"Rate my Team" Supercoach Finals Thread

[Jackross10]

JUDD ? Experience ? Think he could play well. Injured ?

[hawkers65]

:o

B: Gibbs, Reid, Grimes
M: Pendlebury, Swan, Murphy, Caddy
R: Sandilands
F: Motlop, A.Edwards, Rohan

Nice team mate!

Got quite a few nice PODs in Gibbs, Caddy and Edwards. Gibbs is coming of a great game and a score of 140 and usually plays alright against the Tigs so will probably be worth the extra coin, Caddy on the other hand has never really been a 'scorer' so i'd be wary of him. Edwards has been in hot form since finding his way into the team and should score well. I was too looking at Reid but with Brown uncertain as well as their defence really getting a hiding recently, i'm a little concerned they will throw him down back again.

Overall a great team! Well done!

[Jackross10]

Burgoyne Yarran Rivers
Pendles Seedsman and 2 of Hodge Lewis Judd Hannerz
Grundy
Gunston Edwards Didak

What do you guys think ? Which 2 mids ? Thanks

[hawkers65]

Burgoyne Yarran Rivers
Pendles Seedsman and 2 of Hodge Lewis Judd Hannerz
Grundy
Gunston Edwards Didak

What do you guys think ? Which 2 mids ? Thanks

I'd def go Lewis and then for me it would be either Hodge or Judd, but Judd has had a pretty poor year and Hodgy loves a tight fierce contest so would expect him to score well.

[Jackross10]

Pendles is my C. Who for VC, Hodge, Lewis, Burgyone, Gunston, Seedsmen 

[no eye deer]

Burgoyne, Yarran, Grundy

Pendles(C), Swan (VC), Hodge, Neale

Sandi

Guns ton, Didak, Rohan

Might need a quick shuffle before the bounce tonight if Rohan starts with the vest. Need to change Grundy as I just realised he only scored 29 against the Hawks last week.

Edit: Backs now Gibbs, Burgoyne, Duigan

[Ringo]

After some consideration and match ups and trying to fit into salary cap here is the team I have come up with a bit unique:

Def: Birchill, Heath Grundy; Rivers
Mids: Pendles (c); S Johnson; Sewell. Menzell/Ellard (dependent on final cut)
Ruck: Mumford (Vc)
Fwds: Gunston, Robinson, Didak

Couple of matters Mumford destroyed Hawks Rucks last week scoring 159 SC points.
Gunston scores against Sydney this year both 102.
Apart from last week Grundy usually takes Roughead and has scored reasonably well against him.Sewell averaging 99 against Sydney in last 5 outings.

Rivers; Menzell/Ellard and Didak to meet Salary cap.

Know stats do not mean a lot but are the best guide. Could of taken a cheaper ruck but Mummies form hard to ignore and taking punt on him as VC.

[Rusty00]

After some consideration and match ups and trying to fit into salary cap here is the team I have come up with a bit unique:

Def: Birchill, Heath Grundy; Rivers
Mids: Pendles (c); S Johnson; Sewell. Menzell/Ellard (dependent on final cut)
Ruck: Mumford (Vc)
Fwds: Gunston, Robinson, Didak

Couple of matters Mumford destroyed Hawks Rucks last week scoring 159 SC points.
Gunston scores against Sydney this year both 102.
Apart from last week Grundy usually takes Roughead and has scored reasonably well against him.Sewell averaging 99 against Sydney in last 5 outings.

Rivers; Menzell/Ellard and Didak to meet Salary cap.

Know stats do not mean a lot but are the best guide. Could of taken a cheaper ruck but Mummies form hard to ignore and taking punt on him as VC.

I've gone Mumford as well at the moment. Bailey is back which should even up the hitouts a bit, but I still think Mumford will score well.

My other thought for the ruck is Matthew Lobbe now that Renouf has been dropped. Been scoring pretty well the back half of the season.

[Typhnn]

B: T.Richards, Yarran, Grimes
M: Pendle, Beams, Fyfe, Murphy
R: Sandi
F: Gunston, Chapman, Rohan

setup strong in most areas, gone with odd backs as the seem to be able to score well against opp and salary cap issues...!!

But should push 1200+... which i think is pretty acceptable...!!

[freddo81]

Hey guys, whats the thoughts on this team??

Burgoyne, Ellis, Grimes

Pendles(c), Selwood(vc), Walker, B. Hill

Grundy

Chapman, Bird, Rohan

[Typhnn]

Freddo81...

Crowley on Selwood, and Armfiled on Ellis both kept these players to a very low score...!! 

both descent picks but you also got to pick a team based on each weeks match ups...!!

Good Luck if they do break the tag!!

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 ::)    Hi guys and gals,
Yarran   Rivers   D Grimes
Pendlebury   Swan   S Johnson   B Sewell
Sandilands
T Cloke   P Chapman   G Rohan
Thinking Pendles for the big C and SJ for the vc.
Any thoughts ??
;)

[Typhnn]

Sabretooth Tigers...

Solid Mid/Ruc/Fwd, but like myself light on in the Def... keep playing you might find a better combo by lockout.. :)

Good luck...

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :) :)
Cheers Typhnn.   Only spot up for auction is the river site. Dylan Grimes will be a gun if he can stay on the park and for the price Yarran is ok. The highest scoring team for the round will definitely be the one that can nail the cap and vc positions, more especially if one is POD. Best of luck mate.    ;)

[tor01doc]

Yarran Morris Colq

Pendleton Swan Ball Murphy

Sandi

Cloke Chappy Rohan


I figure Pies should smash Port. Looking at cheap guys in defence after this year.