WXV Trade Thread

[Nige]

Lol at the 10 coaches who voted to pass that trade. I could add more, but would probably offend too many people.

The thing is, the way the system works is that you don't vote to pass the trade... but to reject/neg it. I assume of the other coaches who let it go, they probably didn't see it as unfairly disadvantaging either side. Not sure though, I can't speak for them.

[elephants]

This ^

I don't like the system, people always look for reasons to neg a trade not to pass it. I try to look for reasons for the trade to pass.

I didn't think Nat 25 was required at all but each to their own. Would rather see more trades get passed because  they are tight/iffy than more trades be blocked for this same reason.

My opinion anyway.

[JBs-Hawks]

What shocked me.the most was HP overruling daz, bit of unrest in France? Come to Korea Daz your welcome here ;)

[Nails]

This ^

I don't like the system, people always look for reasons to neg a trade not to pass it. I try to look for reasons for the trade to pass.

I didn't think Nat 25 was required at all but each to their own. Would rather see more trades get passed because  they are tight/iffy than more trades be blocked for this same reason.

My opinion anyway.

It's not tight/iffy

It's the worst trade there has been

2 superstar premos of 21 years old

For 2 players 1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

You need 5 first round picks to make up for that difference.

It's really 2 premos for Zero premos once you factor in Westhoff only had 1/3 a good season and it has been his only good one.

Normally 2 premos for Zero premos = zero premos are young, not the other way around!

[elephants]

This ^

I don't like the system, people always look for reasons to neg a trade not to pass it. I try to look for reasons for the trade to pass.

I didn't think Nat 25 was required at all but each to their own. Would rather see more trades get passed because  they are tight/iffy than more trades be blocked for this same reason.

My opinion anyway.

It's not tight/iffy

It's the worst trade there has been

2 superstar premos of 21 years old

For 2 players 1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

You need 5 first round picks to make up for that difference.

It's really 2 premos for Zero premos once you factor in Westhoff only had 1/3 a good season and it has been his only good one.

Normally 2 premos for Zero premos = zero premos are young, not the other way around!

I said I disagreed with Nat 25 being thrown in. Nat 6 carries a lot of value, that brings them a star midfielder who will EVENTUALLY be able to take over from Ball.

Its not r@pe.

Would have liked to see HP/Daz agree haha but each to their own. Not my fault if the system is flawed.

[ossie85]

1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

:/ I'd be careful Nails! You'll talk people into rejecting every trade you ever do!

[Nige]

1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

Didn't you just do a trade with Seoul for James Kelly?  ???

[Justin Bieber]

I don't mind the trade passing, I just get why would you trade McKenzie and Libba!!

One of the best defenders as he's young and the team is getting better and Libba who is up there in the Pendles regards.

[Nails]

This ^

I don't like the system, people always look for reasons to neg a trade not to pass it. I try to look for reasons for the trade to pass.

I didn't think Nat 25 was required at all but each to their own. Would rather see more trades get passed because  they are tight/iffy than more trades be blocked for this same reason.

My opinion anyway.

It's not tight/iffy

It's the worst trade there has been

2 superstar premos of 21 years old

For 2 players 1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

You need 5 first round picks to make up for that difference.

It's really 2 premos for Zero premos once you factor in Westhoff only had 1/3 a good season and it has been his only good one.

Normally 2 premos for Zero premos = zero premos are young, not the other way around!

I said I disagreed with Nat 25 being thrown in. Nat 6 carries a lot of value, that brings them a star midfielder who will EVENTUALLY be able to take over from Ball.

Its not r@pe.

Would have liked to see HP/Daz agree haha but each to their own. Not my fault if the system is flawed.

Mitch Thorp, Richard Tambling, the list goes on...

1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

Didn't you just do a trade with Seoul for James Kelly?  ???

We're trying to win the next 1-2 grand finals, therefore he's exactly what we're after

[JBs-Hawks]

1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

Didn't you just do a trade with Seoul for James Kelly?  ???

Think nails and sids lists are a bit different,   wrll were :P

[Nige]

1 who will retire after this season and 1 who will retire in a few seasons

Didn't you just do a trade with Seoul for James Kelly?  ???

Think nails and sids lists are a bit different,   wrll were :P

Good point haha.

[Nails]

I would've traded it all for Libba instead of James Kelly if I could Nige.

I think we're still up there in talks for premiership favourtism, top 4 at least. Point is, our team is beast, but if we had Libba, Libba would be #1 captain option for season 2014.

Ahead of Stevie J/Swan etc.

[elephants]

Calling it now, Libba will drop off slightly next season.

[DazBurg]

Calling it now, Libba will drop off slightly next season.

was thinking that myself tbh

[Holz]

Calling it now, Libba will drop off slightly next season.

was thinking that myself tbh

No way he is top 5 for value, watch him cop attention and fall back to the pack. I'm thinking 105. 110 is the best case scenario.