need to match shaws 122 with my last trade....

Started by wetDT, August 23, 2013, 11:02:07 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

wetDT

gonna be a tight finish in my final. Which def do i bring in to match it with shaws 122....can afford any def for my last trade.

def is Murphy Grimes  ______? VS Shaw (122) Dixon Hanley

Houli against GWS?

or do i go enright for a little safety??


caluuum

Who are your other defenders?

Ellis maybe? If he doesn't get a tag against GWS he could run rampant

wetDT

Quote from: caluuum on August 23, 2013, 11:03:44 PM
Who are your other defenders?

Ellis maybe? If he doesn't get a tag against GWS he could run rampant

sorry mate should of put them all up there. Got Goddard Gibbs Birchall Grimes Murphy _____

Swoozie

Quote from: caluuum on August 23, 2013, 11:03:44 PM
Ellis maybe? If he doesn't get a tag against GWS he could run rampant
+1. I can see him getting a rather decent score if he is allowed to run. And it's not as though he is high up in the pecking order of tags.

Typhnn

I'd say Hibberd or Dixon...

but I reckon Carlton might tag Hibberd...   Dixon for me..!!

wetDT

Quote from: Typhnn on August 23, 2013, 11:19:59 PM
I'd say Hibberd or Dixon...

but I reckon Carlton might tag Hibberd...   Dixon for me..!!

i will need to make ground so need a POD, my opp picked up dixon for hartlett. cheers for the comment tho mate

Typhnn

sorry my bad... must of glazed over it...!!


maybe d. pearce v port??

Enright would be safe, but I don't think he would score huge against Syd..?? its a hard call...!!

only other possibles are...

Birchall, Adcock, maybe Mackie...?? 

Hazza09

I don't know if this sounds crazy but because of Shaws 122 I'm thinking of benching JPK against the Cats (my opponent doesn't have him) and am thinking JPK might find it tough going against the cats and bringing in Barlow might gain me a 50-60 point margin.

Is this is a crazy idea?

wetDT

Quote from: Typhnn on August 23, 2013, 11:38:29 PM
sorry my bad... must of glazed over it...!!


maybe d. pearce v port??

Enright would be safe, but I don't think he would score huge against Syd..?? its a hard call...!!

only other possibles are...

Birchall, Adcock, maybe Mackie...??

im falling short of points at the moment. Enright is my safe card that i want to play as that was the trade i had in mind for heppell out. Just realised I have Jelwood as a POD (thought opp. had him!) so im gonna captain Jelwood and hope to gain some points on my opp Gablett C....but it might come down to shaw 122 vs the defender i bring in.

Enright seems safe but ellis might be what i need to stick my nose ahead. not sure at all.





wetDT

#9
My players                         his players                                  same players

Murphy ______ Grimes       Shaw Dixon Hanley                     Goddard Gibbs Birchall
Fyfe Selwood Crouch          Griffen Cotchin Priddis                Pendles Ablett Swan JPK Dangerfield
Minson    *                           Goldstein Kruzer                       Cox*
Martin Zorko Franklin           Bartel  JJK    *                           Walker Rockliff Stevie J




ubeaut

Quote from: wetDT on August 23, 2013, 11:02:07 PM
gonna be a tight finish in my final. Which def do i bring in to match it with shaws 122....can afford any def for my last trade.

def is Murphy Grimes  ______? VS Shaw (122) Dixon Hanley

Houli against GWS?

or do i go enright for a little safety??
Considering Houli myself.