WXV Trade Thread

[Nige]

Pacific give: Jack Viney + Jackson Paine + pick 60
Berlin give: Andy Otten + Lindsay Thomas + pick 15

Purp to confirm.

:o Lindsay is moving continents again.

[tbagrocks]

Pacific give: Jack Viney + Jackson Paine + pick 60
Berlin give: Andy Otten + Lindsay Thomas + pick 15

Purp to confirm.

:o Lindsay is moving continents again.

He likes coconuts!

[Purple 77]

Pacific give: Jack Viney + Jackson Paine + pick 60
Berlin give: Andy Otten + Lindsay Thomas + pick 15

Purp to confirm.

Confirmed! After many, many weeks of discussion haha

A guy with an attitude, talent, work ethic and willingness to be great... is just impossible not to chase. Viney is this guy. He is a gun. He will be a star. Because a guy with those attributes is impossible not to turn into a star. Yes I am a melbourne supporter  :P but the kid is fantastic.

Jackson Paine looked alright in 2012 and I saw he impressed in the VFL, but Q stick and Cloke have kept him out. I believe Paine will take over Q stick in time and be a solid forward.

Otten is expendable, especially with the additions of Petterd and Ben Reid coming, so I had an stack of defenders like him. I ama aware that he may have a def/for status, but so will Ben Reid and Lachie Henderson.

I hope Nigey doesn't mind me trading lindsay  :-X I did say I'd take good care of him, and I did the exact opposite by trading him to Pacific.....  ;) In all seriousness though, Lindsay should be a solid forward for Pacific and serve them well I reckon

[Nige]

I hope Nigey doesn't mind me trading lindsay  :-X I did say I'd take good care of him, and I did the exact opposite by trading him to Pacific.....  ;) In all seriousness though, Lindsay should be a solid forward for Pacific and serve them well I reckon

Not happy Jan.

:P

Haha, I kid!  ;D

[Nige]

Cairo give: Shaun Grigg
Dublin give: Jed Anderson

Reason: Holz wanted an established mid and offered us Jed Anderson. Both of us at Cairo really like Anderson and felt we needed to get a little bit more youth into the team. Grigg's a solid high 80s/low 90s player while Anderson's shown and both clubs believe he can match or even better that in time. 

[Holz]

Cairo give: Shaun Grigg
Dublin give: Jed Anderson

Reason: Holz wanted an established mid and offered us Jed Anderson. Both of us at Cairo really like Anderson and felt we needed to get a little bit more youth into the team. Grigg's a solid high 80s/low 90s player while Anderson's shown and both clubs believe he can match or even better that in time.

confirmed

exactly what Nigel said ando will be a gun when mitchell hodge sewell etc.. leave but I need a soild utility and its a waste to have someone other than a mid there. Grigg a solid high 80s player having abit of a down year but i think he can go 85-90 hopefully next year.

[Master Q]

Looking to trade our priority pick, Pick 20. Toga is away so make sure you PM with offers  :)

[Master Q]

Has everybody voted!?

[ossie85]

Everyone voted as of last night! Thanks all....

Trades Passed Fully (2 votes or less)
* These trades passed, with or without my objection

Trade 18:
Beijing trade: Pick 77
Berlin trade: Alipate Carlile

Trade 20:
Cape Town trade: Blayne Wilson and Pick 37
Moscow trade: Dom Tyson

Trade 21:
Cape Town trade: Lee Spurr
Pacific trade: Sam Reid (Swans)

Trade 24:
New Delhi trade: Jarryd Blair, Terry Milera and Pick 25
Pacific trade: Shane Savage, Zach Williams, Daniel Talia and Pick 42

Trades Fully Rejected (9 votes or more)
* These trades passed, with or without my support

Nil

Trades Passed by the Coaches, but referred to me (3 votes or more)

Trade 23:

Dublin trade: Zac Clarke, Tom Lee and Pick 67
Moscow trade: Charlie Dixon and Robert Murphy

Verdict: PASS Another close one, but if we assume Clarke and Dixon are of roughly equal value (and I think they are). It comes down to Tom Lee and Pick 67 v Robert Murphy. Murphy is getting older, but a proven defender, while Lee is a developing forward who may or may not live up to potential. I think pick 67 is enough to any difference.

Trades Rejected by the Coaches, but referred to me (8 votes or less)

Trade 19:

Dublin trade: Jack Watts, Jack Darling, Jed Lamb, Brad Hill and Lachy Plowman
Cape Town trade: Jobe Watson and Lyndon Dunn

Verdict: I thought about this one for a while.... If I squint, I think it is a fair trade in some respects.... In others a bit dodgy. The reasons given by people basically say that Holzman is giving up too much. All in all, I call it inclusive vision and leave it to the people's call REJECTED

Trades Rejected for other reasons

Trade 22
Buenos Aires trade: Pick 16
Tokyo trade: Chris Judd and Pick 90

Why? This trade puts Tokyo under the 24,000 mark therefore rejected. This trade would have been referred to me (3 or more votes, less than 6), and I would have been very tentative to let this pass or not....

[elephants]

:D

[My Chumps]

flowering cow shower arse twat.

That ruins a lot of my plans. I don't get this rejection shower sometimes. Took us about 3 weeks to get to that deal.

[Ricochet]

Trade 24:
New Delhi trade: Jarryd Blair, Terry Milera and Pick 25
Pacific trade: Shane Savage, Zach Williams, Daniel Talia and Pick 42

Pretty happy with this. Banking on a break out year for Savage

[elephants]

Trade 24:
New Delhi trade: Jarryd Blair, Terry Milera and Pick 25
Pacific trade: Shane Savage, Zach Williams, Daniel Talia and Pick 42

Pretty happy with this. Banking on a break out year for Savage

Yep, Blair is a big loss to our fwd line but Sav and Williams love SC scoring!

[Nige]

flowering cow shower arse twat.

That ruins a lot of my plans. I don't get this rejection shower sometimes. Took us about 3 weeks to get to that deal.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VL4ei-RE3Nc

[kilbluff1985]

 :'(