Main Menu

Your best Freo starting line up

Started by greendayz, September 04, 2013, 07:59:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

greendayz

It's been a while since Freo has had such a good depth in its squad...list your best starting line up, interchange, sub and 3 emergencies.

Consider all players as being available (even Mora) and up against a generic opponent (ie not countering specific threats).

Ricochet

OK I'll go with...









FBIbbotsonDawsonDuffield
HBSpurrMcPharlinJohnson
CBarlowMundyHill
HFde BoerPavlichMayne
FFWaltersBradleyBallantyne
FOLLSandilandsFyfeCrowley
BENCHCPearceDPearceZClarkeMzungu

With...
CPearce, DPearce and Mzungu rotating through HB and the Middle
ZClarke rotating through FF and the Ruck
Dawson, McPharlin, Ibbotson and Johnson not in any real position, just grab best matchups

greendayz

Good line up. I'd go:

FB   Ibbotson   Dawson   Duffield
HB   D Pearce   McPharlin   Johnson
C   Barlow   Mundy   Hill
HF   de Boer   Pavlich   Mayne
FF   Walters   Z Clarke   Ballantyne
FOLL   Sandilands   Fyfe   Crowley
BENCH   C Pearce   Spurr      Griffin   Mzungu

Very similar but Danyle Pearce in for Spurr and Zac Clarke at FF instead of Bradley whose doesn't make the bench because of Griff. Really don't like Bradley.

No room for Neale, Silvagni and Morabito.

valkorum

FB -      Spurr, Dawson, Duffield
HB -      Ibbotson, McPharlin, Johnson
C -        Morabito, Mundy, Hill
HF -       Fyfe, Pavlich, Mayne
FF -       Walters, Clarke, Ballantyne
FOLL -    Griffin, Barlow, Crowley
BENCH -  C Pearce, D Pearce, Mzungu, DeBoer
EMG -     Neale, Silvagni, Sutcliffe


Cicjose

FB -      Spurr, Dawson, Duffield
HB -      Ibbotson, McPharlin, Johnson
C -        Fyfe, Mundy, Hill
HF -      Morabito, Pavlich, Mayne
FF -      Walters, Bradley, Ballantyne
FOLL -   Griffin, Barlow, Crowley
BENCH -  C Pearce, D Pearce, Mzungu, DeBoer
EMG -     Neale, Silvagni, Sutcliffe

valkorum

No second ruckman Cic?  Only Keplar as backup?

Cicjose

yeah gives us more mobility around the ground

greendayz

No Sandilands for two of the squads? Is this the end of 211?

Cicjose

he isnt a walk up start for 1st ruck anymore

Ricochet

If fit he has to be surely... The big part is "if fit" though

valkorum

Quote from: Cicjose on September 04, 2013, 09:05:49 PM
yeah gives us more mobility around the ground

Zac Clarke is more mobile than Keplar, remember when he chased down Lachie Henderson

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nbXBRfoAPI

valkorum

Quote from: greendayz on September 04, 2013, 10:09:12 PM
No Sandilands for two of the squads? Is this the end of 211?

I have said this a few weeks ago - I feel really bad that I dont think Sandi is best 22 but moving forward I think Griffin and Clarke are our best 2 ruck options. 

Holz

Quote from: Cicjose on September 04, 2013, 09:05:49 PM
yeah gives us more mobility around the ground

clarke is way too good to play in the reserves though. I would play clarke number 1 and eventually Clarke and Moller.

valkorum

Moller is still a few years away from being able to play full time.  Griffin and Clarke and both miles ahead of him at the moment.

Ricochet

Yeh i wouldn't expect Moller to get a regular gig until 22-23