The Best R2 For Round 23?

Started by Serial_T, August 25, 2013, 10:59:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Best #2 Ruck for R23

Roughead (v Sydney)
0 (0%)
Minson (v Melbourne)
17 (63%)
Goldstein (v Collingwood)
3 (11.1%)
Kreuzer (v Adelaide)
0 (0%)
Leuenberger (v Geelong)
4 (14.8%)
Clarke (v St Kilda)
0 (0%)
Lobbe (v Carlton)
3 (11.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Serial_T

Hey there guys.
Who would you consider to be the best R2 option to partner Cox in Round 23? The first five would be the best options, but Zac Clarke could be a sneaky POD given his recent form.

I've got Roughie, but I'm considering upgrading him.

Mr.Craig

Lobbe has gone 130+ three times in the last six weeks. Strangely he hasn't been that great at AAMI. But still...

fertalong

Minson will be the most reliable scorer and an easy 100, but if you are chasing a big score and POD then Lobbe would be the way to go.

BGK

It may be because he's in my team but I like the look of Goldy vs Collingwood. As good as Grundy has been, Collingwood leak points to opposition rucks

Serial_T

Quote from: BGK on August 26, 2013, 07:35:02 AM
It may be because he's in my team but I like the look of Goldy vs Collingwood. As good as Grundy has been, Collingwood leak points to opposition rucks

This is true.
Grundy's opponents:
ROUND 22 - Cox (100)
ROUND 21 - Hale (92)
ROUND 20 - Mumford (95)
ROUND 19 - Ryder (91)
ROUND 18 - Brogan (57)


But then you looks at what Melbourne conceeds to opposition rucks:
ROUND 22 - Jacobs (104)
ROUND 21 - Clarke (116)
ROUND 20 - Gorringe (76)
ROUND 19 - Brogan (76)
ROUND 18 - Goldstein (137)
ROUND 17 - Leuenberger (117)
ROUND 16 - Simpson (109)
ROUND 15 - Mumford (80)
ROUND 14 - Minson (110)

BGK

Quote from: Serial_T on August 26, 2013, 10:37:23 AM
Quote from: BGK on August 26, 2013, 07:35:02 AM
It may be because he's in my team but I like the look of Goldy vs Collingwood. As good as Grundy has been, Collingwood leak points to opposition rucks

This is true.
Grundy's opponents:
ROUND 22 - Cox (100)
ROUND 21 - Hale (92)
ROUND 20 - Mumford (95)
ROUND 19 - Ryder (91)
ROUND 18 - Brogan (57)


But then you looks at what Melbourne conceeds to opposition rucks:
ROUND 22 - Jacobs (104)
ROUND 21 - Clarke (116)
ROUND 20 - Gorringe (76)
ROUND 19 - Brogan (76)
ROUND 18 - Goldstein (137)
ROUND 17 - Leuenberger (117)
ROUND 16 - Simpson (109)
ROUND 15 - Mumford (80)
ROUND 14 - Minson (110)

Nice bit of research. Going by this Minson probably is the better option.

Ricochet

After seeing what Minson did in the second half against Brissie, he will destroy Melbourne

woofy

Quote from: Ricochet on August 26, 2013, 11:33:58 AM
After seeing what Minson did in the second half against Brissie, he will destroy Melbourne

touch wood! i hope so!

henry

Yeah have had minson since kruze went down and he's been great. Should score well against the dees and is ultra consistent.

Spinking

Go Minson. Most consistent and will dominate against the Dees.