WXV Trade Thread

[Holz]

If it's such an obvious pass, then why did I neg it?

Because your thretaned by Dublin.

[Nails]

Pacific trade: Tom Rockliff, Luke Delaney and Pick 78
Dublin trade: Jack Redden, Michael Hurley and Sam Day

Neg on this trade.

Pick 78 essentially has zero worth. Tom Rockliff won't be a forward in the future. Maybe one more season. But with Leppa as a coach, he'll be mid only

Therefore

Last 3 seasons - Rockliff 103 average, Redden 101

Redden is (in terms of footy seasons) younger than Rockliff

Therefore Redden = Rockliff

78 = worthless

Therefore it comes down to

A guy who has played a max of 13 games in a season and has a terrible average for two guys who are both YOUNGER, actually get GAMES and actually average HIGHER

Yeah, no thanks. Neg on this trade.  Redden = Rockliff (if Redden not slightly higher)

and other 2 good solid young players for a middle agedish useless flowering hack.

[My Chumps]

Didn't Rockliff average like 128 in the second half of the season?

If I was to neg it (which I didn't), it'd be the other way round  :-X

[Vinny]

Hmm that's some interesting thinking there Nails!

[kilbluff1985]

and that ladies and gentlemen is why i hate this voting system

[Nails]

Rockliff actually 106 last 3 years but my point still stands.

So Chumps?

He averaged 88 in the first half. How can you guarantee he won't go back to 88 average?

Jordan Gysberts averaged 110 in 2 games.

[elephants]

So Chumps?

He averaged 88 in the first half. How can you guarantee he won't go back to 88 average?

Because Rocky will be in the guts. You said it yourself with Leppa at the helm.. Not even remotely comparable to Jizz-Spurts.

[Vinny]

BXV is the best system IMO. Not having a go at Ossie here! :)

But it's just Ringo and a trade committee that is in no way involved with BXV. Both sides get a chance to explain why it should be approved if it is leaning towards rejection.

[Nige]

The makers of don't hate the player, hate the game bring you:

Don't hate the system, hate the traders.  :P

#banter

[Holz]

Pacific trade: Tom Rockliff, Luke Delaney and Pick 78
Dublin trade: Jack Redden, Michael Hurley and Sam Day

Neg on this trade.

Pick 78 essentially has zero worth. Tom Rockliff won't be a forward in the future. Maybe one more season. But with Leppa as a coach, he'll be mid only

Therefore

Last 3 seasons - Rockliff 103 average, Redden 101

Redden is (in terms of footy seasons) younger than Rockliff

Therefore Redden = Rockliff

78 = worthless

Therefore it comes down to

A guy who has played a max of 13 games in a season and has a terrible average for two guys who are both YOUNGER, actually get GAMES and actually average HIGHER

Yeah, no thanks. Neg on this trade.  Redden = Rockliff (if Redden not slightly higher)

and other 2 good solid young players for a middle agedish useless flowering hack.

Do you truly believe rocky = redden

You say he will be mid only yet when you compare averages you include all the forward games. Rocky is better than Barlow so if redden is equal if not better.

How about redden for Barlow + much more.

[Purple 77]

So Chumps?

He averaged 88 in the first half. How can you guarantee he won't go back to 88 average?

Not even remotely comparable to Jizz-Spurts.

That really made me laugh ele haha lol  ;D

[elephants]

So Chumps?

He averaged 88 in the first half. How can you guarantee he won't go back to 88 average?

Not even remotely comparable to Jizz-Spurts.

That really made me laugh ele haha lol  ;D

Hahah that nickname was flogged a couple of years ago but I decided it needed a comeback :P

[Nails]

Rockliff will average shower next year

After his brownlow performance and actually getting midfield time he's #1 tagged 2014.

[elephants]

Its ok Nails, you don't have to fear Dublin ::) :P

[Nige]

Its ok Nails, you don't have to fear Dublin ::) :P

Hypothetically speaking...

What if wasn't so much fearing Dublin as it was fearing the competition being a blowout or uneven if Dublin became 'too strong'.

#foodforthought