanced team but not sure on C/VC?
Btw leaves $0 in the bank!

Probably, Bartel C and Murphy VC. I like stokes ahead of bartel

[Vinny]

Looking at Gibbs/Murphy for VC & Bartel for C.

[GCSkiwi]

@Ringo - Menzell would be big risk of vest?

This week I think I'm settling for:

Gibbs, Duigan, Logan
Jelwood, Jack, Murphy, Cassissi
Lobbe
Robinson, Bird, Young
C/VC Jelwood and Jack, haven't decided which order. Probably Jelwood C.

Thoughts?

[storeymjs]

@Ringo - Menzell would be big risk of vest?

This week I think I'm settling for:

Gibbs, Duigan, Logan
Jelwood, Jack, Murphy, Cassissi
Lobbe
Robinson, Bird, Young
C/VC Jelwood and Jack, haven't decided which order. Probably Jelwood C.

Thoughts?

Is anyone considering Shane Biggs? He is only $96,400 and my theory is that he will score as many points as Duigan does (assuming Biggs isn't the sub, I think Cunningham will be)! In his only game he scored 62 against Hawthorn and had 18 possies but did go missing in the second half. But I don't believe Duigan will perform the way he did last week against the Swans but I could be wrong!

The only problem is, is that I really like your midfield! But maybe for Cassisi? Allowing you to upgrade Robinson or Bird to Bartel (I think ... I haven't done the math but it sounds about right)

Good luck :)

[Jackross10]

I have 10/11 players playing tonight !

[Nige]

I have 10/11 players playing tonight !

:o

[Jackross10]

Taylor Guthrie Logan
Selwood C Corey Duncan BELL
Lobbe
Stokes VC Gray Young

[Rusty00]

@Ringo - Menzell would be big risk of vest?

This week I think I'm settling for:

Gibbs, Duigan, Logan
Jelwood, Jack, Murphy, Cassissi
Lobbe
Robinson, Bird, Young
C/VC Jelwood and Jack, haven't decided which order. Probably Jelwood C.

Thoughts?

Is anyone considering Shane Biggs? He is only $96,400 and my theory is that he will score as many points as Duigan does (assuming Biggs isn't the sub, I think Cunningham will be)! In his only game he scored 62 against Hawthorn and had 18 possies but did go missing in the second half. But I don't believe Duigan will perform the way he did last week against the Swans but I could be wrong!

The only problem is, is that I really like your midfield! But maybe for Cassisi? Allowing you to upgrade Robinson or Bird to Bartel (I think ... I haven't done the math but it sounds about right)

Good luck :)

It's not a bad thought about Biggs v Duigan. I agree it would be unlikely for Duigan to repeat his heroics from last week and you would generally expect around 60-70 from him. The extra coin could come in handy.

I think you've talked me into it  ;)